If you are looking for something nice, affordable and not too fancy, look no further than Michael's Crafts Supply store. With over a zillion locations near NYC, you can't go wrong. We bought cute little flip-flop luggage tags for our destination wedding in Puerto Rico. It was perfectly themed. In addtion, we purchased bubbles, wedding themed sticker, a photo frame for guests to sign and the colored sand we would use during out Unity Sand Ceremony. Thanks to the detail and creative resources at Michael's, our wedding day could not be any more special!