Family owned and operated serving the finest quality European pastries, cakes, cupcakes, cake pops, Rudy's Cuties Cheesecake Drops, and various desserts for over 35 years. We are open to the public as well as a wholesale bakery to local eateries and retailers. We Deliver Quality Baked Goods to Your Door!
We would be excited to work with you and your family on your personal, fun, and creative cake and dessert ideas to help make your event become a reality. Allow us to take part in your special day!
Please call 973-743-3768 or email info@rudyspastryshop.com for any questions you may have for us or to schedule a private cake tasting at our location.
We do not have a storefront. All of our products are Custom Made for each order. We ask you to allow a minimum of 48 hrs to place any order. Larger or more complicated orders may require more time.
Vendors you may like
See other vendors that are popular with couples right now
The cake wasn’t just visually stunning, it was also moist, flavorful, and not overly sweet, which made it easy for everyone to enjoy without feeling too heavy. Our baker worked with us closely to create a design that felt personal and unique, and they were so accommodating with all our requests.
I can't thank them enough for making our day extra special with such a perfect cake. Highly recommend for anyone looking for a wedding cake that's as delicious as it is beautiful!"
Beth Sent on 09/29/2023
5 out of 5 rating
5.0
Cake of our dreams!
Rudy's Pastry shop exceeded all of our expectations from the moment we walked through the door. Chris and his team are so kind and went out of their way to make our tasting so memorable - and delicious! Our wedding cake was beautiful and I'm already counting down the days until our 1st anniversary next August so we can take the top tier from the freezer! :)
Melanie Sent on 07/02/2023
5 out of 5 rating
5.0
Still thinking of that raspberry filling!
Working with Rudy's Pastry Shop was a breeze! Our wedding venue gave us two bakery options for our wedding cake, one being Rudy's. Our tasting appointment with Rudy's was easy to make and they prepare 3 small cakes of your choice flavors to taste there and take home with you. I am not a big sweet person, and do not normally care for cake, but Rudy's cake with the raspberry filling, wow! It was not too sweet and the bright tartness was perfect for our springtime wedding. Thank you Rudy's! Our guests were raving about the cake! Can't wait to eat the top tier on our wedding anniversary!
Samantha Sent on 01/02/2023
5 out of 5 rating
5.0
SO Delicious!
I have literally never liked a wedding cake until I had my tasting with Rudy's- the flavors are amazing and the cake didn't taste stale or old as wedding cakes usually do. I even used them for my shower and we got so many compliments! Highly recommend!
Dana Sent on 06/14/2021
5 out of 5 rating
5.0
Most Delicious Cake!
We had a great experience with Rudy’s from the start. We did our cake tasting with them, and were amazed that they baked us 3 mini cakes in the flavors of our choice. The cakes were absolutely delicious and it was so hard to decide which combo to go with. We opted for them vanilla cake with fresh strawberries and Bavarian Creme. It was DELICIOUS and we received so many compliments from our guests!
Kim Sent on 11/23/2019
5 out of 5 rating
5.0
Delicious!
We chose Rudy's for our wedding cake at the Stone House at Stirling Ridge. My husband and I are very pleased that we did! There are a variety of cake flavors and fillings to choose from. Their tasting was also phenomenal. We loved the fact that we were able to have different flavor combinations for each tier of our cake. We still hope to use Rudy's for future special occasions as well!
Allison Sent on 11/11/2019
5 out of 5 rating
5.0
100% you need a cake from Rudy’s
Cake was BEAUTIFUL and delicious. I showed them a random picture from Pinterest and they blew that picture out of the water. My guests actually ate cake...we also got a cannoli tower which i made sure i ate from and they were delicious. Thank you!
Jeff Sent on 10/25/2019
5 out of 5 rating
5.0
Perfect Cake
We worked with Rudy's through our venue (The Stone House at Stirling Ridge) and had an amazing experience with them. Our tasting was early and we loved all the options, but chose a yellow cake with bavarian creme and white frosting. They were able to recreate a design we'd seen online, and everything turned out perfectly. The cake was delicious and exactly how we wanted it to look. Everything was very easy and we'd definitely recommend them to others! Thank you
Christina Sent on 07/04/2019
5 out of 5 rating
5.0
Tasty and Beautiful Wedding Cake
Our venue had two preferred bakeries we could choose from to design our wedding cake. When we looked at the two options, Rudy's was our obvious choice.
Rudy's is one of the few bakeries I have found that offers so many varieties of cake flavors and fillings. What I loved about our tasting was that we were able to create 3 mini cake combinations of our top choices and those cakes were made fresh for us for our visit. We then got to take the leftovers home!
We went with a chocolate chip cake that had a cannoli filling. Our guests raved over how moist and unique the cake was, and how great it went with their coffee at dessert! The staff at Rudy's also worked well with our custom-made cake toppers and our floral designer. We froze our top layer and can't wait to revisit our memories on our anniversay.
Kristen Sent on 04/29/2019
5 out of 5 rating
5.0
Beautiful Wedding Cake
Rudy’s was amazing! The taste test was so delicious and I loved how they made 3 mini cakes for us to take home! Our wedding cake was absolutely stunning and tasted amazing. We did Vanilla with Lemon Filling & Red Velvet with Cannoli filling. Both flavors were amazingly Rudy’s will not disappoint. Book them for your wedding!
We're all about trust. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.
Monday - Friday 8 AM to 5 PM.
Saturday 8 AM to 4 PM
Sunday Office is Closed. Deliveries ONLY.
Cake Tastings: Thursday, Friday, or Saturdays by Appointment Only.
