Skip to main content
Weddings
ARE YOU A VENDOR?
Susan's Sugar & Spice
Susan's Sugar & Spice
Classic white with pink flowers
Classic white with pink flowers
First Place @ IX Center
First Place @ IX Center
Chocolate drizzle
Chocolate drizzle
Topped with fresh fruit
Topped with fresh fruit
An elegant three-tiered cake
An elegant three-tiered cake
Red-ribbon accents
Red-ribbon accents
A four-layered wedding cake
A four-layered wedding cake
An ocean theme
An ocean theme

Interested in this vendor?

Cupcake platter

About

Susan’s Sugar & Spice is a wedding cake bakery located in Avon Lake, Ohio. Founder, Susan St. Aubyn-Zeyer specializes in delicious and heartwarming desserts made from scratch. Susan’s enthusiasm for baking began at a young age, inspiring her to perfect her recipes and share them with couples celebrating their once-in-a-lifetime occasion. With a distinct focus on achieving delectable flavor profiles, Susan’s Sugar & Spice provides a sweet addition to any wedding celebration.

Services Offered

Susan’s artfully crafted desserts are made to order for each wedding. Beyond providing her delightful desserts, Susan also offers cooking classes for wedding showers and other wedding-related events. Some of the services and selections offered by Susan’s Sugar & Spice include:

  • Consultations and private cake tastings
  • Order delivery and setup
  • Cupcakes and pastries
  • Lactose and nut-free options
  • Sweet wedding favors
  • Woman-owned
illustration popular

Vendors you may like

See other vendors that are popular with couples right now

Lizzie’s Bakery Nut Free
Lizzie's Bakery Nut Free
Lizzie's Bakery Nut Free
Lizzie's Bakery Nut Free
Lizzie’s Bakery Nut Free
Cleveland, OH
$300 starting price
Chef Gina's Bakeshop
Gold Stars
Dessert Table
Butterflies
Chef Gina's Bakeshop
5.0 (29) ·
Akron, OH
$4 starting price

Award winner

Omalicha Custom Cakes & Confectionery
Vintage Style Cake
Sugar Effects Wedding Cake
Couture Wedding Cake
Omalicha Custom Cakes & Confectionery
5.0 (16) ·
Stow, OH
$350 starting price

Award winner

Love Bites Cake Pop Co
Simple black and gold
5th Birthday Police theme
Axolotl Birthday order
Love Bites Cake Pop Co
5.0 (3) ·
Eastlake, OH
$25 starting price
Buehler's Catering
Grazing
Serving
Dining
Buehler's Catering
4.8 (32) ·
Wooster, OH
$1,000 starting price

Frequently asked questions

What is the starting price for wedding cakes with buttercream frosting (per slice, without tax)?

$3

Which of the following are included in the cost of the cake?

Top Tier of the Cake

What is the starting price for cupcakes (per cupcake, without tax)?

$3

What services do your prices include?

Consultation
Custom Cake Design
Delivery
Set Up
Tastings - Private

What types of desserts do you provide?

Cupcakes
Groom's Cake
Pastries

What services do you provide?

Consultations
Custom Design
Delivery
Setup
Tastings - Private

What cake items do you provide?

Cake Stands

What dietary needs can you accommodate?

Lactose Free

What special ingredients do you use?

Fresh Fruit

Are you licensed by the state health department?

Yes

Reviews of Susan's Sugar & Spice

Write a review
Write a review
Susan's Sugar & Spice - 1
Susan's Sugar & Spice - 2
Susan's Sugar & Spice - 3
+3 User photos
Susan's Sugar & Spice - 4
Camryn
Camryn Sent on 07/12/2020
5 out of 5 rating

You NEED to hire Susan for your baker!!

