172 Reviews
Guest Capacity
Venue Setting

About Watermill Caterers

Caterers of Distinction

Caterers of Distinction

The newly renovated Watermill is Long Island's premier destination for weddings and special events

Stunning ballrooms, luxurious bridal suites, indoor & outdoor chapels and so much more...

As a Scotto Family facility, the Watermill is commited to providing you with innovative cuisine and superior service.

For an celebration that will be remembered for a lifetime, contact the Watermill 631-724-3242


Categories: Wedding Venue

Regions serviced: Long Island

Follow Watermill Caterers on

172 Reviews for Watermill Caterers

out of 5.0
User Photos
todo alt text
todo alt text
todo alt text
Filter reviews by services used:
All Reviews
Cake (23)
Clean Up (23)
Dance Floor (23)
Bridal Suite (22)
Set Up (22)
Bartender(s) (22)
Open Bar (22)
Chairs (22)
China (22)
Linens (22)
Dessert (21)
Flatware (21)
Glassware (21)
Valet (21)
Server(s) (20)
Champagne Toast (20)
Premium Liquor (20)
Barware (20)
Event Planning (19)
Cocktail Reception (18)
Hors d'Oeuvres (18)
Plated (18)
Stations (18)
Wheelchair Access (18)
Indoor (17)
Parking (17)
Lighting/Sound (16)
Liability Insurance (13)
Chocolate Fountain (13)
Uncovered Outdoor (11)
Outside Cake (11)
Liquor License (11)
House Liquor (10)
Event Rentals (9)
In-House Bar (8)
In-House Catering (8)
House Beer (8)
House Wine (8)
Furniture (8)
Tables (8)
Buffet (5)
Signature Drink (5)
Wireless Internet (4)
Specialty Beer (3)
Cash Bar (1)
Sort by:


Many thanks to Brian Fingerman and the staff at the Watermill for doing a SUPERB job making our daughter’s July 28th wedding beyond amazing! Your incredible attention to detail, delectable food so beautifully presented in abundance, and making sure everything ran smoothly from start to finish made this most important event in our lives a truly spectacular evening to remember and treasure. We’re still getting calls from guests saying it was the best wedding ever! We wholeheartedly agree! If you’re planning a wedding or special occasion, call Brian at the Watermill!

Profile Picture Joyce, 7/28/18, 1 Review
Category: Ceremony & Reception Venue

My wife and I couldn't be more happy with our wedding at Watermill Caterers (4/27/18).

Booking with Eric who is no longer there was a pleasure. Everything from the initial tour to discussing our options was relaxed and fun. After Eric left, Tom took over managing our date and he did a wonderful job. He made appropriate recommendations regarding our needs and never tried to up-sell us. We always felt like we were in good hands and that our requests would be met.

The renovations they've done are incredible, if you're looking for clean and modern like we were this place will take your breath away. The menu options (your guests get like 10 choices...what?!) will please any crowd. We got so many compliments on the food, both for the cocktail hour and dinner. Honestly, we can't wait to be invited to a wedding here so we can enjoy it as guests too!

The day of our wedding was perfect. Our maitre'd Sean was on top of everything and I'm convinced he can be in three places at once - a true professional. The bridal attendant Jessica was extremely attentive, warm, and kind. The rest of the staff was always smiling and we heard nothing but compliments from our friends and family regarding their waitstaff. They placed our decorations exactly how we wanted (even better than we had imagined in some instances!) and really make the place look amazing.

We couldn't recommend this place enough. To everyone at the Watermill, THANK YOU!

Megan & Lawrence

Profile Picture Lawrence, 4/27/18, 9 Reviews
Category: Ceremony & Reception Venue
Services Used: Parking, Valet, Wheelchair Access, In-House Bar, Cake, In-House Catering, Clean Up, Event Planning, Event Rentals, Bridal Suite, Liability Insurance, Lighting/Sound, Set Up, Wireless Internet, Barware, China, Chocolate Fountain, Flatware, Glassware, Linens, Chairs, Dance Floor, Furniture, Tables, Indoor, Dessert, Hors d'Oeuvres, Plated, Server(s), Stations, Bartender(s), Champagne Toast, Open Bar, Premium Liquor, Signature Drink, Specialty Beer

Watermill Caterers Pricing

Wedding Catering Avg. Price Per Person
Bar Service Price Includes:
Champagne Toast
House Liquor
House Wine
Open Bar
Premium Liquor
Signature Drink
Specialty Beer
Specialty Wine

Watermill Caterers FAQ

Venue Highlights
Maximum Capacity
Guest Minimum
Event Spaces
Ballroom, Banquet Hall
Classic, Elegant, Luxury
Indoor, Uncovered Outdoor
Bridal Shower
Engagement Party
Rehearsal Dinner
Bridal Suite
Clean Up
Event Planning
Event Rentals
In-House Bar
In-House Catering
Liability Insurance
Set Up
Wireless Internet
All Inclusive Packages
Outside Vendors
Pet Friendly
Preferred Vendors Only
Cocktail Reception
Hors d'Oeuvres
Outside Cake
Family Style
French Service
Champagne Toast
House Beer
House Liquor
House Wine
Liquor License
Open Bar
Premium Liquor
Signature Drink
Specialty Beer
Cash Bar
Limited Bar
Outside Alcohol
Specialty Wine
Dance Floor
Aisle Markers
Aisle Runners
Audio Equipment
Chair Covers
Tent Accessories
Chocolate Fountain
Wheelchair Access

