Heavenly Sweets Cakes Reviews
Reviews
We're all about trust. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.
-
Kelly Sent on 05/25/2023
Wish They Weren't Retiring
Best cake ever! The almond cake with white chocolate ganache and buttercream was to die for! I am so so so sad they are retiring. -
-
Kerri Sent on 06/10/2022
Perfection and delish!
We ordered almond cake and a variety of cupcakes from Heavenly Sweets and they are incredibly good. Like beyond good and unlike your normal, average cake flavors. They provided great service and were so easy to work with. -
-
![Rachel]()
Rachel Sent on 08/10/2021The Cake is actually heavenly
The cake was beautiful but more importantly it tasted amazing. Just like it tasted at the tasting. My mom and I went around and tasted all the popular wedding cake bakeries in the Indianapolis area. Heavenly sweets was the only place with moist, flavorful, delicious cake. Everyone else was dry and a waste of our time. On my wedding day the cake was once again delicious and everyone talked about it and kept saying how good the cake was. I highly recommend the apricot creme filling! -
Mina Sent on 07/08/2021
Beautiful and DELICIOUS cake!!!
Not only did our cake look beautiful, but it tasted absolutely divine - extremely moist and flavorful!! We would definitely recommend them to anyone who wants their guests to love the cake! I can't tell you how many of our guests raved about the cake and asked where we had gotten it! We had almond cake with apricot creme filling - soooo good!!! -
-
![Sara]()
Sara Sent on 05/03/2021Delicious and Gorgeous!
We hired Heavenly Sweets to make our wedding cake and it was absolutely fantastic! It looked great and tasted even better! All of our guests raved about how delicious the cake was all night. I would highly recommend this company if you are still looking for your wedding cake baker! -
Eleni Sent on 05/03/2020
Highly Recommend!
My husband and I used Heavenly Sweets for our wedding cake on 12/28/19. Our cake was beautiful and looked exactly like the pictures I provided for reference. In addition, it was absolutely delicious! Our guests raved about the buttercream frosting and how tasty the cake was even after our wedding! Finally, Heavenly Sweets went above and beyond to ensure that all the details were perfect for the wedding day and provided a beautiful gold cake stand that matched our decor! We were very happy with how accommodating and easy to work with Heavenly Sweets was throughout the planning process and would definitely recommend their delicious cakes! -
-
![Ruth]()
Ruth Sent on 04/04/2020There Is No Comparison
My sister hired Heavenly Sweets for her wedding cake, and honestly, I don't even know why I tried anywhere else. After many cake tastings my mom, sister, and I went to Heavenly Sweets and finally got what we were looking for. My mom got out her checkbook before we even heard the prices. The experience is unparalleled. She knows so much about cakes and tells you what to try with what. I am a big advocate for letting the professionals do their thing and this was the only place that I went that felt like someone was there to help me choose the best possible cake. And the experience you have at the cake tasting is not a smokescreen, the cake is AMAZING. My husband does not like sweets and ever since our wedding night every time that he tries something he compares it to our wedding cake. IT WAS SO GOOD. I drool a little thinking about the fact that I get to have it again on our one year anniversary! I can't wait! Also, she was the only place that didn't push a crazy upcharge at me for wanting gold painting on the outside of the cake. Not to mention she made suggestions like which color to use, etc. Again, she is a professional and she knows her stuff. It was stunning, exactly what I asked for, and delicious. -
-
![Nicole]()
Nicole Sent on 02/02/2020Best cake ever!
Our wedding cake and cupcakes from Heavenly Sweets was amazing! It was the best cake I have ever had and it looked great too! I would highly recommend them to anyone and I can't wait to go back for more of their delicious cupcakes. -
-
Caitlin Sent on 01/30/2020
Best cake ever!
This was one of the best cakes I have every had. We had two flavors Pumpkin Spice, and her butter flavor, and every person I've talked to who ate the cake LOVED them! I've had multiple people tell me they were going to show up at my house on our anniversary (as she offers an anniversary cake with the purchase of a wedding cake instead of having to freeze the top) so they can have more! Not only did the cake taste absolutely AMAZING, her decorating skills are awesome. My cake was absolutely stunning, I will just stare are the pictures of it. I could not recommend Heavenly Sweets more! Writing this makes me want to go there now and get more cake or any of her delicious deserts! :) -
-
Marissa Sent on 01/30/2020
Wonderful!
We live in Cleveland but were getting married in Indianapolis. Heavenly Sweets worked with us over the phone and with the assistance of our local friends to make sure that our cake was exactly what we were looking for! In a day full of stress, Heavenly Sweets made sure that we had one less thing to worry about! The cake was beautiful and absolutely delicious! -
-
Kara Sent on 01/30/2020
Beyond Perfection
My wedding cake was fantastic! It was unique and one of a kind. I had so many compliments on my cake tasted as well (fantastic!). Honestly, my cake was much more than I could have ever imagined. -
-
![Maria]()
Maria Sent on 01/09/2020The most DELICIOUS wedding cake!
Heavenly Sweets cannot be beat! We had their white almond cake for our wedding and received SO many compliments on it! Great flavor and the buttercream frosting is to die for. You get the polished look of fondant without the gross taste! Tanya was great to work with! Can't recommend them enough! -
-
![Brittany]()
Brittany Sent on 01/06/2020Best cake ever!
The cake was beautiful and exactly what I wanted. It was also the most delicious cake I have ever had! Customer service was great through the whole process. The tasting experience was so helpful. She had all the parts separate and walking us through tasting the various combinations. We ended up with the golden butter cake with caramel filling and chocolate cake with raspberry filling. We will definitely be getting an anniversary cake from here! -
-
Sue S. Sent on 02/06/2019
Delectable!
