Cutie Pies NYC is a Brooklyn-based, artisanal pie bakery specializing in delicious, handcrafted pies, tarts, cookies, cakes and more – including an award-winning coconut cream pie and Canadian maple butter tart (‘Best Overall’ and ‘First Place’ at the 2011 Led Zeppelin Pie Contest at Brooklyn's City Reliquary). Everything is made by hand, with all-natural ingredients; whenever possible, we use organic and locally-sourced materials.

With so may discerning brides-to-be seeking out custom desserts and alternatives to wedding cake, pies — especially our three-inch personal pies and 1.5-inch hors-d'ouvre pies — are becoming an increasingly popular choice!

Bespoke orders are welcome – we can create a delectable dessert to your exact specifications, and can accommodate gluten-free, vegan, and sugar-free requests to please everyone on your guest list.

If your event is near New York City, you have access to a greater variety of pies (most notably, our bestselling Guinness fudge-Irish cream and prize-winning coconut cream flavors); available for local delivery or weekend pick-up at neightborhood markets. Follow us for local event dates and times.

Don't see what you're craving in our shop? Browse our gallery for ideas, let your imagination run riot, and feel free to email any questions or requests!