We're here to help you keep moving forward, no matter what your plans are.

Shelter Island Wedding Venues

Browsing wedding venues is among the very first steps of planning your big day. But with so many wedding venues to choose from, how do you find The One? First, consider the style of venue you’d like: Garden or beach? Ballroom or barn? Then, read reviews of wedding venues in your desired city and select a few to tour in person. Happy venue hunting!

View By:
  • New York
  • Long Island
  • Shelter Island
  • Clear all
1 result:
  • List
  • Images
  • Map
1
The Boathouse Shelter Island
The Boathouse Shelter Island
5 reviews
· Banquet Halls · Shelter Island, NY

The Boathouse Shelter Island is a wedding venue located in Shelter Island, New York. This elegant, rustic venue at the Island Boatyard & Marina is ideal for couples who wish to have a destination-style wedding near home. The beautiful building the event space is based in dates back to the 1920s.... (Wedding Venues Shelter Island)

Anker
Anker
Restaurant Weddings | 2.7 miles from Shelter Island, NY

Anker is a waterfront restaurant located in the Village of Greenport. Between the upstairs and downstairs, the two-floor venue accommodates up to 100 guests.The main floor seats up to 40 people, while the second floor outdoor patio, set against stunning harbor views, seats up to 60. Both spaces are... (Restaurant Weddings Greenport)

Peconic Bay Yacht Club
Peconic Bay Yacht Club
13 reviews
· Boat Weddings | 3.2 miles from Shelter Island, NY

Peconic Bay Yacht Club is a premier wedding venue based in the town of Southold in New York’s Suffolk County. The beautiful yacht club, which is nestled in North Fork’s Peconic Bay within Long Island’s wine country, is the perfect setting to host the waterfront wedding you have always imagined. At... (Boat Weddings Southold)

1
Bridgehampton Tennis and Surf Club
Bridgehampton Tennis and Surf Club
21 reviews
· Banquet Halls | 11.7 miles from Shelter Island, NY

Bridgehampton Tennis and Surf Club is a coastal wedding venue located in Bridgehampton, New York. Surrounded by the Mecox Bay, Sam’s Creek and the Atlantic Ocean, Bridgehampton Tennis and Surf Club is the perfect setting to host the waterfront wedding of your dreams. The experienced event... (Banquet Halls Bridgehampton)

2
The ROUNDTREE, Amagansett
The ROUNDTREE, Amagansett
20 reviews
· Barn & Farm Weddings | 12.0 miles from Shelter Island, NY

Say “I Do” amidst the luxe serenity of the East End at The Roundtree, Amagansett, a new boutique hotel whose elegance embodies the natural beauty of its surroundings. A tranquil gem near the ocean and set against the pristine landscape of the Amagansett farmlands, The Roundtree, Amagansett offers an... (Barn & Farm Weddings Amagansett)

RGNY
RGNY
26 reviews
· Winery Weddings | 14.4 miles from Shelter Island, NY

**NOW OFFERING VIRTUAL TOURS** **Special Promotions being Offered for Couples Planning or Re-Planning their Wedding During the Covid Pandemic** **Elopement Packages Too!** Located on the North Fork of Long Island, RGNY is a destination for wine lovers, families, and those wanting to take in the... (Winery Weddings Riverhead)

1
Jamesport Manor
Jamesport Manor
7 reviews
· Mansion Weddings | 15.1 miles from Shelter Island, NY

Jamesport Manor is a vintage wedding venue located in Jamesport, New York. In the 1950s, Jamesport Manor opened as a very special place of celebration in Suffolk County. Since then, the event venue has specialized in making memories for couples and their loved ones as they celebrate one of the most... (Mansion Weddings Jamesport)

The Vineyards at Aquebogue
The Vineyards at Aquebogue
58 reviews
· Winery Weddings | 16.4 miles from Shelter Island, NY

The Vineyards at Aquebogue is a banquet hall and winery wedding venue located in Aquebogue, New York. Situated on the North Fork of Long Island, this elegant space offers verdant surroundings and carefully designed interiors. You can have a venue in the midst of a luscious wine country that will... (Winery Weddings Aquebogue)

