Nearby Vendors to Consider

About Cindy's Cakery, LLC

Custom Wedding Cakes

Cindy's Cakery is a custom wedding cake studio located in Gloucester, Virginia serving the Peninsula, Williamsburg, Mathews, and the Northern Neck areas.  With more than 10 years of experience we will strive to bring your sugar dreams to life and help make your wedding truly memorable.  Please feel free to browse our galleries here and at for examples of our work.  Email or call (757.377.0997) today for your personal bridal tasting consultation. We look forward to hearing from you soon!

Categories: Wedding Cake

Regions serviced: Hampton Roads

Follow Cindy's Cakery, LLC on

187 Reviews for Cindy's Cakery, LLC

out of 5.0
User Photos
todo alt text
todo alt text
todo alt text
Filter reviews by services used:
All Reviews
Consultations (14)
Delivery (14)
Private Tastings (14)
Custom Design (13)
Setup (13)
Cakes (12)
Cupcakes (2)
Fresh Fruit (2)
Groom's Cake (1)
Cake Stands (1)
Gluten Free (1)
Sort by:


Cindy was wonderful to work with! Our wedding date was bumped up 4 months and she still made it work for us so easily and professionally. Her cakes were delicious and we remembered how much we loved them from th tasting the same day as our wedding. Our guest raves about the flavors, especially the cinnamon roll cupcakes! I would highly recommend Cindy for any of your cake needs!!

View Vendor Response
Profile Picture Kendall, 10/27/18, 1 Review
Category: Unique Services (Other)

Cindy did an amazing job with our wedding cakes! We had a smaller cutting cake since I have a dairy allergy. The dairy free cake was delicious! Our guests loved the three different flavors we chose and even had an extra tier to take home after the wedding, which was eaten the next day at a post wedding family get together. I would recommend her to everyone!

View Vendor Response
Profile Picture Katie, 9/15/18, 3 Reviews
Category: Unique Services (Other)

Cindy and her cakes were absolutely AMAZING! From the very first contact, I knew that I would love working with her. We did our tasting and it was so hard to chose between the different flavors she offers-they all tasted wonderful. I showed her pictures of what we wanted and she made it come to life with a personal and special touch. I also asked her to make a surprise grooms cake and that was also fabulous & just what I wanted. Her cake was not only beautiful but delicious as well. Cindy was so kind and very nice to work with and I highly recommend her-you will not be disappointed!

View Vendor Response
Profile Picture Chandler, 9/8/18, 1 Review
Category: Unique Services (Other)

Cindy's Cakery, LLC Pricing

Wedding Cakes Pricing
Buttercream Frosting (Per Slice, Without Tax)
Starting from $5.00
Fondant Starting Price (Per Slice, Without Tax)
Starting from $6.00
Cake Prices Include:
Anniversary Cake
Cake Stands
Top Tier of the Cake
Cupcakes (Each, Without Tax)
Starting from $4.00
Prices Include:
Custom Cake Design
Set Up
Tasting - Private

Cindy's Cakery, LLC FAQ

Groom's Cake
Cake Pops
Dessert Buffet
Custom Design
Private Tastings
Cake Stands
Cake Cutters
Cake Toppers
Gluten Free
Lactose Free
Nut Free
Fresh Fruit
Health License


33 Photos


33 Photos
220x220 sq 1525720150 6b273cda14a8094b 1525720148 9c9aab44f0b6e0fb 1525720149435 3 img 1419
220x220 sq 1493766361997 gamez0795
220x220 sq 1525719938 82ffa1fee45fd0a0 1525719937 68fc065ece860c7c 1525719938326 2 lacey jack
220x220 sq 1493766843303 beckyjessereception1218
220x220 sq 1485820396803 dscf1001
220x220 sq 1485820754879 madelineconnor cellpic
220x220 sq 1432674771968
220x220 sq 1464747307674 larissa 1
220x220 sq 1383061759738 ashleyryan by photo
220x220 sq 1422928455537 rosemariejeff1
220x220 sq 1413924535490 wkp sss wcp03 10 14242
220x220 sq 1413921270084 tiltawhirl imagery williamsburg va wedding photogr
220x220 sq 1327354003006 dscf06711
220x220 sq 1372695934737 jessicajay front view
220x220 sq 1383062667671 suzyrayn
220x220 sq 1413921673484 cindy shields favorites 0006
220x220 sq 1413921717718 virginiaweddingphotographersmichaelandcarinaphotog
220x220 sq 1413923741158 saramatthew cell pic
220x220 sq 1413923932990 brd5990
220x220 sq 1413924079696 erinchristopher by brad
220x220 sq 1413926053110 cattlowery262
220x220 sq 1432684827226 zolty398
220x220 sq 1432687820959 464
220x220 sq 1432690023899 hrwpzv 05 m
220x220 sq 1437175848974 carisa alex wedding 0796
220x220 sq 1505185599219 annatravis by caiti garter photog
220x220 sq 1505185668824 lindsay by tracy saunders photography
220x220 sq 1505185713765 parkerwedding 9454
220x220 sq 1505185757192 haleyandjoshblog0595
220x220 sq 1505186291915 cindy shields favorites 0012
220x220 sq 1505186500870 erinmatt
220x220 sq 1505186706416 mishadaniel
220x220 sq 1525719897 01f365fe870cf1d6 1525719896 cd43464c0e5c7a50 1525719897754 1 d512c5312874b04fec

Professional Network & Endorsements

Cindy is not only an incredibly talented artist and baker, but a kind and wonderful individual. I cannot recommend her highly enough! We worked together on Kaitlyn's wedding (see Kaitlyn's review) and it was a true joy! The cake she created was gorgeous, delicious and a true focal point of the reception. She is now on my list of recommended vendors because of her thoughtfulness, professionalism and talent.

Cindy's cakes are awesome! Not only do they look good, they taste amazing! She is so professional and you will love working with her!

Beautiful work and delicious cake!

Cindy is such a great person! She is very personable, friendly and would be a great cake baker for your event. I personally use her for all my events small and large and everyone that bites into these yummy cakes she makes, I hear "mmmmmm" from every guests! She is always my top recommendation for cakes.

We had the pleasure of working with Cindy for a December 2014 Bride. The bride had given her a very specific inspiration photo. Cindy's interpretation of the cake was beautiful and the guests all raved about the varieties of flavors. We found Cindy to be very organized and easy to communicate with. Style Events recommends Cindy's Cakery.


Hayes, VA 23072   See On Map
757-377-0997 (phone)