Wedding Cakes in Indianapolis

View 37 more photos

Award winner

Sweet Escape Cake Company

4.8 (160 reviews)
Indianapolis, IN

Setup · Delivery · Custom Design · Dietary

Congratulations on your Engagement! If you're looking to make your wedding day extra sweet, you've come to the right...Read more place. Sweet Escape Cake Company is a family owned boutique wedding bakery nestled in the heart of Indianapolis, Indiana on South Meridian Street. At Sweet Escape Cake Company, we...

$250 starting price

Responds within 24 hours
View 23 more photos

Popular with couples

Sweet Revolution Bake Shop

Lafayette, IN

Delivery · Dietary

Sweet Revolution Bake Shop is a bakery in Lafayette, Indiana that creates made-from-scratch pies and sweets for weddings...Read more and other events. This business was founded by Sarah McGregor-Ray and her family in 2015. Since then, they have been committed to providing top-notch pastries and catering to...

$4 starting price
View 17 more photos

Popular with couples

Boone County Cake Co.

Lebanon, IN

Setup · Delivery · Custom Design · Dietary

Boone County Cake Co. based in Lebanon, Indiana, specializes in crafting delicious custom cakes for weddings and other...Read more special occasions. Their stunning creations are crafted in a small, scratch bakery whose team is passionate about using only the highest-quality ingredients in their treats. They...
View 15 more photos

Popular with couples

Molly’s Sociable Sweets

Plainfield, IN

Setup · Delivery · Custom Design · Dessert Buffet · Dietary

Based out of Plainfield, Indiana, Molly’s Sociable Sweets offers stunning cakes and cupcake bouquets for weddings and...Read more other special occasions. The powerhouse behind the company, Molly, is a talented artist with over years of experience in the industry. She now puts her skill to the test by creating...

$500 starting price

Responds within 24 hours
View 90 more photos

Award winner

Cake Me Happy

5.0 (46 reviews)
Carmel, IN

Setup · Delivery · Custom Design · Dietary

Cake Me Happy is a boutique wedding bakery located in Carmel, Indiana, specializing in bespoke cakes for the big day....Read more Owner Amy Murnane is a talented baker and decorator with years of experience. She whips up deluxe multi-tiered wedding cakes with delicate floral patterns and delicious...

$100 starting price

Save 5%

Responds within 24 hours
View 7 more photos

Butter & Batter Bakery

5.0 (3 reviews)
Lapel, IN

Setup · Delivery · Custom Design

Couples in Lapel, Indiana and the surrounding area can enjoy a unique, delicious, and aesthetically stunning wedding...Read more cake from Butter & Batter Bakery. From your initial consultation, you'll feel the team's passion for baking and desire to create a magical experience for your special day. Services...

$115 starting price
View 27 more photos

Classic Cakes

4.8 (185 reviews)
Carmel, IN

Setup · Delivery · Custom Design · Dietary

Classic Cakes is an award winning Custom Cake Shop serving Central Indiana. Everything is baked in house with premium...Read more ingredients. Highly trained decoators that can do anything you can dream of. For professional service, quality product and truely custom cake for your special day, you want to go to...

$4.95 starting price
View 19 more photos

Revolution Barbeque

Lafayette, IN

Setup · Dietary

Revolution Barbeque is a family-owned restaurant that provides catering services for weddings throughout the greater...Read more Lafayette, Indiana area. Couples who book this caterer can share a meal of comforting barbeque with their loved ones in honor of their special day. Cuisine Revolution Barbeque has...

$1,000 starting price
View 11 more photos

Pots & Pans Pie Co.

Indianapolis, IN

Setup · Delivery · Custom Design · Dessert Buffet · Dietary

Pots & Pans Pie Co. is an Indianapolis, Indiana-based bakery that offers freshly baked pies as a delicious alternative...Read more to wedding cakes. Owner Clarissa Morley proudly creates mouthwatering pies with in-season fruits and her own unique twist. Coming from a long line of bakers and business owners,...

$500 starting price
View 12 more photos

Red Velvet Dreams Bakery

5.0 (1 reviews)
Kirklin, IN

Setup · Delivery · Custom Design · Dietary

My name is Rebecca, and I am the owner and creator of Red Velvet Dreams Bakery, a wedding cake business located in...Read more Kirklin, Indiana. I have been in business for a little over a year, but I have been baking and decorating for almost four years and professionally for two years. I look forward to...

$250 starting price
View 16 more photos

Handel's Homemade Ice Cream

5.0 (1 reviews)
Carmel, IN

Setup · Delivery

Based in Fishers, Indiana, Handel's Homemade Ice Cream serves a delightful array of chilled treats to the local...Read more community. This business was established back in the hot summer of 1945 where Alice Handel created a beloved industry from her homestead. Armed with fresh fruits from her backyard garden...

$565 starting price
View 1 more photo

Aspasia Coffee and Bake Shop

5.0 (1 reviews)
Carmel, IN

Setup · Delivery · Custom Design · Dessert Buffet · Dietary

Aspasia Coffee and Bake Shop is a Carmel, Indiana-based bakery specializing in gluten-free wedding cakes and desserts....Read more This team would love to fill your wedding dessert table with delicious treats that your guests won't believe are gluten-free and a wedding cake that tastes just as good as it...

