Skip to main content
Weddings

About

Perfect Wedding Bands At Ben Garelick

Find the perfect wedding bands to symbolize your everlasting love and commitment at Ben Garelick Jewelers. No matter what your budget, you’ll find affordable wedding bands and the largest selection in the Buffalo, New York area.

Incredible Selection Of Wedding Band Designs

Whether you are looking for coordinating his and hers wedding bands, or selecting unique bands for each of you, Ben Garelick Jewelers offers an unbelievable selection in a variety of styles. Choose from yellow gold, rose gold, white gold, platinum and more in vintage, filigree, and comfort-fit styles. The diamond experts at Ben Garelick will help you choose matching, coordinating, or unisex wedding bands or ones that coordinate with your engagement ring. We offer featured designers Gabriel & Co, Barkev's, Kirk Kara, Benchmark, Lashbrook, Simon G., and Artcarved so you have a wider selection of styles to choose from. Our wedding ring selection ranges from classic diamond channel set bands to contemporary designed inserts and wedding wraps. These enhancer wedding bands wrap your engagement ring in diamonds and precious metal to create a complete bridal set.

Customizing Your Deepest Desires

Did you find the perfect wedding band...almost? Not a problem. The pros at Ben Garelick Jewelers will work closely with our designers on any customizing of your wedding bands that you would like so that your wedding bands are lasting symbols of love you will cherish for a lifetime. Each wedding band is expertly crafted of the finest metals and precious stones for the utmost sparkle.

Visit Our Buffalo, NY Showroom Or Shop Online

When you choose your wedding bands from Ben Garelick Jewelers, you can be sure you’re receiving the most expert care and advice and the highest quality craftsmanship and materials at the best price. Call (716) 631-1584 and ask about our layaway and 0% financing options to assist you in purchasing the rings that make you smile. Stop by our Buffalo showroom and try them on, or browse our selection online. Either way, our experts are here to help you select the rings that will represent you on the day you say “I do,” and every day after.

  • Woman-owned
illustration popular

Vendors you may like

See other vendors that are popular with couples right now

Frequently asked questions

Which of the following services do you offer?

Cleaning
Diamond Certification
Payment Plans
Ring Sizing
Shipping
Stone Upgrades

What kind of jewelry do you offer?

Antique Engagement Rings
Antique Wedding Bands
Designer Engagement Rings
Designer Wedding Bands

What is your average turnaround time for an engagement ring?

1-2 weeks
3-4 weeks
5-6 weeks

Reviews of Ben Garelick Jewelers

C
Caitlin Sent on 06/12/2025
5 out of 5 rating

Incredible experience, start to finish

I was thrilled to find out the ring I’d been dreaming of for years already existed at Ben Garelick (one of their original designs), but I was even more excited to find out it was surprisingly affordable and customizable. I reached out to ask about pricing and spoke with the owner himself, who really took the time to answer all my questions and provide upfront quotes. He never tried to upsell or pressure me and he offered to price-match the diamond, which saved me enough money to upgrade a full half carat and still come in under budget. Financing was a breeze and shipping was fast and secure. Buying from an individually owned and operated jewelry store instead of a big box retailer made all the difference in the world. I wasn’t treated like just a number on an invoice and I have peace of mind knowing they stand behind their work. This ring is a dream come true and I’ve enjoyed every step of the process with Ben Garelick. I can’t wait for my kids to fall in love so I can introduce them to Peter for their engagement rings!
L
Letitia Sent on 08/15/2024
5 out of 5 rating

Beautiful custom creation!

I have always wanted an Art Deco ring, but had been unable to find what I was looking for. After seeing the positive reviews, I decided to hire Ben Garelick to create a perfect custom design for me. Peter was very professional, responsive, attentive, and just a pleasure to work with. He and his team were able to create a beautiful ring in the updated Art Deco style I was looking for: a round brilliant center diamond in a square double halo platinum setting. The work is excellent and the price extremely fair. Thank you!
Alexandra
Alexandra Sent on 10/15/2023
5 out of 5 rating

Incandescent sparkles

I L😍VE the INCANDESCENT SPARKLES of my new custom bridal set!
I just can’t get enough of looking at my rings. They catch my eyes 👀 with glimmer and shine in every movement.
3rd time is the charm!
Peter and staff @ Ben Garelick right all the wrongs of previous jewelers!
Peter provided honest transparent information. He was patient and insightful. He provided very clear and constant communication.
We live in Florida. After being misled and taken advantage of by a couple of jewelers, we had our hesitations about working with a jeweler in a different state. I’m so glad I stumbled upon Ben Garelick while searching the web!
S
8814699F7Be0B2Bbbee87Afee4D5Dc6B2D17B351 Sent on 12/30/2022
5 out of 5 rating

Engagement

My fiancé purchased my engagement ring from Ben Garelick in November of 2022. He received the engagement ring and wedding band in December of 2022.

