About Heavenly Sweets Cakes

Our Name Says It All

You deserve nothing less then the BEST for your special day.  We specialize in taste AND design.  No one else in the state comes close to our homemade Signature Butter Cream Frosting that "Looks As Smooth As Fondant."  We can create almost any design using our Signature Frosting in place of traditional fondant, and it will taste 100 times better.  Using only the purest, high quality ingredients and the same homemade recipe for the past 20 years has helped us grow to the reputation we have today.

We have an expanded line of offerings including Occasion Cakes, Cake Pops and Truffles, Cupcakes, Chocolate Covered Pretzel Rods, Cheesecakes, Cookies, Gift Baskets and more.  We're always baking up something new, and keeping track of the latest trends, colors, designs, and fashion.  Come see what we're up to today on facebook or twitter.

Many of our past brides will tell you that our cake was the one thing they recieved the most compliments on their entire wedding day.  We even have clients come in to order a small cake just because they love our quality and addicting flavors and fillings.  Don't take our word for it. Read our reviews.

If your not a "cake person"  give Heavenly Sweets Cakes a try and find out why you should be :) 

Our Name Says It All

Categories: Wedding Cake

Regions serviced: Indianapolis

Follow Heavenly Sweets Cakes on

155 Reviews for Heavenly Sweets Cakes

out of 5.0
User Photos
todo alt text
todo alt text
todo alt text
Filter reviews by services used:
All Reviews
Consultations (36)
Delivery (36)
Setup (31)
Cupcakes (5)
Groom's Cake (3)
Gluten Free (2)
Cookies (1)
Sort by:


We could not have asked for a more incredible wedding cake! Tanya and her staff at Heavenly Sweets definitely have perfected their name in the form of the most phenomenal cakes. My husband and I ordered a four tier white cake with buttercream frosting. We had grecian lace frosted on alternating tiers (yes, the "lace" was actually frosting placed on the cake) and a simple navy ribbon on the bottom of each tier. To say that the cake was perfect in presentation and taste would be an understatement. The staff at Heavenly Sweets were absolutely wonderful to work with and I would highly recommend them to any bride in search of her dream wedding cake!

Profile Picture Kayla, 9/1/18, 3 Reviews
Category: Wedding Cake
Services Used: Delivery, Setup

Our cake was phenomenal! I highly recommend Heavenly Sweets to anyone looking for an amazing tasting and looking Wedding Cake. Tanya was so wonderful to work with and made the process so easy. Everyone loved our cake. It looked amazing and tasted even better. I can't wait to get our anniversary cake! Thank you Tanya and Heavenly Sweets for helping make our day so incredibly wonderful!

Photo of Heavenly Sweets Cakes in Noblesville, IN
Profile Picture Deborah, 8/25/18, 5 Reviews
Category: Wedding Cake
Services Used: Consultations, Delivery, Setup

Heavenly Sweets Cakes FAQ

Dessert Buffet
Groom's Cake
Cake Pops
Custom Design
Private Tastings
Gluten Free
Lactose Free
Nut Free
Health License

Photos & Videos

37 Photos

My Photo Album

37 Photos
220x220 sq 1435757665539 kelleyhacklconfortiphotographyllcjz9a03482low
220x220 sq 1440525608051 siners photography mcauly wed
220x220 sq 1435757726373 kelly brian s wedding kellybrian 0179
220x220 sq 1439489061479 angel canary
220x220 sq 1444144000836 amanda nick s wedding 0184
220x220 sq 1324497265758 2092521015024493498045073798544992990163134300o
220x220 sq 1444144119517 brittan  evan coryjackiephoto 5
220x220 sq 1327690684550 heather8.27.11
220x220 sq 1444144058144 brittan  evan coryjackiephoto 1
220x220 sq 1327690725581 carlycalebwedding0244
220x220 sq 1443115938255 heavenly sweets cake resized
220x220 sq 1435757516723 monica  keaton 2
220x220 sq 1444144198285 brittan  evan coryjackiephoto 6
220x220 sq 1327690635300 2688711015025242812180156777680074549242417788n
220x220 sq 1324497295055 bairdwallisofp3
220x220 sq 1435757776378 kelly brian s wedding kellybrian 0182
220x220 sq 1440525546870 rachel brandon s wedding rachelbrandon 0215
220x220 sq 1444144233226 styled shoot kristin hornberger 2
220x220 sq 1440525584243 rachel brandon s wedding rachelbrandon 0226
220x220 sq 1327690762425 img1300
220x220 sq 1324497251133 21608819293749628531496580206321815514615161n
220x220 sq 1435757541986 393
220x220 sq 1435757672634 kelleyhacklconfortiphotographyllcjz9a03592low
220x220 sq 1435757633045 gs1a3154
220x220 sq 1435757508918 monica  keaton 1
220x220 sq 1327690993706 jennycrowe42xl
220x220 sq 1439489123473 styled shoot kristin hornberger 2
220x220 sq 1444829954123 111163569070194027538226463838563945037320o
220x220 sq 1281621311524 weddingcakeatscottishrite
220x220 sq 1327689752503 rogueartphotography
220x220 sq 1327689687487 rufflespicture
220x220 sq 1281621203195 garybrackettindplscoltplayercake
220x220 sq 1435757570653 397
220x220 sq 1324497144414 4079c
220x220 sq 1449596782706 amanda  jake 212 of 599
220x220 sq 1449596795880 amanda  jake 214 of 599
220x220 sq 1449596804499 amanda  jake 346 of 599


Professional Network & Endorsements

When you are ready to take a bite of the best cake you will ever have in your life, with the best person in your life.. please remember Heavenly Sweets. They are not only the best cake in Indy, but the sweetest, most professional to work with! Always a stunning job- almost too pretty to eat. But, trust me, you'll want to enjoy every last slice!

Heavenly Sweets is an amazing vendor to work with. Not only do their cakes look stunning, they taste amazing! You will be in wonderful hands if you choose them to be a part of your special day!

It's hard to believe that someone is so passionate about cake and the way it tastes, but that is the truth and Tanya Marshall is the best.

There are not enough words to express how amazing Tanya is! Her professionalism and love of baking is what makes working with her so great Let me also add that her cakes are SOOOOOOOOO Yummy! She really enjoys working with brides and helping them create magical cakes. It you are looking for the perfect cake, call Tanya!!! You will not be disappointed!


610 Hannibal Street, Noblesville, IN 46060   See On Map
317-770-9399 (phone)
Sunday: CLOSED Monday: CLOSED Tues - Fri: 9:00am - 5:00pm Saturday: 9:00am - 11:00am Private appointments available Mon, Wed - Saturday 9:00am - 6:00pm
Heavenly Sweets Cakes is a wedding bakery from Indianapolis, IN. We service weddings throughout the local area, including Noblesville, IN, Carmel, IN, and Fishers, IN. Heavenly Sweets Cakes is a professional wedding bakery that has been part of the Indiana wedding industry for 23 years. We specialize in wedding cakes, wedding cupcakes, grooms cakes, wedding desserts, special occasions cakes.