Skip to main content
Weddings
ARE YOU A VENDOR?
Milk Bar
Milk Bar
Strawberry lemon | Credit: redfield photo
Strawberry lemon | Credit: redfield photo
Large three tier multi flavor | credit: ryon lockhart photo
Large three tier multi flavor | credit: ryon lockhart photo
Four tier birthday cake | credit: sasithon pooviriyaku photo
Four tier birthday cake | credit: sasithon pooviriyaku photo
Six tier cake multi flavor | credit: roey yohai photo
Six tier cake multi flavor | credit: roey yohai photo
Four tier cake in apple pie | credit: julie paisley photo
Four tier cake in apple pie | credit: julie paisley photo
Six tier cake ombre multi flavor | credit: wilde scout photo
Six tier cake ombre multi flavor | credit: wilde scout photo
Four tier cake in chocolate malt | credit: lilian haidar photo
Four tier cake in chocolate malt | credit: lilian haidar photo
Small three tier cake in birthday | credit: brindamour photo
Small three tier cake in birthday | credit: brindamour photo
Six tier cake multi flavor | photo: chellise michael photo
Six tier cake multi flavor | photo: chellise michael photo
Multi flavor cake | credit: jessica schmitt photo
Multi flavor cake | credit: jessica schmitt photo
Chocolate malt truffles | credit: milk bar press
Chocolate malt truffles | credit: milk bar press
Cornflake chocolate chip marshmallow cookie | credit: milk bar press
Cornflake chocolate chip marshmallow cookie | credit: milk bar press
Birthday cake truffles | credit: milk bar press
Birthday cake truffles | credit: milk bar press
Whole crack pies | credit: gabriele stabile
Whole crack pies | credit: gabriele stabile
Cookies
Cookies
Cookie baking mixes | credit: milk bar press
Cookie baking mixes | credit: milk bar press
Chocolate malt cake truffles | credit: milk bar press
Chocolate malt cake truffles | credit: milk bar press
Birthday cake truffles | credit: milk bar press
Birthday cake truffles | credit: milk bar press
Crack pie slice pillow box packaging | credit: milk bar press
Crack pie slice pillow box packaging | credit: milk bar press
Cookie gift tins & birthday truffle dozen | credit: milk bar press
Cookie gift tins & birthday truffle dozen | credit: milk bar press
Milk Bar
Milk Bar
Milk Bar
Milk Bar
Milk Bar
Milk Bar
Milk Bar
Milk Bar
Milk Bar
Milk Bar
Milk Bar
Milk Bar
Milk Bar
Milk Bar
Milk Bar
Milk Bar
Milk Bar
Milk Bar

Interested in this vendor?

Untiered 14 inch cakes | credit: one night cereus

About

*IMPORTANT 2021 UPDATE -- MILK BAR WEDDINGS DISCONTINUED *

The Milk Bar weddings offering has been discontinued due to the ongoing impact of the COVID-19 pandemic. That being said, you can still celebrate your event with Milk Bar!

Please visit our website, milkbarstore.com, for a selection of classic untiered 6“ or 10” cakes & supplemental desserts for your event – perfect for a small to medium sized celebration or digital at-home wedding! Pro tip -- place untiered cakes on decorative cake stands to incorporate some added height to your dessert table!

Thank you so much for thinking of Milk Bar for your celebration. We hope you will consider celebrating with classic untiered cakes this year, which will still WOW your guests -- no matter the size!

If you have any questions, please direct them to our support team at help@milkbarstore.com.

Best wishes for a safe & healthy year,

Team Milk Bar

illustration popular

Vendors you may like

See other vendors that are popular with couples right now

Mia's Bakery
Green Ombre
Painted Bird cake
Vintage Wedding Cake
Mia's Bakery
5.0 (1) ·
Brooklyn, NY
Firefly Cake Design
Midsummer flower birthday cake
Four tier wedding cake
Midsummer birthday cake
Firefly Cake Design
5.0 (4) ·
Brooklyn, NY
$50 starting price
Sucre Nu Cake Company
Sucre Nu Cake Company
Sucre Nu Cake Company
Sucre Nu Cake Company
Sucre Nu Cake Company
5.0 (1) ·
Brooklyn, NY
$600 starting price
Sugar Butter Chocolate
Sugar Butter Chocolate
Floral wedding cake
Creative cupcakes
Sugar Butter Chocolate
5.0 (2) ·
Brooklyn, NY
$350 starting price
Crave & Crumb LLC
Crave & Crumb LLC
Crave & Crumb LLC
Crave & Crumb LLC
Crave & Crumb LLC
Bronx, NY
$250 starting price

Frequently asked questions

What types of desserts do you provide?

Cookies
Croquembouche
Dessert Buffet

What services do you provide?

Custom Design
Delivery
Tastings - Private

Are you licensed by the state health department?