This is honestly, hands down, the best cake I’ve ever tasted!! I hate whipped frosting, but trusted her anyways. Went to the cake tasting and boy oh boy I’ve never tasted anything so delicious! The cake literally melts in your mouth. The whipped frosting is so light, it compliments the moist cake so well, making the cake not dense at all. She cares about more than just providing you a cake. With the shutdown, I came to the mall to see if the jewelry store was open and it wasn’t, and she told me she would call me when the store opened so I didn’t have to drive back up there! My experience with Susan was nothing short of amazing.

Photo credit to Lindsey Poyar Photography
  • Susan's Sugar & Spice - 5
S
Samara Sent on 03/26/2023
5 out of 5 rating

The Best Cake

Susan was wonderful! The cake was perfect and her service was far more than we could have ever hoped for. We recommend her highly!
  • Susan's Sugar & Spice - 6
Holly
Holly Sent on 05/20/2021
5 out of 5 rating

Delicious and beautiful

The cake was absolutely delicious and the flavor choices we had to choose from were vast. Susan helped us decide on size and flavors as well as loaning us a fun tablecloth to help showcase the cake.
  • Susan's Sugar & Spice - 7
A
Ashaunta Sent on 11/22/2020
5 out of 5 rating

Great Cake

Susan was great to work with, we had a beautiful cake that tasted great.
Sara
Sara Sent on 10/12/2020
5 out of 5 rating

Best Tasting Cake

The cake is so good, literally at the tasting we could have went with all of the flavors if that was an option.
Our cake was pina colada and it was amazing. We also did mini cupcakes and had zero left because they were that good.
Awesome cake exceptional service
  • Susan's Sugar & Spice - 8
Izzy
Izzy Sent on 10/05/2019
5 out of 5 rating

Best Flavor of Them All

We met Susan at the Today’s Bride show at the IX center. Her moist cake and wide variety of flavors sold us, she had the best cake in the joint! We had a small cake for cutting that turned out amazing, as well as cake squares in several different flavors. I definitely recommend Susan for any event!
  • Susan's Sugar & Spice - 9
  • Susan's Sugar & Spice - 10
T
Tracey Sent on 12/13/2015
5 out of 5 rating
Susan was awesome... Professional, flexible, and so reasonably priced. Her cakes are second to none!!!
F
Kara Sent on 07/14/2015
5 out of 5 rating
Our experience with Susan's Sugar and Spice was amazing! All of our guests raved about our cake, and we loved it too! We can't wait until our 1-year anniversary to eat the top layer! Susan is so easy to work with. She is very flexible and has great ideas, which for an indecisive person like me is very helpful. She took the time to get to know us as a couple and was able to make a cake for us that we both loved. I would recommend Susan to anyone, we will definitely use her again whether it be for a baby shower, anniversary, birthday, or whatever! She is that good.
V
Vanessa Sent on 12/22/2014
5 out of 5 rating
Ive ordered cakes from Susan for years & they are absolutely wonderful! Her butter cream frosting is delicious & so creamy! The cakes are always moist & taste great, no matter what flavor. You can even work with her to create your own flavor if you choose. She's always very accommodating & presents her cakes/desserts beautifully! And her prices are great too...cheaper, if not the cheapest than most bakeries!!
S
Sachi Sent on 10/22/2014
5 out of 5 rating
Susan was wonderful from the moment we first spoke. She brought a variety of cake for us yo choose from and the one we decided on was out of this world. We chose butter pecan. Not one guest didn't LOVE it. The cake was just what we pictured and tasted even better. I highly recommend Susan as your baker.
We're all about trust. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.
Read all reviews

Awards

22
WeddingWire Couples' Choice Awards 2016 Winner

Explore other vendors in your area

Find the most recommended vendors and Couples' Choice Award winners.

See vendors

Professional Network & Endorsements

1 Endorsement
Consider It Done Consider It Done Wedding Planners

Susan is both professional and very talented in her baking and decorating skills. Always willing to go above and beyond for her clients, love to work with her always fun and easy!

Map

Addresses map
Cakes Cleveland
Cakes Elyria
Next Wedding Cakes: Colozza's Bakery

Other vendors in Cleveland for your wedding

Wedding Vendors