Also, please change your avatar to something other than the rings! (Your avatar isn't the same as the background pic on the app). It will help you get more responses to your posts and it makes the threads easier to read. Here's how: https://www.weddingwire.com/wedding-forums/welcome-new-users-faq-lingo-and-guidelines/736e1073af1a0860.html
I think steak goes over better than fish. Fish option is way too broad as people will want to know the type of fish and how it will be cooked, etc. I would do chicken, beef, and a veggie platter. We are doing chicken for dinner, but going heavy on apps with beef and crab dip included.
FH and I are big red meat eaters. FH definitely prefers red meat to fish or chicken. However, when FH, my mom, and I went to a tasting event that my venue offered we all raved over one of the chicken options offered, raved over one of the vegetarian options, FH absolutely loved the fish and not a single one of us cared for a single one of the beef options. I always thought I'd have my options be beef, chicken, and vegetarian but we went with what actually tasted amazing so now we have chicken, fish, and vegetarian.
I don't think we will be choosing a beef option. But I think it depends on your trust of the finished product, some beef can be overdone. We are also not likely to pick chicken either due to the risk of dry chicken.
I think we will end up with another meat of either pork, veal + fish + vegetarian.
But if the beef dish is supposed to be good, I'm all for it as it's usually the most popular choice.