Wedding Cakes in Madison

We LOVED working with Bloom for our wedding cakes. They don't do tiered cakes, so we did multiple cake rounds in multiple flavors (Pistachio Caramel, Lemon Vanilla Raspberry, and Vegan/GF Vanilla). All of them came out incredible, and our favorite was actually the Vegan Vanilla! Bloom was fairly priced, easy to work with, and made cakes we were proud to serve at our wedding. Thank you so much to the Bloom team for making our day even more special!

We loved working with Jennifer! Her pies were delicious, affordable, and she even offered to customize them for our wedding setting. (We were married under an oak tree, so she did specialty decorations on the tops!) She was easy to work with and very professional. I'd recommend her to any of my friends throwing a party or getting married!

Hubbard Avenue Diner provided an assortment of 10 cakes and pies for our wedding reception. The tasting was really fun - Ashley, the baker, prepared a big selection of cakes, pies, fillings, and icing for us to try out. We were hesitant to ask for much detail on the wedding cake itself, but she ended up doing a beautifully classic design with the icing and it was gorgeous. All the cakes and pies were labeled and dropped off on time, which made it very easy for our venue's staff to set them up for the dessert buffet. The prices at Hubbard Ave. are also very reasonable - all those cakes and pies for LESS than the cost of a traditional wedding cake. Hubbard Ave. asked us to drop off the pie dishes within a week of the wedding - and when I dropped them off, they gave me the $5 per plate deposit back in cash. Overall, a wonderful experience. Ashley is a very talented baker!

Madison Sourdough (MSCo Patisserie) did a wonderful job with our wedding desserts! Mo, the Patisserie Manager, was a joy to work with - extremely responsive, flexible, and accommodating of our requests. We did not want a traditional wedding cake, but instead a combination of our favorite desserts - cherry pie, french lemon tarts, and yellow cake - and MSCo Patisserie had no problem accommodating us. We were planning our wedding remotely from the East Coast, and they were so flexible in scheduling our tasting two weeks before the wedding date when we were finally in town. The tasting was wonderful, and Mo and the team were so flexible in making a few tweaks to the crusts/frosting at our request. They helped us estimate the perfect amount to order, and had them pre-cut/ready to go the day before the wedding. The price was extremely reasonable, and a steal for such high-quality. Our guests raved about each of the desserts - we just wish we had ordered a few more to nibble on in the days after! :) We highly suggest Madison Sourdough (MSCo Patisserie) to other wedding couples - you will not be disappointed!

We ordered several cakes and had a dessert bar at our wedding. They were all fantastic and beautifully decorated. People were asking days later if they could come over a d have left overs! It was a great addition to our day!

Emily

5.0 out of 5 rating

5.0

We did an assortment of donuts from a different bakery, and cupcakes from Batch for our wedding dessert table. Batch was super flexible and easy to work with, and the tasting experience was great (easy to pick up a box, and they subtract the cost from your bill when you order with them). Picking up the cupcakes day of was easy, and payment was straightforward. In terms of flavor, the midnight buttercream was a hit, as was the caramel. The cupcakes were generously sized, classically beautiful, and popular with everyone!

Kristine and Dough Baby Bakery were so fun to work with. My husband and I are not from Madison and were in town for a short weekend and Kristine accommodated a tasting at the time that worked best for us. They were also able to deliver and set up our desserts and it looked awesome. We got a small cake for my husband and I to cut and got an assortment of cupcakes, cookies, and bars for all our guests. They have so many fun flavors and options and everything is AMAZING! Everything went so smoothly and I think there prices are great also. We kept saying we wished we lived in Madison because we would be visiting Dough Baby all the time!