Yes: book this vendor! As the Milwaukee-based mother of a remote bride, I was searching for a local store that was hip, fashionable, and modern in its selection of invitations. Broadway Paper fit the bill BEAUTIFULLY. We flew the bride in from the East Coast, took her to the Third Ward, and showed her the shop. She was thrilled with the selection: there were just as many modern/unique papers as traditional offerings, and the quality was there. Our bride and groom (both in their mid-twenties) chose a very cool and modern set of medium gray papers that offered white lettering and a very unique font; it also included a unique paper shape for each type of enclosure. Stunning. (They wanted modern and streamlined but elegant, and they found it). Also, our contact person was very professional (very savvy). In particular, she saved us time by offering suggestions about the typical way things are phrased when there's a unique circumstance to be clarified in an invitation. Really helpful. We were also grateful that she turned around each proof quickly (and paid great attention to detail---every change we specified made it in, no matter how tiny). Finally, our invitations came in early, and they contacted us immediately (I did a same-day pickup.) Loved the quality papers, and loved the quality experience. (We also returned to the shop a few months later for some classy tags---off-the-rack---to use on our traveler boxes for hotel guests. Nice selection.) Fun to write this review: very satisfied with this vendor.

Amanda Pearson at Broadway Paper was awesome to work with! She helped us create our wedding invitations and day of wedding items for the reception, including some super cute customized cocktail napkins. The best part is that we were able to create beautiful pieces that matched our style and fit within our wedding budget. I would definitely recommend both Amanda and Broadway Paper!

I had a very specific motif in mind when ordering the save the dates and invitations. By sheer luck, I found Broadway Paper at a wedding show at the state fair grounds, displaying the very invitation I wanted! We ordered all of our invites, as well as our bride and groom stationary through them. Kate was fun to work with, and the entire staff made us feel very good about the ordering process (and about what we chose!) I would recommend them to anyone!