2
Atlantis Banquets & Events/Long Island Aquarium
Atlantis Banquets & Events/Long Island Aquarium
71 reviews
· Banquet Halls | 19.6 miles from Shelter Island, NY

Atlantis Banquets & Events is a unique wedding venue located on Long Island in Riverhead, New York. Nestled on the banks of the Peconic River, this iconic waterfront wedding venue is a one-of-a-kind setting in the heart of Long Island. The dedicated event and culinary specialists at Atlantis... (Banquet Halls Riverhead)

Navy Beach
Navy Beach
11 reviews
· Restaurant Weddings | 19.8 miles from Shelter Island, NY

Navy Beach is a beach bistro-style wedding venue located in Montauk, New York. The seaside location is set out upon a pristine 200-foot section of coastline which is exclusively reserved for its guests. Couples who host their special event here will be treated with the highest priority while they... (Restaurant Weddings Montauk)

The Suffolk Theater
The Suffolk Theater
14 reviews
· Historic Weddings | 19.8 miles from Shelter Island, NY

The Suffolk Theater is a vintage wedding venue located in Riverhead, New York. This venue has a long history and offers a beautiful design with many upgrades. Past guests of the theater applaud the venue’s beauty, event coordination and dedicated staff. This theater is located in Riverhead, New York... (Historic Weddings Riverhead)

Solé East Resort
Solé East Resort
8 reviews
· Hotel Weddings | 20.1 miles from Shelter Island, NY

Solé East Resort is located in Montauk, New York in the Hamptons. Couples interested in having a destination style wedding close to home should look no further than this beautiful coastal resort. This private venue would be honored to host your indoor and/or outdoor wedding events on gorgeous... (Hotel Weddings Montauk)

Gurney's Star Island
Gurney's Star Island
11 reviews
· Hotel Weddings | 21.1 miles from Shelter Island, NY

Located on a private lakefront in the hamlet of Montauk, Gurney’s Star Island offers a timeless backdrop for your wedding and related events. Our indoor and outdoor venues are ideal for celebrations both big and small, from casual to black-tie. In addition to rooms, suites, and cottages, Gurney’s... (Hotel Weddings Montauk)

1
The Elegance Ballroom at the Residence Inn Long Island East End
The Elegance Ballroom at the Residence Inn Long Island East End
1 review
· Banquet Halls | 22.1 miles from Shelter Island, NY

The Elegance Ballroom at the Residence Inn Long Island East End is a wedding destination located in Riverhead, New York. The modern furnishings and muted colors of the ballroom and venue as a whole lend a stylish and chic atmosphere, ideal for a wedding celebration. The hospitality team strives to... (Banquet Halls Riverhead)

Montauk Lake Club and Marina
Montauk Lake Club and Marina
2 reviews
· Hotel Weddings | 22.2 miles from Shelter Island, NY

THE MONTAUK LAKE CLUB & MARINA Nestled midway down the protected eastern shore of Montauk’s safe harbor, the Montauk Lake Club was built in 1929 during the Carl Fisher era as part of the Montauk Dream, a plan of creating a playground for the rich and famous. The structures, grounds, and amenities of... (Hotel Weddings)

1
Giorgios Caterers
Giorgios Caterers
136 reviews
· Banquet Halls | 22.3 miles from Shelter Island, NY

Giorgios Baiting Hollow is a boutique, family-owned and operated wedding venue and catering company located in Baiting Hollow, New York. They pride themselves on their delicious cuisine, detailed approach to planning, and superb service. What truly sets this venue apart is their welcoming atmosphere... (Banquet Halls Calverton)

Oceanbleu at Westhampton Bath and Tennis
Oceanbleu at Westhampton Bath and Tennis
32 reviews
· Banquet Halls | 24.7 miles from Shelter Island, NY