The process of the design and purchasing this rings was extremely easy. He could have just purchased it right on the website but since he had a particular design in mind he wanted to consult with with a specialist. Peter Manka Jr. our consultant at Ben Garelick Jewelers was incredibly responsive to his numerous email inquiries, exhibited an impressive degree of resourcefulness with making such an important purchase online. They also gave him a realistic time frame from development to shipping right when they expected it to.

Buying an engagement ring remotely is a leap of faith, but I'm glad that he put trust into Peter Manka Jr. from the first step to the last.

As for the quality of my rings, I think the picture does it justice. The detail and quality of these rings are unmatched. I'm completely in love with them!

"Thank you, Ben Garelick Jewelers!"
T
Tim P. Sent on 12/15/2021
5 out of 5 rating

Top Notch…AGAIN

Peter and Peter Jr. did it again going above and beyond with professionalism, service, and quality. This is my second transaction with them. Bought our engagement ring, super impressed, came back for our wedding band, super impressed. Peter Jr went the extra mile and found my fiancé’s matching wedding band when I only gave him a generic picture of what we thought we wanted. Leave it to the professionals y’all! These people know what they’re doing, A++, highly recommend!!!
Jaclyn
Jaclyn Sent on 10/02/2021
5 out of 5 rating

Amazing customer service. Beautiful rings

Amazing! Our rings are beautiful. My engagement ring came from here as well. My now mother in law worked here a long time ago and they have been great with cleanings and anything else. Highly recommend!
K
Kaitlyn Sent on 09/10/2021
5 out of 5 rating

Customized engagement rings

Peter and staff are incredible. Both my fiancé and I customized engagement rings for each other. We worked with Peter to get the specific design we wanted and he responded timely with a drawing of what it would look like, worked within our budget, and was very knowledgeable throughout the process! I definitely recommend them to anyone who is just looking or even those who do have an idea in mind. Everyone we worked with was friendly and very personable! We will definitely be back for future purchases.
S
Sebastian Sent on 02/09/2021
5 out of 5 rating

Engagement ring and Wedding bands - Peter Manka Jr. The Hero.

In December 2019 I proposed to my wife now, with the best ring ever. This ring was made by Kirk Kara, but little I knew the ring was going to take a few weeks to be made (as it is handmade) and add the shipping times to a friend in the US and then final destination... it seemed like mission impossible. However, I luckily was helped by Peter Manka Jr. and he basically made it happen. He contacted Kirk Kara, he sorted the shipping and in the end I got the ring on time after international shipping... OH! and with Peter also gave me a discount... GREAT! - in 2020 same process happened and now I needed my wedding band and my wife's - again Peter gave us unbelievable prices. This time he went above and beyond. He helped me getting the perfect size for my ring, as I was not able to do the fitting personally as I live in a different country. He sent me about 5 emails with all the recommendations and all the resources he had available to make sure I had the perfect fit. The ring arrived and it is perfect. Really recommend Ben Garelick to everyone. Thanks Peter.
M
Mary Sent on 12/26/2020
5 out of 5 rating

Fabulous!

The ring is absolutely gorgeous after looking for months during a global pandemic I’d almost given up on finding a ring until I came across Ben Garelick Jewelers .. the possibilities were endless on their website . Peter was a joy to work with SO professional and bent over backyards to accommodate me. I have never been more satisfied with a jeweler.. can’t say enough good things.. I was able to create something so beautiful in the midst of so much negativity... priceless
K
Kris Sent on 06/24/2020
5 out of 5 rating

Trusted jeweler with amazing service

My family has been working with Ben Garelick for decades. They continue to exceed expectations in terms of selection, value, and customer service. I always buy with confidence when working with their staff.
We're all about trust. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.

Awards

54
WeddingWire Couples' Choice Awards 2020 Winner
WeddingWire Couples' Choice Awards 2019 Winner
WeddingWire Couples' Choice Awards 2018 Winner

Map

Addresses map
Next Wedding Jewelers: Brian Michaels Jewelers

Other vendors in Buffalo for your wedding

Wedding Vendors