Skip to main content

Post content has been hidden

To unblock this content, please click here

Kendra
Super May 2015

Name Change Identity Crisis :(

Kendra, on February 1, 2015 at 4:47 PM

Posted in Planning 127

I have no clue what we're doing about names and we are getting married in less than 4 months and have a baby due in September that is going to need a last name. We considered and seemed like we both loved the idea of both changing our names to something new. A lot of our family and friends said the...

I have no clue what we're doing about names and we are getting married in less than 4 months and have a baby due in September that is going to need a last name. We considered and seemed like we both loved the idea of both changing our names to something new. A lot of our family and friends said the name we chose didn't sound good. His mom was livid. It kinda made him less keen on the idea. Then he found out how expensive/time consuming the process is. And we started thinking about how it would impact his career. It is no big deal for a woman to say in an interview/job application that "Oh I have a different last name now bc I got married" but men would be looked at funny for saying the same thing. He's a diesel mechanic, too. Which is a field filled with "men's men." We wouldn't want him to miss out on any opportunities bc of this. It's just a hassle altogether. It sucks. Honestly I don't care that no one likes it and I wish he still wanted to change it.

127 Comments

  • GoneAndMarried
    Master August 2015
    GoneAndMarried ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    Okay, honestly, I am NOT changing my last name, I don't care WHAT you do, and I have offered genuinely supportive advice regardless. Your comment is sarcastic, both of them, and how was I supposed to know the difference as to whether or not you were being rude the second time.

    My advice came from experience, I have a child, I have been pregnant, I have dealt with both parenting issues within my own home and with a step parent. I offered advice as to that. And even if this is the only issue NOW, its the only parenting issue thus far. And no, I don't know you, but from what I do know, you are fighting with your husband w/o being willing to bend, in any direction, on your first parenting issue. Yes, that to me, says you will be fighting for a looonggg 18 years or more. And to point out the obvious, no one here "knows" anyone, but you are asking for advice from literal strangers on a very sensitive and private topic. Its borderline ridiculous to be like "you don't know me well enough to say ____"

    In regards to pregnancy hormones, yes, I feel that I can safely say that when your body is literally terrorizing itself, emotions get out of whack and can sometimes make people feel more convicted in their decisions that they otherwise wouldn't be, and make you more irritable, sad, etc. This WILL happen to you, in some capacity at some point. If you felt offended, I'm sorry, but honestly the general tone you have in this entire thread is radically different from your past posts, so to me it says its possible its hormones.

    Again - in no way was I attempting to be offensive, and at various points I offered advice that seemed genuinely helpful. Whether or not you choose to take it is up to you.

    • Reply
  • alyshadanielle
    Master April 2015
    alyshadanielle ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    Typical dramatic post where OP ignores all helpful comments and only responds to create more drama.

    • Reply
  • Future Mrs. Weaver
    Devoted March 2016
    Future Mrs. Weaver ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    Do you not like his last name??? Personally, I can not WAIT to be Mrs. Weaver. I wish I could do it today! Buuuuuut then again, it is a good last name, it isnt like. Schlidenhjzberg or something ridiculous lll

    • Reply
  • MrsBest2B
    Master June 2016
    MrsBest2B ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    I understand wanting to keep your originality. My last name is also very unique. I'm the only person at least in the U.S. with my full name. I do plan on changing it after we get married, but keep thinking about the possibility of hyphenating too. My FH has 4 people with his same name in our town alone and one of them was arrested for child pornography!! I had to post the article on Facebook that it was NOT my FH!!! I suggest both of you hyphenating both of your current last names and doing the same for baby. It may be long, but a lot of people are doing that and it keeps both sides happy. When your kids are 18 or get married, they can decide to change or shorten it down the line. Making it something totally different is a cool idea in theory, making something that's all your own, but it does take away from the history of your family lines.

    • Reply
  • Kristin
    Expert August 2015
    Kristin ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    I'm going to change my middle name to my maiden and take my FH's last name. I do like mine better but I'm doing it because we want to make things easier for when we have kids. People would end up calling me by his name regardless if we have kids because people assume you have the same last name.

    Not in a mean way at all jus my opinion - There's nothing wrong with keeping your name if that is what you want. hands down. but...It seems like you would change your name to anything other than just your FH's last name. You would give yours up if he would change his too. Makes me wonder if you are really connected to your name or you just want to keep things even - like you both are giving something up.

    • Reply
  • MrsA
    Master October 2015
    MrsA ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    My FH doesn't mind what I do....take his or not. He understands if I want to keep mine.

    I'm old fashioned. I like the idea of taking the husbands name. And when It comes to the comedown I think men like it too. No matter how much the times have changed both men and women have basic instincts that need to be met as men and women. Men measure their self worth through their accomplishments. A successful career, establishing a family and providing for them. His children, caring his name, is a since of pride and accomplishment. Their are exceptions, but very few. I think it the same when a women takes his name, its a small symbol that shows connection and unity within family.

    • Reply
  • Haley
    Beginner July 2020
    Haley ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    Why don’t you talk to him about you both taking on your last name? If his mother is so adamant that her name be carried on, make his last name your children’s middle. If he really doesn’t care about his name that is. As far as his mans man job, talk to him about your worries for his future career. He knows his work place best.
    • Reply

You voted for . Add a comment 👇

×
WeddingWire celebrates love ...and so does everyone on our site! Explore how we embrace diversity

Groups

WeddingWire article topics