About Cakes by Karol Key West

Cakes by Karol has been feature in Extreme Makeover Wedding edition, in In touch magazine, local newspaper.
Creating wedding and specialty cakes for the florida Keys

Categories: Wedding Cake

Regions serviced: Florida Keys

197 Reviews for Cakes by Karol Key West

out of 5.0
User Photos
todo alt text
todo alt text
todo alt text
Filter reviews by services used:
All Reviews
Delivery (31)
Cakes (29)
Custom Design (22)
Cake Stands (13)
Setup (12)
Consultations (9)
Private Tastings (5)
Cupcakes (4)
Pastries (2)
Dessert Buffet (1)
Gluten Free (1)
Sort by:


Cakes by Karol hosted the desserts and cake for our wedding day last week. I have Celiac Disease and other food allergies so I stick mostly to a gluten free/vegan diet. Given that, we did a one tier gluten free, vegan cake with chocolate cake, peanut butter filling and vanilla buttercream icing with a blush flower on the side. Not only did our cake look beautiful, but you would have never known it was a gluten free, vegan cake - it was DELICIOUS! I totally recommend them whether you have food allergies or not. Our guests loved the dessert display we put underneath (key lime shooters, chocolate trifle shooters, peanut butter chocolate shooters, chocolate covered strawberries). Our guests ate them until they couldn't eat anymore, even after our reception had ended. Cakes by Karol worked amazing with all of this and the fact that we live almost 2,000 miles away. They kept in contact with us through emails, calls, etc. and always responded in a timely fashion. That was such a breeze to feel important so far away. Thank you Cakes by Karol! If we could give you more than 5 stars I would!

Photo of Cakes by Karol Key West in Key West, FL
Profile Picture Samantha, 5/17/18, 3 Reviews
Category: Wedding Cake

The cake was exactly what we ordered! It was beautiful and it tasted even better! We’re so glad we pick this bakery for our wedding!!

Profile Picture Maria, 5/12/18, 5 Reviews
Category: Wedding Cake
Services Used: Cakes, Delivery

I ordered a cake tasting to be shipped to us in California so we could experience it together since we were not planning to visit key west before our wedding. The tasting arrived in shambles and cost us $60. I sent Cakes by Carol a photo of how the tasting arrived and all they could say was “oh no they must really throw those packages around”. Terrible.

Profile Picture Karen, 3/17/18, 4 Reviews
Category: Wedding Cake
Services Used: Delivery

Cakes by Karol Key West FAQ

Cake Pops
Dessert Buffet
Groom's Cake
Custom Design
Private Tastings
Cake Stands
Cake Cutters
Cake Toppers
Gluten Free
Lactose Free
Nut Free
Health License


12 Photos

My Photo Album

12 Photos
220x220 sq 1249488952481 k40
220x220 sq 1249489053419 picture001
220x220 sq 1249489231013 k67
220x220 sq 1249489290325 k66
220x220 sq 1338915838855 81
220x220 sq 1338915921668 cct23
220x220 sq 1338915967286 cakesbykarold
220x220 sq 1338916046041 wedding150
220x220 sq 1338916073027 34
220x220 sq 1338916135186 262
220x220 sq 1338916199213 229
220x220 sq 1338916231684 131

Professional Network & Endorsements

So tasty and beautifully made cakes! We enjoy coming by the cake table to see their creation and they do a great job every time.

We work with this company constantly! They always deliver fresh, fantastic and beautiful cakes for any of our events! Thanks Cakes by Karol team!

One of the most creative and the cakes taste great too!

We wouldn't use any other bakery in town. Cakes by Karol is great. They are dependable, honest and reliable. it is our pleasure and honor to endorse Cakes by Karol!

Karol is a very creative person and can really get the vision of what the couple wants for their special day. They are tasty and always arrive on time. We enjoy referring business to Karol and her staff. Sincerely, The Reach


218 Whitehead St # 4, Key West, FL 33040   See On Map
305-393-3020 (phone)
Tues- Friday 10:30 am to 4pm Sat 10:30 am to 3pm