Yes

Reviews of Milk Bar

Write a review
Write a review
Milk Bar - 1
Milk Bar - 2
Milk Bar - 3
+5 User photos
Milk Bar - 4
D
Dan Sent on 12/07/2019
5 out of 5 rating

Same price but 10x better of an impression

Had Milk Bar ship us three 10 inch cakes for our wedding of 130 people and people are still talking about our cake... Was similarly priced as a custom wedding cake but 10x more memorable. They were also incredible responsive/easy to work with and shipped it to our caterer to store and deliver!
Bailey
Bailey Sent on 07/20/2019
5 out of 5 rating

Delicious and affordable!

Instead of ordering a traditional wedding cake, we ordered 5 assorted Milk Bar cakes in varying sizes to create a dessert bar style, and our guests loved it. We definitely ordered more cake than our vendor recommended and we barely had any leftover because everyone loved the cakes that much. It was absolutely more affordable than a standard wedding cake and the flavors were much more delicious!
Rachel
Rachel Sent on 06/04/2019
5 out of 5 rating

Perfect cake!

We had 3 cakes at our wedding, one of which was a MilkBar birthday cake. It looked so good!! The staff communicated within 24 hours via email for the entire ordering process, payment was easy, and for the size of cake we ordered pricing was not outrageous. Cake arrived on time and as described and was delicious!
Stacey
Stacey Sent on 03/27/2019
5 out of 5 rating

Delicious Birthday Cake flavor!

The great thing about Milkbar is that they are consistently delicious. We ordered a smaller version of our cake as an excuse to just eat cake, and see how it delivered. It is packaged well and there was no damage to the cake after arrival. It was still cold when we unwrapped the package, and still just as tasty. We look forward to receiving our wedding cake!
M
Maria Sent on 01/02/2019
5 out of 5 rating

Amazing cake!

Loved having Milk for our wedding. We were looking into different options but MIlk had the widest variety, it was easy to try the flavors and they delivered directly to the venue. We ordered 2 flavors: German Chocolate and Chocolate chip and it was so good we didn't even get a chance to take some home. If in doubt, just go to one of their stores and try anything, it is all delicious!
Samantha
Samantha Sent on 11/01/2018
5 out of 5 rating

Milk Bar is the Best

We have been big Milk Bar fans for years so when we began to plan our wedding, we knew exactly where to go to order our wedding cake. Milk Bar’s wedding cakes are not only incredibly gorgeous, unique and whimsical- they are also so delicious, it’s like eating magic clouds. People are still raving about our wedding cake and we (luckily) saved the top layer to eat on our anniversary… ok… truth be told, we’ve definitely had a few bites of it already. It’s just too delicious! Do yourself a favor and go with Milk Bar for your wedding cake!
  • Milk Bar - 5
  • Milk Bar - 6
  • Milk Bar - 7
R
Rebecca Sent on 10/14/2018
5 out of 5 rating
We ordered 3 untiered cakes - Birthday cake, German chocolate, and Double chocolate cakes. Milk Bar was super responsive and helpful in creating the order and the size. The cakes looked beautiful day of and were DELICIOUS! The guests loved the cakes! Many people told me they ate 3 pieces that night! I would highly recommend ordering them for your wedding!!
K
Kate Sent on 07/24/2018
5 out of 5 rating
A Milk Bar wedding cake, what more could you want? I got married in June, and the cake was delivered and presented beautifully. No tilting, nothing melting, it was the highlight of my wedding night. Grace was so easy to work with, and was so flexible as I changed my mind a bunch of times. i highly recommend Milk Bar's wedding cake.
  • Milk Bar - 8
  • Milk Bar - 9
A
Ashley Sent on 06/29/2018
5 out of 5 rating
I love all of Milk Bar's treats/goodies and my wedding cake was no exception! It was beautiful and delicious. Grace was an absolute pleasure to work with.
  • Milk Bar - 10
M
Mandy Sent on 09/16/2017
5 out of 5 rating
We knew we wanted a Milk Bar cake and were thrilled with it! We ordered a tasting and decided on four flavors for a four-tiered cake, and ordered a separate sheet cake just to be sure we had plenty. It looked and tasted amazing! We love that we can stop by to get a little cake on our anniversary and relive the experience without having to store it in the freezer for a year!
We're all about trust. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.
Read all reviews

Awards

81
WeddingWire Couples' Choice Awards 2020 Winner
WeddingWire Couples' Choice Awards 2019 Winner
WeddingWire Couples' Choice Awards 2018 Winner
WeddingWire Couples' Choice Awards 2017 Winner
WeddingWire Couples' Choice Awards 2016 Winner

Explore other vendors in your area

Find the most recommended vendors and Couples' Choice Award winners.

See vendors

Map

Addresses map
Cakes Greater New York City Metro
Cakes Brooklyn
Next Wedding Cakes: Patisserie Tomoko

Other vendors in Greater New York City Metro for your wedding

Wedding Vendors