$250 starting price
View 13 more photos

Pelmear's Cake Creations

5.0 (2 reviews)
Auburn, IN

Setup · Delivery · Custom Design · Dessert Buffet · Dietary

Pelmear's Cake Creations is a wedding bakery based in Auburn, Indiana. Owner Susan Pelmear delights in designing and...Read more producing one-of-a-kind wedding cakes for couples planning their special occasion. Susan specializes in bespoke designs and boasts a diverse and impressive repertoire of cake...
View 46 more photos

Gracey's Goodies

5.0 (5 reviews)
Fort Wayne, IN

Setup · Delivery · Custom Design · Dessert Buffet · Dietary

Gracey's Goodies serves Fort Wayne area Brides as well as through out Indiana. Each cake is priced custom to your dream....Read more Along with cakes, Gracey's Goodies offers cookies, brownies, and much more for dessert tables of all kinds. ...
View 4 more photos

Miss May Designs

Indianapolis, IN

Setup · Delivery · Custom Design · Dessert Buffet

Based out of Indianapolis, Indiana, Miss May Designs is a cake designer that specializes in wedding cakes. Owner and...Read more designer Kristen Snyder has many years of cake decorating experience and is ready to make every couple's sweet treat fantasies a reality. With a variety of cake flavors and frosting...

$60 starting price
View 43 more photos

Itty Bitty Bakery

Knightstown, IN

Setup · Delivery · Custom Design · Dessert Buffet · Dietary

Itty Bitty Bakery, based out of Knightstown, Indiana, offers bespoke wedding cakes. The team here collaborates with the...Read more to-be-weds to design a cake that reflects their vision and personal tastes. They also take into account the design and atmosphere of your day, creating a confection that fits...
View 37 more photos

Maxine's On Green

5.0 (1 reviews)
Crawfordsville, IN

Setup · Delivery · Custom Design · Dessert Buffet · Dietary

Maxine’s On Green is a local family owned bakery and bistro in Crawfordsville, Indiana. Your cake should be made from...Read more the freshest and finest ingredients and the team at Maxine’s On Green will make sure that happens. They will create a cake that is tailored to your vision and needs for your wedding...
View 12 more photos

The Cakehole

4.9 (18 reviews)
New Palestine, IN

Setup · Delivery · Custom Design · Dessert Buffet · Dietary

About The Cakehole Hi, I’m Jovanna and I like cake. Well, I didn’t always like cake. You might even call me a “cake...Read more snob”. If it’s dry and crumbly…no thanks! So I started making cakes that I would actually eat (everything made from scratch). Then I decided that I wanted to bake and decorate my boys’...
View 21 more photos

Whisk Bakery and Catering

4.8 (12 reviews)
Greenwood, IN

Setup · Delivery · Custom Design · Dessert Buffet · Dietary

Laura's Bakery and Cake Studio is a locally owned bakery that specializes in made from scratch wedding cakes, cupcakes,...Read more brownies, cookies, and pastries. Our professional bakers and decorators have years of experience. We are located in Greenwood and serve all central and southern Indiana. We cater...
View 38 more photos

Grafton Peek Cakery

5.0 (1 reviews)
Greenwood, IN

Setup · Delivery · Custom Design · Dessert Buffet · Dietary

Cakes by Grafton Peek is a cake shop located in Greenwood, Indiana, that serves the Indianapolis region. This licensed...Read more cake shop creates unique, personalized cakes for couples that taste as great as they look. They heavily involve couples in the design process to ensure they have a gorgeous,...
View 11 more photos

Kim's Kakery, Bakery, & Café

4.7 (14 reviews)
Indianapolis, IN

Setup · Delivery · Custom Design · Dessert Buffet · Dietary

Kim's Kakery, Bakery, & Café bakes incredible wedding cakes for couples in and around Indianapolis, Indiana. The skilled...Read more team of bakers works with each couple to design and build their dream cake, from first tasting to delivery. Finely crafted cakes made from top-quality ingredients can be decorated...
View 12 more photos

Le Petit Gâteau

5.0 (6 reviews)
Carmel, IN

Setup · Delivery · Custom Design · Dessert Buffet · Dietary

Le Petit Gâteau is a charming bakery creating delicious and beautiful cakes, pastries, and desserts. The name, meaning...Read more “the small cake” in French, is indicative of our recipes being European-inspired with an American twist. Everything we create is meticulously crafted with artistic finishes that are...
View 49 more photos

Taylor's Bakery

4.9 (84 reviews)
Indianapolis, IN

Setup · Delivery · Custom Design · Dessert Buffet

Taylor’s Bakery is a 4th generation, family-owned and operated bakery. We just celebrated our 110th Anniversary on...Read more February 2023. We specialize in scratch recipe birthday cakes, wedding cakes, cupcakes, cookies, and specialty cakes.
View 28 more photos

Heavenly Sweets Cakes

4.6 (182 reviews)
Noblesville, IN

Setup · Delivery · Dessert Buffet · Dietary

NO LONGER TAKING WEDDING ORDERS. CANNOT DELETE THIS PROFILE FROM WEDDINGWIRE.

