52 Reviews
Guest Capacity
Venue Setting

About Mustard Seed Gardens


Mustard Seed Gardens, nestled in the heart of Noblesville Indiana,  is a unique setting, rich in history with roots dating back to the mid-1800s. Located on the original Metsker Plantation is the “Olde Barn,” which has been completely converted to a one-of-a-kind wedding and event facility which offers old world charm and modern conveniences. 

The grounds have been meticulously restored and updated featuring picturesque landscaping and outdoor amenities including a bar, fireplace gathering area, pergola, water features and a romantically lit, rolling hillside for strolling under the stars. 

Originally, the property was deeded to George Metsker by Andrew Jackson, the seventh President of the United States. The rich and historical linage of the plantation property has been preserved, including the Metsker House, originally constructed in the 1800s. Designed to highlight a unique Italiante style architecture with ornate cornices and detailed trim work, the home stays true to its historical roots.  Today it serves as a semi-private wedding party lounge or prep area for events held in the “Olde Barn” and provides an excellent hideaway to take a break from the festivities.

If you are planning your special wedding day, family get-together or your next corporate event and are considering a unique venue that is rich in history, beauty and charm, you owe it to yourself to explore Mustard Seed Gardens.


"LIKE" us on Facebook!   facebook.com/mustardseedgardens

Categories: Wedding Venue, Rehearsal Dinner

Regions serviced: Indianapolis

Follow Mustard Seed Gardens on

52 Reviews for Mustard Seed Gardens

out of 5.0
User Photos
todo alt text
todo alt text
todo alt text
Filter reviews by services used:
All Reviews
Chairs (5)
Parking (5)
Wheelchair Access (5)
Bridal Suite (4)
Event Planning (4)
Event Rentals (4)
Set Up (4)
Furniture (4)
Lighting (4)
Tables (4)
Barware (4)
Linens (4)
Uncovered Outdoor (3)
Clean Up (3)
Lighting/Sound (3)
Decor (3)
Drapery (3)
Buffet (2)
Cocktail Reception (2)
Dessert (2)
Hors d'Oeuvres (2)
Outside Cake (2)
Audio Equipment (2)
Indoor (1)
Altar/Arches (1)
Centerpieces (1)
Glassware (1)
Sort by:


I'll start with WOW! The venue couldn't have been better! Perfect size for us; elegant, yet comfortable and cozy; pre-wedding home was charming; bathrooms were spic and span clean; grounds were beautifully and freshly landscaped; fire in the outdoor fireplace and water flowing in the waterscape was beautiful; and heaters outside for those guests who were chilly during the cocktail hour.

We started our planning a mere 10 weeks before the wedding date. I met with Bethany and Face-timed my daughter (bride) to discuss dates and high-level details. As the weeks progressed, Bethany was a gem! Her experience brought significant value to our planning. She was lovely to work with, accommodating, and attentive. The rentals available through the Mustard Seed were perfect, as the kids live out of state, and we had no need to purchase decorative items.

The Mustard Seed staff were friendly, helpful, and on-point for us. Having the wedding in November, and wanting it outside, was risky from a weather perspective but the staff were very flexible. They provided us with the ability to make the call for an outdoor or indoor wedding at rehearsal. We lucked out with a beautiful outdoor Fall ceremony!

Wedding day surpassed my expectations. Bethany coordinated with the Photographer(s), the DJ, the Caterer, the bartenders, and our group for the table decorations (pre-wedding). She insured we all had what we needed to make an unforgettable day of memories. We had no need to worry about any of the details. Even after the event, there are bound to be things left behind, staff had everything gathered up for us to pick up a few days later.

Our event was one for the books! Not only did we (parents of the bride, bride and groom, parents of the groom, and guests) have a good time, but the staff seemed to also be enjoying themselves. I would highly suggest the Mustard Seed Gardens as a wedding venue (or any other event)! We can't wait to see the pictures!

Photo of Mustard Seed Gardens in Noblesville, IN - An exuberant Bride & Groom!
Photo of Mustard Seed Gardens in Noblesville, IN - Bride and FOB, coming through the barn doors
Photo of Mustard Seed Gardens in Noblesville, IN - FOB validating everything is ready to go!
Photo of Mustard Seed Gardens in Noblesville, IN - PreWedding setup in the kitchen.
Profile Picture Michelle, 11/3/17, 1 Review
Category: Ceremony & Reception Venue, Rehearsal Dinner Location

Such a great team at MSG! I feel like we got our money's worth plus some! Bethany, Curtis and Wes are a fantastic team and really bring the professionalism and customer service. I could go on and on how amazing and beautiful this place is and that they put hard work and money into the modern updates and up keep of the venue. We are so happy and lucky they we found MSG and the team that comes along with it.

Profile Picture Lindsay, 8/12/17, 1 Review
Category: Ceremony & Reception Venue, Rehearsal Dinner Location

Mustard Seed Gardens Pricing

Reception Site Fee
Site Fees Include:
Bridal Suite
Clean Up
Set Up
Wedding Catering Avg. Price Per Person
Catering Prices Include:
Cake Cutting

Mustard Seed Gardens FAQ

Venue Highlights
Maximum Capacity
Guest Minimum
Event Spaces
Farm/Ranch, Historic, Mansion
Covered Outdoor, Indoor, Uncovered Outdoor
Maximum Capacity, Rehearsal Dinner
Guest Minimum, Rehearsal Dinner
Setting, Rehearsal Dinner
Covered Outdoor, Indoor, Uncovered Outdoor
Bridal Shower
Engagement Party
Rehearsal Dinner
Private Room
Private Section
Exclusive Venue Use
Public Seating
Bridal Suite
Clean Up
Event Planning
Event Rentals
Set Up
All Inclusive Packages
In-House Bar
In-House Catering
Liability Insurance
Outside Vendors
Pet Friendly
Preferred Vendors Only
Wireless Internet
Cocktail Reception
Family Style
Hors d'Oeuvres
Outside Cake
French Service
Audio Equipment
Aisle Markers
Aisle Runners
Chair Covers
Dance Floor
Tent Accessories
Chocolate Fountain
Wheelchair Access


48 Photos


12 Photos


12 Photos

Professional Network & Endorsements

If you are looking for the perfect and I truly mean PERFECT barn to host your big day, there is hands down no better venue than Mustard Seed Gardens! In addition to the barn, the venue holds plenty of outdoor space for games and activities as well as an amazing cocktail space! You will be in the best hands working with Megan and Bethany throughout your wedding plans! Go check it out today!

A special place to be married

Stunning facility!! So much space, beautifully landscaped, and they truly make each couple feel special.

The Mustard Seed in Noblesville is a great setting for a wedding ceremony under the gazebo and the reception in the huge barn. A different venue for couples who want something unique and different. Happy Ever After Ministers love presiding over ceremonies at the Mustard Seed. Rev. Ida-May Hanson Happy Ever After Wedding Officiants



77 Metsker Lane, Noblesville, IN 46062   See On Map
317-776-2300 (phone)
By Appointment Only
Mustard Seed Gardens is a wedding venue from Noblesville, Indiana servicing weddings throughout the local area, including Indianapolis, Lafayette, and Fort Wayne. Mustard Seed Gardens is a professional venue that has been part of the Indianapolis wedding industry since 2011 specializing in Barn & Outdoor Events.