x14 Award winner
Award winner thanks to recommendations from couples on WeddingWire.com.
- 2025
- 2024
- 2023
- 2021
- 2020
- 2019
- 2018
- 2017
- 2016
- 2015
- 2014
- 2013
- 2011
- 2010
Aggie's Bakery and Cake Shop
Interested in this vendor?
1/69
"Our wedding cake looked amazing and tasted even better!! I have a vision of what I wanted and the..."
"Our wedding cake looked amazing and tasted even better!! I had a vision of what I wanted and the day..."
About this vendor
7 years running Aggie's Bakery and Cake Shop has won the Couple's Choice Award for creating Milwaukee's best wedding cakes and desserts - as named by voters for the Milwaukee A-list! Aggie's specializes in making the most beautiful and delicious wedding cakes. From tier cakes, cupcakes, cheesecakes, table cakes, sheet cakes, and fine pastries - we have your dessert needs covered! We make our own made-from-scratch buttercream and use fresh, incredibly delicious cake that results in a cake that is just as delicious as it is beautiful - your guests will be sure to rave! Made from only the highest quality ingredients, Aggie's developed recipes that deliver superior texture and flavor. Our passion is creating your dream wedding cake and/or desserts. We look forward to meeting you and learning more about your big day!
Weddings with this vendor
Brynn & George
68 photos
Michelle & Luke
135 photos
Molly & Nick
26 photos
Moriah & Ben
19 photos
Kiryn & Ken
76 photos
Mary & Ian
91 photos
FAQ
What is the starting price for wedding cakes with buttercream frosting (per slice, without tax)?
$3.50
What is the starting price for fondant wedding cakes (per slice, without tax)?
$4.50
Which of the following are included in the cost of the cake?
Anniversary Cake
What is the starting price for cupcakes (per cupcake, without tax)?
$2
What services do your prices include?
Consultation
Custom Cake Design
Tastings - Private
What types of desserts do you provide?
Cheese
Cookies
Cupcakes
Dessert Buffet
Fruit
Groom's Cake
Pastries
What services do you provide?
Consultations
Custom Design
Delivery
Setup
Tastings - Private
What cake items do you provide?
Cake Stands
What special ingredients do you use?
Fresh Fruit
Local
Are you licensed by the state health department?
Yes
Still have questions?
Reach out about anything you didn't see answered here—no question is too small!
Reviews of Aggie's Bakery and Cake Shop
This AI-generated summary gives you a snapshot of the overall ratings and feedback from the reviews this vendor has received.
Review summary
Powered by AI
Aggie's Bakery consistently delivered beautiful, delicious wedding cakes and assorted desserts with excellent communication, helpful tastings, and timely delivery/setup. Reviewers praised the variety of flavors, attentive service, flexibility, and reasonable pricing. Highly recommended for weddings and events.
Nicole Sent on 06/28/2021
5 out of 5 rating
Absolutely Amazing!
Our wedding cake looked amazing and tasted even better!! I have a vision of what I wanted and the day of it came out exactly how I pictured it! The staff was amazing & super flexible when we decided to postponed due to covid!
We received so many compliments on how yummy our cake was and all the different flavor combos that we could put inside of 1 simple 4 tier cake!! I would hands down recommend Aggies for your wedding cake because they are now my go-to bakery for any special cake I will be ordering in the future!
We received so many compliments on how yummy our cake was and all the different flavor combos that we could put inside of 1 simple 4 tier cake!! I would hands down recommend Aggies for your wedding cake because they are now my go-to bakery for any special cake I will be ordering in the future!
Andrea Sent on 01/24/2026
5 out of 5 rating
Beautiful and Delicious
Our wedding cake looked amazing and tasted even better!! I had a vision of what I wanted and the day of it came out exactly how I pictured it! I will be choosing Aggies for all future dessert catering needs.
Letecia Sent on 12/20/2025
5 out of 5 rating
Beautiful Wedding Cake and Cupcakes
The bakery was delivered and set up on time. Our families and friends really loved the artistry style on the cake. It was a beautiful display. It was a beautiful day that we will never forget. I would recommend Aggie's Bakery.
