Rudy's Pastry Shop Reviews
Reviews
We're all about trust. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.
-
Beth Sent on 09/29/2023
Cake of our dreams!
Rudy's Pastry shop exceeded all of our expectations from the moment we walked through the door. Chris and his team are so kind and went out of their way to make our tasting so memorable - and delicious! Our wedding cake was beautiful and I'm already counting down the days until our 1st anniversary next August so we can take the top tier from the freezer! :) -
-
Melanie Sent on 07/02/2023
Still thinking of that raspberry filling!
Working with Rudy's Pastry Shop was a breeze! Our wedding venue gave us two bakery options for our wedding cake, one being Rudy's. Our tasting appointment with Rudy's was easy to make and they prepare 3 small cakes of your choice flavors to taste there and take home with you. I am not a big sweet person, and do not normally care for cake, but Rudy's cake with the raspberry filling, wow! It was not too sweet and the bright tartness was perfect for our springtime wedding. Thank you Rudy's! Our guests were raving about the cake! Can't wait to eat the top tier on our wedding anniversary! -
-
![Dana]()
Dana Sent on 06/14/2021Most Delicious Cake!
We had a great experience with Rudy’s from the start. We did our cake tasting with them, and were amazed that they baked us 3 mini cakes in the flavors of our choice. The cakes were absolutely delicious and it was so hard to decide which combo to go with. We opted for them vanilla cake with fresh strawberries and Bavarian Creme. It was DELICIOUS and we received so many compliments from our guests! -
-
Kim Sent on 11/23/2019
Delicious!
We chose Rudy's for our wedding cake at the Stone House at Stirling Ridge. My husband and I are very pleased that we did! There are a variety of cake flavors and fillings to choose from. Their tasting was also phenomenal. We loved the fact that we were able to have different flavor combinations for each tier of our cake. We still hope to use Rudy's for future special occasions as well! -
-
![Allison]()
Allison Sent on 11/11/2019100% you need a cake from Rudy’s
Cake was BEAUTIFUL and delicious. I showed them a random picture from Pinterest and they blew that picture out of the water. My guests actually ate cake...we also got a cannoli tower which i made sure i ate from and they were delicious. Thank you! -
-
![Jeff]()
Jeff Sent on 10/25/2019Perfect Cake
We worked with Rudy's through our venue (The Stone House at Stirling Ridge) and had an amazing experience with them. Our tasting was early and we loved all the options, but chose a yellow cake with bavarian creme and white frosting. They were able to recreate a design we'd seen online, and everything turned out perfectly. The cake was delicious and exactly how we wanted it to look. Everything was very easy and we'd definitely recommend them to others! Thank you -
![Christina]()
Christina Sent on 07/04/2019Tasty and Beautiful Wedding Cake
Our venue had two preferred bakeries we could choose from to design our wedding cake. When we looked at the two options, Rudy's was our obvious choice.
Rudy's is one of the few bakeries I have found that offers so many varieties of cake flavors and fillings. What I loved about our tasting was that we were able to create 3 mini cake combinations of our top choices and those cakes were made fresh for us for our visit. We then got to take the leftovers home!
We went with a chocolate chip cake that had a cannoli filling. Our guests raved over how moist and unique the cake was, and how great it went with their coffee at dessert! The staff at Rudy's also worked well with our custom-made cake toppers and our floral designer. We froze our top layer and can't wait to revisit our memories on our anniversay. -
-
![Kristen]()
Kristen Sent on 04/29/2019Beautiful Wedding Cake
Rudy’s was amazing! The taste test was so delicious and I loved how they made 3 mini cakes for us to take home! Our wedding cake was absolutely stunning and tasted amazing. We did Vanilla with Lemon Filling & Red Velvet with Cannoli filling. Both flavors were amazingly Rudy’s will not disappoint. Book them for your wedding! -
-
![Heather]()
Heather Sent on 12/09/2018Absolutely the best!
