Skip to main content
Weddings

About

Craig's Cake Shop is a custom wedding cake bakery located in Verona, Wisconsin that is licensed by the state health department. They have been creating stunning and delicious wedding cakes since 2000. They specialize in custom wedding cakes that truly reflect the personal taste of the couple and are cohesive with the rest of the event design. They also offer backroom layered sheet cakes as well as many small desserts for a dessert display: cupcakes, mini cream puffs, cake push-up pops, dessert shooters, cookie bars and cake donuts.

Services Offered
Before the big day, couples are invited to schedule a private and prsonalized tasting consultation for up to 4 people. This will give you the opportunity to try all of the flavors for cake, fillings, and frostings to create your custom menu! The tasting appointment and process also includes a custom design consultation for your display cake. To ensure everything moves smoothly, they will deliver and set up the cake for the celebration along with coordinating with your florist, reception venue, and wedding planner for all of the custom wedding cake details. Pick up options are also available for some orders. A fresh first anniversary cake is included in our custom wedding cake packages and can even be added on to pickup orders. We look forward to working with you to create a custom wedding cake and/or dessert order for your special day!

  • Woman-owned
illustration popular

Vendors you may like

See other vendors that are popular with couples right now

Frequently asked questions

Which of the following are included in the cost of the cake?

Anniversary Cake
Top Tier of the Cake

What types of desserts do you provide?

Cookies
Cupcakes
Groom's Cake

What services do you provide?

Consultations
Custom Design
Delivery
Setup
Tastings - Private

Are you licensed by the state health department?

Yes

Reviews of Craig's Cake Shop

K
Kristen Sent on 08/28/2022
5 out of 5 rating

Cake went beyond our expectations!

Craig’s Cakes did an amazing job creating our wedding cake and went above and beyond our expectations! We wanted to include figurines of two animals. We sent photos of what we were looking for and Craig’s Cakes hit it out of the park! Our jaws dropped when we saw how accurate the figurines were and how every little detail was accounted for. Our guests commented on how great the cake tasted and we didn’t have any left at the end of the night. The cake was extremely fresh and moist and the frosting was to die for. The cake was one of our most favorite details of the day and we definitely plan to purchase more cakes from Craig’s Cakes in the future!
M
Maria Sent on 07/26/2022
5 out of 5 rating

Delicious and Beautiful

I hired Craig's Cake shop to make the cakes for my daughter's wedding. We had three different flavors and they were all delicious.
The staff at Craig's communicated well with me, with my daughter and with the florist who provided the flowers for the cake decoration.
Excellent servuce and yummy cakes!!!
M
Matthew Sent on 04/10/2022
5 out of 5 rating

Delicious and Beautiful

Our desserts were truly incredible. The cupcakes we had were all delicious and looked beautiful! Our wedding cake was even more beautiful than we could have imagined. Craig’s was so helpful throughout the tasting/flavor choice process, and was great through the design decision making. Our cake was the perfect touch to our day! Thank you, Craig’s!!
Lauren
Lauren Sent on 04/04/2022
5 out of 5 rating

Tasty Cake!

We loved our cake from Craig’s! We definitely recommend it!
Lily
Lily Sent on 10/21/2021
5 out of 5 rating

Let Craig’s design your cake!

Elisa and Craig’s cake shop is the best!! I sent pictures of our invites and color scheme, and she along with simply glamorous designs made our dream cake! It was such a fun surprise not knowing what the cake would look like and seeing how beautifully it turned out. What wonderful designers! They even took the wax seal from our invites and put it on the cake! Not to mention how tasty all the cake and cupcakes were, especially the carrot! Beyond happy with Craig’s cake shop!
Margaret
Margaret Sent on 09/13/2021
5 out of 5 rating

Crain/Fedenia Wedding Cake review

We hired Craigs Cake Shop for our 4-tier wedding cake on August 28, 2021. Our cake was simple but so elegant and beautiful and came out just as I imagined. Our guests raved about how delicious the cake was, and so moist/not dry AT ALL. The we did 4 flavors in our cake, lemon-poppyseed with lemon mousse and blueberry curd (my personal favorite), pumpkin with cheesecake mousse, and the bottom tier was a split tier with chocolate and chocolate mousse and vanilla with cheesecake mousse with a layer of raspberry jam in the center (so so good). Craig's was very responsive and professional throughout the wedding planning process, and the price was very reasonable. You also get an included anniversary cake on 1 year anniversary! I would highly recommend them to anyone looking for their wedding cake vendor! Thank you so much again!
-Peggy Crain
Lauren
Lauren Sent on 08/24/2021
5 out of 5 rating

Looks and tastes great!

Craig's Cake Shop made the cake for our wedding in August 2021. I heard from many guests how great the cake was. We had a chocolate cake with peanut butter mousse and the guests loved it. There was a mix up with our florist and the cake flowers, but Craig's improvised, clipped some extra greens from our head table, added a few flowers and it looked exactly how we wanted. They truly went above and beyond and I would highly recommend them!
Katie
Katie Sent on 12/06/2019
5 out of 5 rating

Delicious cake

Our wedding cakes were delicious!! Everyone loved them, and we were able to have multiple flavor combinations from all of the sheet cakes. We found a design we loved on Pinterest, and they were able to make our cake look even better than the pictures. We are so excited to have another fresh cake for our first anniversary!!
Kelsey
Kelsey Sent on 10/24/2019
5 out of 5 rating

Absolutely amazing

Elisa was the best! She made sure that everything was exactly the way I wanted it and also made sure it looked perfect! Everything tasted sooooo good!!! Definitely will be ordering from Craig’s again!
Jessica
Jessica Sent on 06/11/2019
5 out of 5 rating

Best of the Best

Craig’s Cake Shop is near and dear to our hearts! When we got engaged I immediately knew where we wanted our cake from! We were elated when we found out that Elisa decided to purchase the shop! With the help of Rhonda (previous owner and family) the two of them and the staff at Craig’s knocked it out of the park! So amazing to work with and the cake was phenomenal (as usual)! You won’t be disappointed if you book Craig’s for your big day!! Wish we had pictures back from our photographer but will definitely post when we do! It was so beautiful!
We're all about trust. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.

Awards

131
WeddingWire Couples' Choice Awards 2023 Winner
WeddingWire Couples' Choice Awards 2018 Winner
WeddingWire Couples' Choice Awards 2017 Winner
WeddingWire Couples' Choice Awards 2016 Winner
WeddingWire Couples' Choice Awards 2015 Winner
WeddingWire Couples' Choice Awards 2014 Winner
WeddingWire Couples' Choice Awards 2013 Winner
WeddingWire Couples' Choice Awards 2012 Winner

Professional Network & Endorsements

3 Endorsements
Paul Toepfer Photography Paul Toepfer Photography Wedding Photographers

I get to eat Craig's Cake Shop cake just about every Saturday (YUMM!) because I recommend them to all my brides! Don't even think about hiring someone for your cake without trying Craig's first!

Beautiful Portraits by Michael Beautiful Portraits by Michael Wedding Photographers

One of my all time favorite cakes! I'm always happy when I learn that my bride and groom have chosen Craig's as their cake. :)

Kuhl Entertainment Kuhl Entertainment Wedding DJs

Craig's cakes are some of the best I've had the pleasure of indulging in over the course of the past decade. What more can I say? DJs love their cake...and Craig delivers top-notch desert every time!

Map

Addresses map
Next Wedding Cakes: Sweet Perfections Bake Shoppe

Other vendors in Milwaukee for your wedding

Wedding Vendors