Thanks you so much!
Mr. and Mrs. Klak
Thanks you so much!
Mr. and Mrs. Klak
Adam Sent on 11/09/2025
5 out of 5 rating
Great Wedding Cake and Desserts!
Aggie's Bakery did a great job with our wedding cake and mini pastries/sweets, I would definitely recommend them to anyone needing delicious desserts.
They did a great job with the communication throughout the planning process, and our tasting for the cakes, frostings, and pastries was a really good experience. They tailored the cake to exactly what we wanted, it turned out great.
And for the mini pastries and sweets, they were a hit, giving different options for everyone at the reception depending on their preferences. Everything tasted fantastic and went great with Aggies!
They did a great job with the communication throughout the planning process, and our tasting for the cakes, frostings, and pastries was a really good experience. They tailored the cake to exactly what we wanted, it turned out great.
And for the mini pastries and sweets, they were a hit, giving different options for everyone at the reception depending on their preferences. Everything tasted fantastic and went great with Aggies!
Mary Sent on 08/07/2025
5 out of 5 rating
Fantastic Service and scrumptious Cake and Pastries
We are super satisfied with Aggie's service. from the first meeting, tasting and wedding day itself. all went smoothly. Rachel and team did amazing job. The cake and pastries taste sooo good. The cake design was so pretty. Highly recommended/
Melissa Sent on 07/08/2025
5 out of 5 rating
Beautiful and delicious!
We used Aggie’s Bakery for our wedding cake last July. They exceeded our expectations for the decor, and the cake was delicious. We went with a marble cake with cream cheese frosting and oh my goodness, everyone was raving about it. A year later, I still think about that cake. We worked with Rachel, and she was an absolute gem. Cake was delivered exactly on time to our venue. Thank you Aggie’s!
Olivia Sent on 05/27/2025
5 out of 5 rating
Dream Cake
Working with Aggie’s was a dream! My spouse has their degree in baking and pastries and i knew whoever was going to provide our cake had to check all the boxes; and they did - immediately.
Rachel was a joy to work with from introducing herself at our tasting all the way through the entire process. Our cake was beautiful, tasted phenomenal, and the cupcakes were to die for with prompt on time delivery.
Not only that but the pricing was very reasonable for dessert for 140-150 people. We were able to relax and enjoy, knowing that Aggie’s bakery was absolutely the correct decision in who to entrust the most important moments of our wedding day with. Book with confidence!
Rachel was a joy to work with from introducing herself at our tasting all the way through the entire process. Our cake was beautiful, tasted phenomenal, and the cupcakes were to die for with prompt on time delivery.
Not only that but the pricing was very reasonable for dessert for 140-150 people. We were able to relax and enjoy, knowing that Aggie’s bakery was absolutely the correct decision in who to entrust the most important moments of our wedding day with. Book with confidence!
Megan Sent on 10/22/2024
5 out of 5 rating
10/10 would recommend
Aggies Bakery was my top pick when deciding on a bakery for our wedding cake. Since the initial email, Rachel was awesome at answering any questions I had as far as how many people would each cake feed etc. The cake tasting was also a great experience to make the decision making easy.
The actual wedding cake exceeded my expectations. It was exactly what I was looking for. Once we had finished off the final bits of cake I was wanting more. It was so good! Will definitely consider Aggies again in the future.
The actual wedding cake exceeded my expectations. It was exactly what I was looking for. Once we had finished off the final bits of cake I was wanting more. It was so good! Will definitely consider Aggies again in the future.
We're all about trust. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.
Awards
Are you interested?
Team
Rachel Schmidbauer
Owner
Professional Network & Endorsements
Map
Location
Why use Weddingwire to message vendors?
- Messaging our verified vendors on WeddingWire is complimentary, safe, and secure.
- Effortlessly manage vendor communications and planning details in one centralized location.
- Our mobile apps ensure you can stay connected with vendors anytime, anywhere.
- For customized pricing and package information, messaging the vendor directly is the quickest way to get the details you need.