Photos & Videos

63 Photos

Watermill Caterers

63 Photos
220x220 sq 1495036449981 kj8716 cm18
220x220 sq 1475519694416 bw17317
220x220 sq 1514911576668 watermill
220x220 sq 1514911552243 2041430715736542926549862381860446346233786o
220x220 sq 1514911544040 2037611215736543526549808081255999358734625n
220x220 sq 1495036420396 dsc9552 1
220x220 sq 1514911569242 2327545916800527186818098050114313183344873o
220x220 sq 1462196383017 wm 8
220x220 sq 1462196349627 wm 2
220x220 sq 1495036399789 1374409013999012700386631786808414n
220x220 sq 1495036406329 1444483111696386364349486744585258224665071o
220x220 sq 1475519622261 bw17259
220x220 sq 1462196370825 wm 6
220x220 sq 1495036577501 wm by marco photo
220x220 sq 1495036466194 kj8716 cm22
220x220 sq 1475519623190 bw17267
220x220 sq 1462196365176 wm 5
220x220 sq 1495036484745 wm by marco 4
220x220 sq 1475519741827 bw17361
220x220 sq 1475519648207 bw17280
220x220 sq 1463514786494 astor ballroom
220x220 sq 1475519787686 bw17451
220x220 sq 1475519848799 bw17488
220x220 sq 1462196354513 wm 3
220x220 sq 1462196344649 wm 1
220x220 sq 1495036615153 wm by marco
220x220 sq 1475519764618 bw17445
220x220 sq 1475519717291 bw17336
220x220 sq 1475520007097 updated astor
220x220 sq 1475519982146 neo6610
220x220 sq 1475519913085 bw23584
220x220 sq 1415822081309 gazebowatermill165
220x220 sq 1415822125604 outdoorchapellwithpetals0
220x220 sq 1415822184667 patioversion2137 1
220x220 sq 1415822139339 outdoorentrance314 2
220x220 sq 1396886311344 lobb
220x220 sq 1463514947253 img6335
220x220 sq 1462196334234 125096058761063758210432786053905073045155n
220x220 sq 1462196316114 1246955210311207402892698007266093903998783o
220x220 sq 1462196327997 1249624110311203669559738667909725822519441o
220x220 sq 1463514783163 img6425 hdr ed
220x220 sq 1463514892799 neo7808ed
220x220 sq 1463515012046 neo7842
220x220 sq 1475519827776 bw17486
220x220 sq 1475519872247 bw23572
220x220 sq 1475519891253 bw23583
220x220 sq 1475519936031 bw23605
220x220 sq 1475519957594 bw23629
220x220 sq 1495036412862 1473115412629045704066724568012364169262683n
220x220 sq 1495036434619 hg   pj   tina  chris   2016 10 22 387 2
220x220 sq 1495036441627 hg   pj   tina  chris   2016 10 22 448 2
220x220 sq 1495036514638 wm by marco photo 2
220x220 sq 1495036548590 wm by marco photo 3
220x220 sq 1514911544034 1909547815236759609861531946631768315143175o
220x220 sq 1514911561287 2254990516572406109630203494572146392521500n
220x220 sq 1514911638457 1444483111696386364349486744585258224665071o
220x220 sq 1514911638544 1473115412629045704066724568012364169262683n
220x220 sq 1514911645920 de ja vu studio
220x220 sq 1514911653230 kj8716 cm18
220x220 sq 1514911683727 live picture studios katherine  neil
220x220 sq 1514911694044 maureen  david deja vu studios
220x220 sq 1514911705228 tj51317 cm 0995
220x220 sq 1514911721275 tj51317 cm 2388


Professional Network & Endorsements

The Watermill has been like family to us for many years. The recent updates are just beautiful. Food is amazing and the staff and management are wonderful to work with. Highly recommend.

You must see this venue! All the rooms have been renovated and have bright modern look. The world class chef brings different approach fine dining (ask about the bacon bar)! Remember to check out the indoor outdoor cocktail area too. They also have many places to take photographs!

Watermill Caterers provides memorable events - great people to work with.

We are located on the grounds of the watermill, the new decor and facility changes are beyond beautiful. We are a recommended vendor at watermill and the staff is always accommodating and friendly, we highly recommend the watermill for all events.


711 Smithtown Bypass, Smithtown, NY 11787   See On Map
631-724-3242 (phone)
Watermill Caterers is a wedding venue from Long Island servicing weddings throughout the local area, including Suffolk County, Nassau County, and Queens & Brooklyn. Watermill Caterers is a professional caterer that has been part of the Long Island wedding industry since 1996 specializing in receptions and ceremonies.