Cher Horowitz
Rockstar December 2019

Engagement Rings: Expectation vs. Reality!

Cher Horowitz, on September 15, 2019 at 3:55 PM Posted in Community Conversations 3 324
Saved Save
Reply

Did your vision for your engagement ring match up with what you actually got? FH and I got engaged without a ring, so I showed him a photo of what I wanted. He ended up getting a totally different style I wasn't expecting, but I absolutely love it!

What I envisionedEngagement Rings: Expectation vs. Reality! 1

What FH got me!Engagement Rings: Expectation vs. Reality! 2


324 Comments

  • Kelsey
    Dedicated August 2019
    Kelsey ·
    Before we got engaged I thought I wanted an oval halo ring. We went shopping together because I’m way too picky and wanted to make sure I liked the ring. I ended up with a pear halo ring that I love! I’m so glad I went with the pear over the oval, I feel like it suits me so much more.
  • Cher Horowitz
    Rockstar December 2019
    Cher Horowitz ·
    View Quoted Comment

    Pear shaped rings are so pretty!

  • Sara
    Expert June 2020
    Sara ·
    I feel like my ring is a better version of what I envisioned. I was pretty sure I wanted bezzel set and did not want any small accent diamonds. I got a bezzel set with accent diamonds and it is so amazing. Fiance really put a lot of thought and detail into his design.

    Engagement Rings: Expectation vs. Reality! 3
  • Cher Horowitz
    Rockstar December 2019
    Cher Horowitz ·
    View Quoted Comment

    I love how your FH designed your beautiful ring!

  • Lauren
    VIP February 2020
    Lauren ·
    FH & I went and picked out rings together when we were talking about getting engaged. I didn’t know it, but the next day, he went back and got the ring I loved from the jewelry store! He proposed with the exact ring I tried on at the store. 😊 It has a round center diamond with a cushion double halo!

    Engagement Rings: Expectation vs. Reality! 4
  • Cher Horowitz
    Rockstar December 2019
    Cher Horowitz ·
    View Quoted Comment

    Aww, that's so sweet! What a beautiful ring!

  • Samantha
    Expert October 2020
    Samantha ·
    I really wanted an Art Deco ring, but my grandma gave my fiancé my great grandmother’s ring to use. It’s definitely not what I envisioned but it’s perfect and I do love it.

    Engagement Rings: Expectation vs. Reality! 5
  • Laura
    Rockstar November 2019
    Laura ·
    I had no idea what I wanted when we went shopping. Then I saw a set that I absolutely fell in love with. Quart cut center diamonds with halo and accent diamonds. FH played it all cool but snuck back a few days later and bought it. I love it!



    Engagement Rings: Expectation vs. Reality! 6
  • Laura
    Rockstar November 2019
    Laura ·
    *quad cut*
    grr. Fat fingers.
  • Samantha
    Savvy October 2020
    Samantha ·
    I wanted a pear shaped diamond but ended up with this beauty. I love it so much more. 😍

    Engagement Rings: Expectation vs. Reality! 7
  • V
    Savvy November 2019
    Victoria ·
    Oh my gosh! His pick is so pretty!

    My FH and I tried my “dream setting” on at the Jewelers but under the lighting I felt that double diamonds crossing bands was a bit too flashy. He bought me my dream setting but surprised me by customizing it with half rose gold. The original has rose gold in the gallery or under area of the center stone so it was a great modification choice. I’m beyond obsessed! A pic of the expectation is on top with reality on the bottom!

    I think its so special when it’s a slightly different then what we thought we wanted!

    Engagement Rings: Expectation vs. Reality! 8

    Engagement Rings: Expectation vs. Reality! 9
  • Jasmine
    Rockstar August 2020
    Jasmine Online ·
    I've always wanted a 3 stone ring. Always fascinated with them. Turns out that when FH proposed, it was with the same exact ring I saw. He had a friend get the dirt on what my dream ring would be. She went back to him with the details so he could get it. I absolutely adore it.




    Engagement Rings: Expectation vs. Reality! 10
  • Lisa Marie
    Devoted October 2020
    Lisa Marie ·

    Before we got engaged, FH and I went to Tiffany's and I fell in love with a beautiful aquamarine center stone, with a double halo of diamonds, approx. $10,000. We both knew that was absolutely ridiculous and I searched Etsy to find something for affordable. He ended having my ring custom made; aquamarine center stone, with a halo of blue diamond and a halo of diamonds. I love it and have never seen anything else like it! Just a few weeks ago FH and I went to Tiffany's because I broke my necklace and needed to buy and new one and also get some other items cleaned. We looked around and we both fell in love with the Tiffany Setting engagement ring. FH stated that he is going to up grade my current ring to the Tiffany Setting before we get married next year! I'm so excited. My original ring will always have a special place in my heart and I will continue to wear with pride.

  • Chandra
    Master May 2019
    Chandra ·
    I love love love rings with a bezel so those were the inspo ones I had been sending H.
    But I love my e ring even more! It helps the center stone was given to H by my dad and had belonged to my late grandfather. I was the only granddaughter he had the chance to meet and know so I was his girl.

    Engagement Rings: Expectation vs. Reality! 11

    Engagement Rings: Expectation vs. Reality! 12
  • Miranda
    Dedicated September 2020
    Miranda ·
    The ring you envisioned is the exact ring I got. And I envisioned more of like the ring you recieved
  • Andrea
    Expert May 2020
    Andrea ·
    Yes! And I was really worried because I thought I picked out my dream ring with my ex fiancé, but this ring is so much more than anything I could have dreamed. My future husband did so much work and put so much time and effort into the perfect diamond and ring. I couldn’t be happier 💗💗
  • Megan
    Super November 2020
    Megan ·
    That’s exactly what I had envisioned, as well. We also got engaged without a ring, so we were able to design it together. I never thought I would want something other than a round stone, but as soon as I put the pear on I knew this was it!

    Engagement Rings: Expectation vs. Reality! 13
  • Kaitlin
    Beginner July 2020
    Kaitlin ·

    At first my ring wasn't what I had envisioned for myself but FH researched into different rings and styles himself. He thought of my personality and what other types of jewelry I wear (simple and dainty) and went from there. I'm a traditional kind of girl and love simple dainty jewelry so in the end my ring is perfect for me!

  • Cher Horowitz
    Rockstar December 2019
    Cher Horowitz ·
    View Quoted Comment

    I love rings that have a special history! It's very pretty

  • Lynne
    Super October 2020
    Lynne ·
    I thought I wanted something simple and plain. But, as we started looking at rings I fell in love with square halo style.

    Engagement Rings: Expectation vs. Reality! 14

Comment on this discussion

×