Wedding Cakes Deals That May Interest You

Celtic Harp Music by Anne Roos

5.0 out of 5 rating, 91 reviews,

Janousek Florist

4.9 out of 5 rating, 14 reviews,

Sweet Harmony Music

5.0 out of 5 rating, 351 reviews,

Harbour Club

4.8 out of 5 rating, 1 review,

The Granger Homestead and Carriage Museum

4.5 out of 5 rating, 11 reviews,

How much does a wedding cake cost?

Having a wedding cake at your reception is one of the biggest (and sweetest!) traditions. But what does a wedding cake cost? While wedding cake prices do vary depending on the size and style of your cake, the average cost of a wedding cake in the U.S. is around $500 with most couples spending between $300 to $700. While this may sound like a lot for a dessert, you’d be surprised as to how much work goes into creating a gorgeous wedding cake.

$ 117 or less Lower range
$ 534 Average cost
$ 326 - $ 750 Most couples spend between
$ 1,020 or more Upper range

Costs displayed are based on spend from thousands of couples who recently reported pricing for this service within their WeddingWire review. Pricing varies based on factors including, but not limited to, vendor’s experience, level of expertise, event guest count, date, and geographic region.

Which factors impact wedding cake prices?

Not surprisingly, the bigger and more elaborate a wedding cake is, the higher the cost of a wedding cake will be. A wedding cake featuring lots of design elements, including sugar flowers, fondant details, many tiers, and unique shapes, will cost more than a simpler cake with classic buttercream icing, a few fresh flowers, and fewer tiers. While your flavor choice likely won’t have an impact on your wedding cake’s price, requesting certain custom flavors may raise your wedding cake cost a bit.

What is the starting price of a wedding cake?

The starting price of a wedding cake can vary depending on the type of frosting you prefer. Cakes covered in fondant, a sugary paste-like icing, tend to cost more than cakes covered in buttercream (frosting made from butter and sugar). Fondant is more durable than buttercream (and it won’t melt in the summertime!), but it’s generally thought of as less tasty. The starting price of a fondant wedding cake is usually about $5 per slice, while the starting price of a buttercream wedding cake is about $4 per slice. Again, these wedding cake prices will vary even more based on decorations, size, etc.

What’s included in the cost of a wedding cake?

This varies from cake baker to cake baker. Usually, the cost of your wedding cake will include the cake itself, a design consultation where your baker will create a custom design just for your wedding, caketasting, delivery and set up. Some cake bakers will also include supplies like cake stands, cake toppers, and cutting utensils, though you may have to provide these on your own. And some wedding cake prices include an extra top tier of your wedding cake or anniversary cake for you and your spouse to enjoy on your first anniversary.

What types of desserts do wedding cake bakers offer?

About 54 percent of couples choose to serve an additional wedding dessert, aside from or in addition to wedding cake, at their receptions. Cake bakers may offer a variety of these alternative wedding desserts, including cupcakes, cake pops, cookies, pies, pastries, doughnuts, and more—the starting price for cupcakes is about $3 per cupcake. There are also groom’s cakes, which are a tradition particularly in the South. We’ve seen these groom’s cakes shaped like everything from sports paraphernalia to burritos!

When should I hire a wedding cake baker?

We recommend hiring a wedding cake baker at least six months before your wedding day—these vendors do tend to book up quickly! Start by reading online reviews of wedding cake bakers near you, and selecting a few to interview (in person whenever possible). You’ll typically have a wedding cake tasting after you’ve booked your baker, where you’ll select your cake’s flavors.

See other couples' reviews of Wedding Cakes in Indianapolis

Classic Cakes

4.8 (185) · Wedding Cakes · Indianapolis

Sweet Escape Cake Company

4.8 (160) · Wedding Cakes · Indianapolis

Cake Me Happy

5.0 (46) · Wedding Cakes · Indianapolis

Butter & Batter Bakery

5.0 (3) · Wedding Cakes · Indianapolis

Kimberly

5.0 out of 5 rating

Our wedding cake from Butter & Batter Bakery was a dream come true. Elizabeth created a stunning three-tier masterpiece with an old-school vintage style. It looked gorgeous and tasted even better! We chose vanilla, chocolate, and lemon. The attention to detail made it truly special, it was perfect from all sides. Our guests raved about it all night. If you want a beautiful, delicious wedding cake, Butter & Batter Bakery is the place to go!

Cake Connection

5.0 (4) · Wedding Cakes · Indianapolis

Fort Wayne Chocolate Fountain

4.9 (3) · Wedding Cakes · Indianapolis

Private User

5.0 out of 5 rating

We absolutely loved having Fort Wayne Chocolate Fountain at our reception. They were the perfect addition and made for a tasty and memorable appetizer for our guests while we finished up photos. They were very easy to get in touch with and have a very high quality product. It was really nice that the staff dipped the fruit and other goodies for our guests. This made for absolutely no mess. They have a bunch of dippers to choose from and some really fantastic homemade chocolate. I hope we will attend an event where they are present soon!