Wedding Caterers in Brooklyn

Ivy

5.0 out of 5 rating

5.0

Jill, Darren, and the entire team at Jillicious were a class act. When we went in for our tasting, Jill took care to design a menu that really reflected us as a couple and she worked with us to offer delicious, fresh seasonal options. Throughout the planning process the Jillicious team was very timely and took care of us as we navigated the rental process and made our final selections. No detail was left untouched at our final walkthrough and meetings, and we were very impressed with the insights and experience the entire team provided, especially pertaining to our venue which was an old house and had a very unique dining/serving setup. When it came to the night of, Jill and her team were so accommodating, flexible, professional, and kind throughout the day during setup and the evening of the wedding. We got SO many compliments on the food. The next morning I had people raving about it to me and texting me that they tried to bribe Jill & team for seconds! It was soooo delicious and I wish we could eat that short rib for every anniversary! My husband and I spent a lot of time on the dance floor and Jill even brought us our special desserts to enjoy a bite while we danced, just the nicest touch and a testament to how her team treats every couple they work with. The team at Jillicious is absolutely the team you want in your corner for such an important day, they are stellar caterers, but more importantly — lovely, caring people who will approach every second of your day with care. I'm so grateful my planner introduced me to Jill & her team and I would 100% recommend them to every couple in NYC looking for a catering service that truly listens to you, is not one size fits all, and sets a new standard for wedding meals! 

Sara

5.0 out of 5 rating

5.0

We had a fantastic experience with Jeff and his team at Bon Soir Caterers for our wedding at the Picnic House. First off, Jeff knows the Picnic House like the back of his hand so he was super helpful to us in the planning process. His pricing is also super transparent and he made sure we were saving money where possible while not skimping on anything important. And then as far as the food, everything came out tasting great and we got tons of compliments from our guests on the food. They also appreciated the large portion sizes! We highly recommend working with Bon Soir Caterers.

I can't recommend Eventfull enough! All the details of the evening were perfectly executed, we were so impressed by the professionalism and preparedness of the staff, and on top of that, the food was truly excellent and we had positive feedback from everyone we spoke to. 10/10 experience I can't recommend enough!

Michelle

5.0 out of 5 rating

5.0

Getting married at Purslane within Prospect Park Boathouse was an absolute dream come true. We celebrated our wedding there in August 2025, and the experience exceeded every expectation we had. Our guests couldn’t stop talking about what a magical, one-of-a-kind venue it was. Our guests are still talking about the food. Purslane’s cuisine was beautifully prepared, elevated, and delicious from start to finish. The seasonal menu and presentation reflected the same thoughtfulness we experienced during the planning process. The group tasting ahead of our wedding was such a fun evening, but the dishes on our wedding day were even better. There were ample options to choose from and seasonal flavors that rivaled any top NY restaurant. As foodies ourselves, this was very important to us and they delivered. Flawless across the board. The Purslane staff were exceptional. Professional, warm, and attentive to every guest. Many friends and family mentioned how cared for they felt, which meant so much to us. They of course treated us like royalty, but it made us so happy to hear our guests also felt and received that same level of service.

Shaun

5.0 out of 5 rating

5.0

Truly unbelievable price for what services are provided. Not only did Mimi's provide truly delicious food, but they impeccably set up our wedding venue and tore it all down at the end of the night. Mimi and her team were communicative, helpful, and incredibly transparent when they thought we were ordering too much food. Be sure to book with Mimi to have a delicious meal with unbeatable service!

I recommend Night Kitchen for any couple getting married! They were incredible from the tasting, through the wedding planning, and the execution on the big day. The number one compliment we received on the day (and have received since) is how amazing the food was. Along with amazing food, the staff is so kind and professional. Angela, who leads the events team, was incredible throughout the planning process and perfectly executed our vision for the dinner set up. We also threw her for a loop (adding a person 2min before dinner started) and she accommodated the issue without missing a beat. Overall, 10/10 experience and would absolutely work with them again!

Marj

5.0 out of 5 rating

5.0

Frank and the team at Bassett did an incredible job catering our wedding! There was so much food and everything was delicious. We got so many compliments on our food specifically! Frank is very easy to work with and he knows how cater a wedding perfectly. Portions are very generous, at both the tasting and the wedding!

We did not use Roberta's as our venue but as our caterer, and the experience was beyond exemplary. They provided us with canapes, meat and cheese platter, salad, and our main course and coffee at the end (Stumptown). They brought their portable wood-fired oven to the venue and were rapidly cooking pizzas for our guests which were then brought to their tables. The pizzas came out extremely quickly and no one was left waiting. The food was incredible. The canapes were creative, well made, and delicious. The salad was a huge surprise, it was easily one of our favorite items and was one we had picked more passingly with our main focus being on the pizza. The pizza itself was incredible which came as no surprise, it was either as good or slightly better than the pizza we had at the main Brooklyn location. I have been continuously receiving messages from friends and family complimenting us specifically on how good they thought the food was and how fun of a surprise pizza was as a main course. They also made additional pizzas for guests to take home again which was an unexpected bonus. The staff was extremely attentive and professional and were able to cater to some slightly unorthodox requests (they served our ice cream cakes) and did an excellent job. The entire process from when we booked them to the day of was extremely smooth and we were in constant contact with the catering manager regarding our preferences. This was an extremely smooth experience and one I would choose again in an instant.

The chef was so accomidating to our diet restrictions and gave us a such a variety of options. We actually got a special customized menu since budget wasn't much a a factor for us because we wanted amazing food!. The ice sculpture and raw seafood bar was such a hit! You don't see that everywhere. We added a couple specialty stations so my guests can have many options to choose from. Overall Clarendon Cuisines was the best choice for a caterer as compared to the others we had checked out.

Booked them last minute and was above and beyond expectations. I highly recommend their service for weddings.