Oceanbleu at Westhampton Bath and Tennis is a luxurious beachfront wedding venue located in the beautiful Village of Westhampton Beach in New York’s Suffolk County. Couples who exchange their vows at this elegant beach resort can experience true seaside glamour as the Oceableu offers breathtaking... (Banquet Halls Westhampton Beach)

2
East Wind Long Island
East Wind Long Island
170 reviews
· Hotel Weddings | 26.6 miles from Shelter Island, NY

East Wind Long Island is an upscale wedding venue located in Wading River, New York. Nestled on 26 lush acres at the gateway to Long Island’s North Fork, this magnificent estate is the perfect setting to host the wedding of your dreams. The experienced event team at East Wind Long Island treat every... (Hotel Weddings Wading River)

La Buena Vida
La Buena Vida
Banquet Halls | 31.4 miles from Shelter Island, NY

La Buena Vida is a restaurant hosting weddings in Moriches, New York. The venue offers couples a blend of sumptuous dining, friendly service, and a welcoming space in which to celebrate. It is conveniently located a short drive of JFK International Airport and within reach of downtown New York City.... (Banquet Halls Moriches)

North Shore Beach Clubhouse
North Shore Beach Clubhouse
4 reviews
· Historic Weddings | 32.0 miles from Shelter Island, NY

North Shore Beach Clubhouse is a historic wedding venue located in Rocky Point, New York. Situated close to the private beaches of Rocky Point, this venue offers space to host your ceremony and reception. Ideal for intimate weddings and low-key celebrations, the happy couple can feel as laid-back... (Historic Weddings Rocky Point)

1
Majestic Gardens
Majestic Gardens
40 reviews
· Banquet Halls | 32.5 miles from Shelter Island, NY

Majestic Gardens is an elegant wedding and catering venue located in Rocky Point, New York. This family-owned and operated property has specialized in producing outstanding wedding events on Long Island since 1995. The experienced staff at Majestic Gardens will go above and beyond on your special... (Banquet Halls Rocky Point)

1
Bellport Country Club
Bellport Country Club
132 reviews
· Country Club Weddings | 38.6 miles from Shelter Island, NY

Bellport Country Club is a Long Island-based wedding venue with stunning views of a championship golf course, the Great South Bay and Fire Island. With a wide variety of facilities to choose from, you’ll be able to custom design the wedding day of your dreams out by the seashore, nestled between the... (Country Club Weddings Bellport)

Sunset Harbour
Sunset Harbour
14 reviews
· Banquet Halls | 40.3 miles from Shelter Island, NY

Sunset Harbour is a full service wedding venue located in Patchogue, New York. They are devoted to creating a wedding day experience that you’ll remember for all of time. This charming venue on the water will give your guests stunning views and a spacious environment for you and your guests to dance... (Banquet Halls Patchogue)

Lombardi's on The Bay
Lombardi's on The Bay
11 reviews
· Banquet Halls | 41.5 miles from Shelter Island, NY

Lombardi’s on the Bay is an elegant restaurant and wedding venue located in Patchogue, New York that serves couples all over Long Island. They won “The Restaurant with the Best View” by Long Island Restaurant News, and specialize in seafood, steaks and Italian cuisine. Their goal is to make sure... (Banquet Halls Patchogue)

1
Villa Lombardi's
Villa Lombardi's
41 reviews
· Banquet Halls | 42.4 miles from Shelter Island, NY

Villa Lombardi’s is a wedding venue located in Holbrook, New York that has been redesigned to suit the modern couple with exceptional taste. This romantic Mediterranean Villa is unparalleled in service and quality, providing a beautiful setting for an unforgettable wedding. Facilities and... (Banquet Halls Holbrook)

The Old Field Club
The Old Field Club
77 reviews
· Barn & Farm Weddings | 42.8 miles from Shelter Island, NY

The Old Field Club is a waterfront wedding venue located in Setauket, New York. The rustic club has a unique style that attracts couples from all over New York. Impeccable service, delicious food, and a priceless view make this venue one to be desired by many. Situated along the water on Long... (Barn & Farm Weddings East Setauket)

Expand Your Search for Shelter Island Wedding Venues
WeddingWire celebrates love Learn more