Peconic Bay Yacht Club is truly a dream venue. The staff is absolutely fabulous. The GM, John, was extremely responsive, always accommodating, and truly made me feel like family. He completely sold the venue for me, I felt a weight lift from my shoulders because i knew he would be on top of anything that may occur on my wedding day, or leading up to it. Unfortunately, due to COVID i ended up canceling my June wedding. The venue was truly amazing through my cancelation process and i was so thankful after i had heard so many horror stories about brides from other venues. I wish i could of had my big day there, but i know in the future i will be sure to host an event there. If i could give them more than five stars i would.

Our wedding day could not have perfect, and it was largely because of John and his amazing staff. My (now) husband and I must have toured 20+ venues in and around NYC and LI, and we knew immediately when we stepped foot at the Peconic Bay Yacht Club to meet with John that it was where we wanted to get married and who we wanted to put our trust in --- and that is saying a lot coming from someone who doesn’t like giving up control! John was so helpful in the lead up to the wedding and on the day of. We didn’t have a wedding planner and I didn’t for a second regret not getting one; John and his staff created a seamless timeline for our day, which was executed to perfection. It truly was the most amazing day!

We got married in November, so there were also a lot of ‘question marks’ leading up to the wedding – What will the weather be like? Could we get married outside? John helped guide us along the way and even let us make the final call (inside vs. outside) the day before the wedding, which was SO appreciated! (And to be clear, there was no wrong option – the entire venue inside and out is spectacular)! It just so happened to be a beautiful November day, so my husband and I were lucky enough to get married on the beautiful outdoor deck on the second floor of the Peconic Bay Yacht Club – and it was magical! The venue and the views are just beautiful, especially around sunset!

We also can’t say enough good things about the food – the cocktail hour was a hit, and the dinner was fabulous. We had so many guests tell us how good the food was! Our favorites were the lobster rolls, sushi sliders, baby lamb chops and fish taco sips & bites for cocktail hour, and we selected the local bass (which was in season), the short rib, and the lemon arugula ravioli for our dinner options. We tried all three… and OMG – they were all so so good. We also had the afterparty on site (in the speakeasy-style basement), which was a hit. Late night chicken tendies and fries were the icing on the cake!

Looking back the standout was really the staff. Everyone was extremely friendly and helpful, and made the Peconic Bay Yacht Club feel like our home for the weekend. If you’re thinking of selecting the Peconic Bay Yacht Club for your wedding venue… DO IT! It will be a day or night to remember forever!!

PBYC is truly AMAZING! We had the most dreamy, magical and perfect day!!!

We were originally booked at another venue that canceled on us 6 months out. We found PBYC and immediately fell in love. We are certain everything happens for a reason and can’t imagine having gotten married anywhere but PBYC.

John was fantastic from the start - so patient in answering all our questions and making sure everything was exactly how we envisioned it. Heather, our bridal assistant, was THE best! She was so conscious of our wants/needs throughout the whole day and was ready to help with anything. We had absolutely no stress with PBYC. We gave them our vision and they brought it all together seamlessly. Every aspect of our day and everything leading up to it was 10/10 fantastic. We are still on cloud 9 from our perfect day. It really was a dream come true!