Our wedding cake 9 years ago is still talked about by many guests. It was gorgeous and tasted incredible. So we ordered a 1 st birthday cake along with a mini duplicate smash cake for our son. We asked for a cake that looked like a stack of pancakes for our lumberjack theme. It was so realistic we had people ask why we served pancakes, lol. Definitely our go to for special occasions! -
-
![Molly]()
Molly Sent on 12/01/2018Amazing cake!
I didn't want to spend the money on the cake but I finally caved. It was SO worth the money! It was not only beautiful but also delicious! I had many guests tell me it was one of the best cakes they've had! -
![Keri]()
Keri Sent on 11/18/2018Simply delicious!
Heavenly Sweets did an amazing job with our wedding cakes. In my opinion, their cake is the best tasting cake in the greater Indianapolis area and 100% percent worth it!! -
Deborah Sent on 08/29/2018Our cake was phenomenal! I highly recommend Heavenly Sweets to anyone looking for an amazing tasting and looking Wedding Cake. Tanya was so wonderful to work with and made the process so easy. Everyone loved our cake. It looked amazing and tasted even better. I can't wait to get our anniversary cake! Thank you Tanya and Heavenly Sweets for helping make our day so incredibly wonderful!
-
-
Robin Sent on 08/18/2018Tanya was the nicest baker to work with. She met us outside of normal business hours for a tasting to accommodate my daughter who lived out of town. The cake design was custom made for our tastes, with different cake, fillings and icing options for each tier. The cake was terrific!
-
-
Emily Sent on 12/11/2017Delicious cake! It was made exactly as requested. The team was wonderful to work with!
-
-
Rosa Sent on 12/03/2017The staff is very nice. My cake was beautiful and delicious. Everyone loved the cake!
-
-
![HisBlackbird]()
Awbrey Sent on 10/15/2017As always (we are frequent consumers of Tanya and Chris's delicious work), Heavenly Sweets had the perfect, perfect cake, all around. We had a small cutting cake, and cupcakes, for our reception. The flavor mix was FLAWLESS, and the cutting cake was EXACTLY what we wanted! Beautifully set up and put together, DELICIOUS - our guests were RAVING about it. It's honestly a wonder we had any left over, though we had a small number left (more for Anthony, though!!), because we had a lot of return cupcakers, haha. They were beautiful and tasty and the cupcake tower was perfect. Everything was just as we had hoped, and then some. Thank you SO MUCH for making our wedding day delicious!! -
![Destinay]()
Destinay Sent on 10/03/2017We had bud luck with cake vendors, either they double booked or something else occurred. So we were about 2 months away from our big day, terrified that we wouldn't find a cake vendor. We went in for a consultation and the owner took great care of us and we booked that day! We had so many of our guest come up to us and ask "where did we get the cake, it is amazing!?" Thank you for making our wedding day special!! -
![Ashley]()
Ashley Sent on 08/27/2017From our first consultation meeting, to the day of the wedding, every interaction with Heavenly Sweets was professional and helpful. At our consultation, we tried out different flavors of cake (amazing!) and discussed what we would like our cake to look like. Even though she had never done a cake like ours before, she was ready to take on the challenge! Our cake arrived on-time and just as beautiful as we envisioned. Many guests commented on how beautiful the cake looked and how delicious it was. This is hands down the best cake I've ever had! -
![Kimberly]()
Kimberly Sent on 03/08/2017I dreamed of the day when I could have Heavenly Sweets make my wedding cake...and she delivered! I just wish I had a bigger piece at the wedding. :-) Looking forward to the 1 year anniversary so we can order another one. -
![Tiffany]()
Tiffany Sent on 01/19/2017We absolutely LOVED our cake from Heavenly Sweets! Hands down, THEE best wedding cake in the Indy metro area. And not only was it beautifully decorated just as we requested, but it tasted amazing and the guests were all raving about how great it was. Thank you for creating our dream cake!!! -
![Chandra]()
Chandra Sent on 06/26/2014They have the best cake I've ever tasted and wonderful customer service. We actually received several comments from our wedding guests that it was the best cake they'd ever had! -
![Rebecca]()
Rebecca Sent on 07/24/2013Wow!! Our guests have not stopped raving about the cake! Worth every penny! -
User1191799 Sent on 06/07/2013Our groom's cake was incredible! The only thing more incredible was Karen and all of the staff at Heavenly Sweets. We planned from out of town, and I had actually scheduled pick up on the wrong day-- they made it for me 24 hours earlier than planned! I can't recommend them enough. We drove 40 miles for this cake-- and it was worth every inch. It was delicious and beautifully decorated-- exactly what I had envisioned for my husband! -
User1176697 Sent on 05/28/2013As part of the wedding planning, I was really looking forward to doing cake tastings. I was only disappointed because I didn't do anymore tastings after I met with Heavenly Sweets Cakes. They were so nice during the consultation and they have the best tasting cake around. Even though I am not a sweets person, I could not wait to eat their cake on my wedding. Their cake is so moist and their butter cream is awesome. Their cakes are not only delicious, but beautiful as well. It's hard to get this combination right! -
![User5880036]()
User5880036 Sent on 04/29/2013God bless Heavenly Sweets for braving the extensive flooding to get my cake to our reception (even on time)!! It was both beautiful and delicious. I couldn't be happier!
(Plus, we got a couple of good deals from them! Because we ordered the same day as our tasting, we got to use an antique silver cake stand at the reception for FREE. AND because we got a larger cake (~150 guests), we get a FREE cake on our 1-year anniversary! :D Sweet!)
Are you interested?
Are you interested?