About Bethel Bakery

Baking Life Sweeter Since 1955

Bethel Bakery is a family owned bakery that has been baking special memories for over 58 years.  With our signature French Buttercream icing, moist cake, and high quality service, we are greatly recognized as "The Cake Place."  We offer dessert cakes, individual cakes, and cakes for all occasions, however, wedding cakes enable us to become part of a very special occasion.  We have cake styles from simple, elegant, and traditional to whimsical and fun.  Having graciously attended thousands of wedding celebrations, we look forward to the opportunity of being a part of yours.


Contact us today!  412-835-6658 ext 4  wedding@bethelbakery.com 

Categories: Wedding Cake

Regions serviced: Pittsburgh

Follow Bethel Bakery on

233 Reviews for Bethel Bakery

out of 5.0
User Photos
todo alt text
todo alt text
todo alt text
Filter reviews by services used:
All Reviews
Cakes (27)
Delivery (24)
Private Tastings (24)
Consultations (21)
Custom Design (20)
Setup (19)
Cookies (7)
Cupcakes (2)
Groom's Cake (2)
Dessert Buffet (1)
Pastries (1)
Sort by:


The tasting was great, love the presentation.

Profile Picture Darlene, 8/25/18, 4 Reviews
Category: Wedding Cake
Services Used: Consultations, Private Tastings, Cakes, Cookies

Cake was delicious and everyone was so nice and easy to work with!

Photo of Bethel Bakery in Bethel Park, PA
Photo of Bethel Bakery in Bethel Park, PA
Photo of Bethel Bakery in Bethel Park, PA
Profile Picture Victoria, 7/21/18, 5 Reviews
Category: Wedding Cake

Bethel Bakery Pricing

Wedding Cakes Pricing
Buttercream Frosting (Per Slice, Without Tax)
Starting from $3.50
Cake Prices Include:
Anniversary Cake
Cupcakes (Each, Without Tax)
Starting from $2.25
Prices Include:
Set Up
Tasting - Private

Bethel Bakery FAQ

Dessert Buffet
Groom's Cake
Cake Pops
Custom Design
Private Tastings
Health License


61 Photos

Wedding Cakes

48 Photos
220x220 sq 1375819176637 diamonds and pearls email
220x220 sq 1511031282130 rose tip pleat
220x220 sq 1511031328751 gumpaste seashell with airbrushing
220x220 sq 1511031295401 version of teresa
220x220 sq 1511031262066 pure  simple on small stand
220x220 sq 1419260963691 audra pic collage
220x220 sq 1375822218144 ombre   fondant email
220x220 sq 1375822189997 ombre buttercream
220x220 sq 1375821139572 julianna email
220x220 sq 1511031450655 custom lacework with separation
220x220 sq 1375820575538 glitz glamour and mini rose
220x220 sq 1511031450453 cake lace with with gold leaf
220x220 sq 1375820891311 snowflake
220x220 sq 1511031288061 skim coat naked cake
220x220 sq 1375821272074 rosalina email
220x220 sq 1511031468521 buttercream cake lace with gumpaste roses
220x220 sq 1375822304652 twice as nice email
220x220 sq 1511031344209 fondant ombre pleat with ruffled tier edges
220x220 sq 1511033543289 tree stump with silk flowers
220x220 sq 1419260904778 emma email
220x220 sq 1419261005675 ella
220x220 sq 1419260984698 bc rosette
220x220 sq 1419261062070 non parell
220x220 sq 1419261080990 pure and simple with burlap
220x220 sq 1419261102423 vanessa black and white
220x220 sq 1511031237552 buttercream metallic dots
220x220 sq 1511031238877 blushing bride
220x220 sq 1511031245165 naked cake with fruit
220x220 sq 1511031370860 bc ruffle with ombre
220x220 sq 1511031459276 cake lace blush
220x220 sq 1511031359056 champagne ombre crystalized sugar with glitter
220x220 sq 1511031485971 cake lace with basecoat tint
220x220 sq 1511031527974 4 tier separated with fresh flowers
220x220 sq 1511031526971 gumpaste flower casecade 4 tier
220x220 sq 1511031549132 audra on 4 tier round
220x220 sq 1511031598857 fondant marble with gold leaf
220x220 sq 1511031598378 gold drip cascade
220x220 sq 1511031622647 gold scrollwork and quilting
220x220 sq 1511031675652 gold metallic texture cascade
220x220 sq 1511033504898 buttercream snowflake cascade cake
220x220 sq 1511033545497 tree bark cake
220x220 sq 1511033567282 birch tree with heart
220x220 sq 1511034491524 rosettes crystalized sugar with glitter and light
220x220 sq 1511034543100 sophia with colored roses
220x220 sq 1511034601364 cake stencil fondant covered up close
220x220 sq 1511034656915 cupcake stand with gourmet cc2
220x220 sq 1511034656848 buttercream ruffle cupcake set up
220x220 sq 1511034665717 cupcake stand with razzles

Grooms Cakes

13 Photos
220x220 sq 1511030905059 pittsburgh themed 10 10 15 cropped
220x220 sq 1353014078985 baseballtopemail
220x220 sq 1353014138462 hoagiecake
220x220 sq 1353014162872 golftheme2tier
220x220 sq 1511030820188 cheesesteak with crinkle cut french fries
220x220 sq 1511030819007 air force
220x220 sq 1511030845391 fish cake
220x220 sq 1511030865930 marine cake
220x220 sq 1511030885420 pittsburgh sports
220x220 sq 1511030920753 snow boarder
220x220 sq 1511030936284 star wars hans solo carbonite 10 2 15
220x220 sq 1511030949848 train
220x220 sq 1511030967734 tree stump

1 Wedding Deal & Discount

1511035016 b1edb94ab19290ee 1511031282130 rose tip pleat

Free Filling Promotion

$86.50 Value | Promo Code: FREEFILLING
Schedule a wedding cake consultation and place your $100.00 non refundable deposit to hold your wedding date within 7 days of the consultation to receive specialty filling free in your wedding cake. This promotion only applies to wedding cakes 3 tiers or larger and is not able to be used for wedding cakes that are provided through your venue. The value of this promotion is determined by the size and shape of wedding cake selected - $31.50-$86.50.

Professional Network & Endorsements

Bethel Bakery is one of our preferred vendors. They have an excellent reputation and deliver a quality product!

A family owned business with great tasting wedding cakes and cakes of all your desires. Our staff loves the moist and delicious wedding cakes that we tasted at various weddings that we photographed. We would definitely recommended Bethel Bakery to our clients or anyone that desires great tasting cakes. -John Lokmer - Lokmer Photography Inc.

A favorite bakery of ours, we recommend to many clients. The wedding cakes are beautiful and priceless!

I get excited when my couples tell me they have Bethel Bakery... Their cakes are works of art, but don't taste like art. They are so yummy. I tend to take more close ups of thier cakes as they are just georgous.



5200 Brightwood Road, Bethel Park, PA 15102   See On Map
412-835-6658 (phone)
Bethel Bakery is a wedding cake bakery from Bethel Park, Pennsylvania. We service weddings throughout the local area, including Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, Washington, Pennsylvania, and the Pittsburgh Airport area. Bethel Bakery is a professional wedding cake bakery that has been part of the Pittsburgh, Pennslyvania wedding industry for 57 years. We specialize in wedding cakes, desserts, and cookies.