Skip to main content
Weddings

About

humble. sweet & savory pies: the modern alternative to fussy cake!

why humble?

[pretty]

cupcake-pretty presentation and soulful flavor—our pies are tailored to reflect your personal style and wedding day vision.

[delicious]

humble’s wedding pies are intensely flavored, jubilant, romantic, textural and just a little bit sexy.

[responsible]

humble shares your commitment to sustainability. Our pies are baked in compostable pie plates made from starches like tapioca and sweet potatoes; our plastic packaging is made from recycled materials; we purchase our ingredients from local farms and farmers’ markets, using seasonal foods to create pies with abundant flavorful ingredients.

our pies:

(lollipies )

Tantalizing pie bites on a stick, pleasingly packaged so that your guests can take a little bit of the revelry home with them. Wrapped in crinkly sheets of cellophane, they make refreshingly unexpected wedding or party favors.

(hand pies)

Beautiful handheld pies; crescent shaped like little quarter moons, these easy-to-eat treats can be appliquéd with simple shapes or monograms and stuffed with sweet or savory gourmet fillings.

(pinch pies)

4” round, hand-built, rustic freeform pies filled with luscious fruit fillings and topped with our signature flaky southern crust.

(petite pies)

Mouthwatering stacks of cupcake-sized pies, inspired by your wedding design. Topped with fluffy creams and toasted meringues or filled with juicy fresh fruits, these chic little pies will leave you wondering why anyone ever serves cake.

(traditional, full-sized pies)

A 9” orb of crispy, flaky crust cradling deliciously fragrant, seasonal fruit or cream fillings. Traditional, but tweaked for modern palates.

illustration popular

Vendors you may like

See other vendors that are popular with couples right now

Frequently asked questions

What types of desserts do you provide?

Pastries

What services do you provide?

Consultations
Delivery
Setup

What dietary needs can you accommodate?

Gluten Free

What special ingredients do you use?

Organic

Are you licensed by the state health department?

Yes

Reviews of humble. sweet & savory pies

C
Cora Sent on 03/21/2020
5 out of 5 rating

Easy to work with, thoughtful and professional!

We loved working with Jennifer! Her pies were delicious, affordable, and she even offered to customize them for our wedding setting. (We were married under an oak tree, so she did specialty decorations on the tops!) She was easy to work with and very professional. I'd recommend her to any of my friends throwing a party or getting married!
S
Sara Sent on 08/15/2016
5 out of 5 rating
My daughter wanted to have an alternative to cake for her wedding. Humble Pies came highly recommended to us. The choices were amazing and even less expensive compared to what it would have cost to have cake for 100 people. Humble Pies were able to cater a beautiful pies and tart buffet. We received may compliments regarding the taste and beauty of these pies!
K
Kara Sent on 12/02/2015
5 out of 5 rating
We purchased petite pies from Humble Pie for our fall wedding celebration and they were amazing. All the guests raved about the pies and loved having the options. Humble Pie created little pie labels for each petite pie so our guests knew which pie to pick. We ordered more pies than guests and provided small pie to-go bags and all of the pies were taken home.

Shelly was great to work with when planning and choosing pies and we enjoyed going to Humble Pie for a planning tasting.

We will not only be eating at Humble Pie again, we strongly recommend them for a wedding or other event!
C
Celia Sent on 08/19/2019
4.8 out of 5 rating

Best Pie I've Ever Had

We decided on pie instead of cake for our wedding, and Humble did such a good job. Multiple guests said it was the best pie that they'd ever had. The crust was amazingly flakey, and she had so many wonderful options for pie fillings. We got one full size pie and then a dessert bar of cupcake sized pies. We seriously recommend the chocolate bourbon chess pie and the seasonal apple pie. Some communication was a little slow, but overall the service was amazing and the pie was so, so good. Definitely recommend!
U
User2483860 Sent on 12/28/2015
4.8 out of 5 rating
Instead of cake we decided to go with wedding pie. We selected a variety of full size and mini pies (the size of mini cupcakes). It was a huge hit! Humble has standard flavors plus a handful of seasonal flavors. We went with a mix of four flavors so our guests could try them all. Many guests commented on how delicious the pie was and that it made for a welcomed change from wedding cake. Humble delivered the pies and set them and provided little labels with the pie names. They also had towers to rent to display the mini pies in a cute way. Shelly was delightful to work with. Our only regret is that we were so busy we didn't enjoy enough pie at our own wedding :)
We're all about trust. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.

Awards

5

Map

Addresses map
Next Wedding Cakes: L'Etoile

Other vendors in Milwaukee for your wedding

Wedding Vendors