Susan’s Sugar & Spice is a wedding cake bakery located in Elyria, Ohio. Founder, Susan St. Aubyn-Zeyer specializes in delicious and heartwarming desserts made from scratch. Susan’s enthusiasm for baking began at a young age, inspiring her to perfect her recipes and share them with couples celebrating their once-in-a-lifetime occasion. With a distinct focus on achieving delectable flavor profiles, Susan’s Sugar & Spice provides a sweet addition to any wedding celebration.
Susan’s artfully crafted desserts are made to order for each wedding. Beyond providing her delightful desserts, Susan also offers cooking classes for wedding showers and other wedding-related events. Some of the services and selections offered by Susan’s Sugar & Spice include:
18 Reviews for Susan's Sugar & Spice
Recommended by 88% of couples
3 User photos
Camryn · Married on 07/11/2020
You NEED to hire Susan for your baker!!
This is honestly, hands down, the best cake I’ve ever tasted!! I hate whipped frosting, but trusted her anyways. Went to the cake tasting and boy oh boy I’ve never tasted anything so delicious! The cake literally melts in your mouth. The whipped frosting is so light, it compliments the moist cake so well, making the cake not dense at all. She cares about more than just providing you a cake. With the shutdown, I came to the mall to see if the jewelry store was open and it wasn’t, and she told me she would call me when the store opened so I didn’t have to drive back up there! My experience with Susan was nothing short of amazing.
Photo credit to Lindsey Poyar PhotographySent on 07/12/2020
Izzy McBride · Married on 10/04/2019
Best Flavor of Them All
We met Susan at the Today’s Bride show at the IX center. Her moist cake and wide variety of flavors sold us, she had the best cake in the joint! We had a small cake for cutting that turned out amazing, as well as cake squares in several different flavors. I definitely recommend Susan for any event!Sent on 10/05/2019
Vanessa · Married on 09/18/2015
Ive ordered cakes from Susan for years & they are absolutely wonderful! Her butter cream frosting is delicious & so creamy! The cakes are always moist & taste great, no matter what flavor. You can even work with her to create your own flavor if you choose. She's always very accommodating & presents her cakes/desserts beautifully! And her prices are great too...cheaper, if not the cheapest than most bakeries!!Sent on 12/22/2014
Susan is both professional and very talented in her baking and decorating skills. Always willing to go above and beyond for her clients, love to work with her always fun and easy!