My husband and I had some unusual requests for our wedding cake and we're so happy we chose Rudy's. Sergio was AMAZING! He spent so much time during our cake tasting to understand what we wanted and to make sure he made our vision come to life. Everyone raved about the cake, from looks to taste, it was perfect. We are so happy with our decision and hope everyone chooses Rudy's, they're the best! -
Megan Sent on 03/18/2018We got a marble cake with fudge filling. The cake was delicious and Rudy's was able to make the perfect cake for our winter wedding theme: Yeti. They made two adorable yeti cake toppers out of fondant and textured the cake so it looked like snow with big snowflake patters on each layer. I highly recommend Rudy's for a beautiful and delicious cake! Can't wait to it it again for our anniversary!
-
-
![Elizabeth]()
Elizabeth Sent on 12/19/2016We chose Rudy's Pastry Shop from a selection from our venue Stone House At Stirling Ridge. We are so glad we did! The tasting--although a little informal--left us with 100% confidence that our cake would be amazing. Great flavors, wonderful people--just a plain ole' great bakery! -
![StephaDeFa]()
Stephanie Sent on 11/09/2015Sergio at Rudy's Pastry Shop was an absolute pleasure to work with. Our tasting was so personable and you could tell he truly loved his job. After a pretty vague description and picture, the cake he delivered to us on our wedding day could not have been any more perfect or delicious. He is truly awesome at his job because you can tell he does it with love! Thank you Sergio! -
![Michelle]()
Michelle Sent on 11/29/2014We love Rudy's!! They made our wedding cake and an amazing groom's cake for my husband. Everything tasted great, was super fresh, and Chris was so easy to work with. They basically created whatever we wanted. We came upon Rudy's after going to another bakery's cake tasting, and that one did not even come close to the experience we had at Rudy's. We will definitely be using Rudy's again for any future cake needs. -
![kitkat1143]()
Kathleen Sent on 02/07/2014Our reception used Rudy's Pastry Shop for our wedding cake. We were able to meet with the bakers, taste our cakes and discuss our designs. Rudy's Pastry Shop more than exceeded our expectations! Our cake was amazing- the design and the taste. We had SO many people comment on how beautiful our cake was and how much they enjoyed eating it! We really cant thank Rudy's enough. We came in not knowing what designs we wanted- we provided 3 photos of different cakes cakes we found online and they made ours perfect! -
![Lisa]()
Lisa Sent on 08/06/2012Working with Rudy's through our venue (Stone House at Stirling Ridge) was wonderful! We met with Peggy for our tasting & consultation. It was a fun, easy process. We brought a photo of an idea for our cake and they let us know they'd be able to do it with no problem. The day of our wedding, our cake was beautiful! It tasted great & it visually fit so nicely with the rest of our wedding. We were very pleased with our experience with Rudy's! -
![User2457617]()
User2457617 Sent on 12/01/2015I used Rudy's bakery for my wedding cake and it turned out absolutely fabulous! The day we met to have our tasting and design the cake was one of he most fun wedding tasks that we had to complete. They offered to make three custom cake samples for us but we were so torn that we inquired about their opinion on four different flavors and they ended up making all of them for us, no questions asked. The very unique cake design that we found on Pinterest and brought in with us for inspiration actually turned out to be a cake from Rudy's! What are the chances!? We knew right then that we could totally trust them without any worries. After the tasting we couldn't choose between two flavors of cake so they offered to alternate the flavors between tiers which was such a good idea, our guests were really liking being able to have two different slices! The cake turned out beautiful and I am still getting compliments about it a month after the wedding. Next time I need a cake I know who I will be using! -
![Kimberly]()
Kimberly Sent on 06/08/2021Beautiful & yummy
My cake was everything I wanted it to be , great price as well . Everyone love the flavor we had which was vanilla mousse with marble cake. -
Are you interested?
Are you interested?