Plum Street Gourmet is a full-service custom caterer with over 30 years of experience serving Lancaster, Pennsylvania. Anne Eshelman and her team are known for combining top quality ingredients with exceptional presentation, customer service and attention to detail. Plum Street Gourmet allows for complete customization of the menu to match each couple’s individual style and taste.
Whether you have dietary needs or are looking to have unique tasting stations, Plum Street Gourmet is your full-service catering company with a variety of flavor and serving options to choose from. This caterer is available for the following cuisine styles:
Plum Street Gourmet also offers:
Recommended by 98% of couples
6 User photos
Ali · Married on 10/13/2018
Our first and final pick for our wedding catering!
Ashley and her team at Plum Street Gourmet were a standout gem among our vendors! Ashley was so receptive to our wants and needs for our wedding, and was so friendly and easy to work with. Her calm and professional demeanor gave us complete peace of mind with our investment in Plum Street- we knew we could trust our wedding dinner to run smoothly and be memorable and delicious because we knew we could trust Ashley! Weeks after our special day, we are still receiving compliments on the dinner, and we have some very discerning palates among our family and friends! Thank you so much to Plum Street for such a wonderful experience on our wedding day!Sent on 10/26/2018
Plum Street Gourmet's reply:Thank you Ali! This is so kind of you to say. It was our pleasure! All the best to you and Brian!
Adrienne · Married on 09/22/2018
Caterer that goes above and beyond
Ashley and Plum Street Gourmet are hands down amazing. They catered my wedding and Ashley assisted with day-of coordinating. The food was delicious. The wait-staff were courteous and professional. Event set up was organized, well-done and beautiful. Ashley even carried around our 1.5 year old toddler in 110 degree heat, walking around with him on her hip, filling waters, making sure everyone had what they needed. I couldn't have asked for a better wedding catering experience!Sent on 07/23/2019
Ann · Married on 03/17/2018
We chose Plum Street Gourmet to cater a post-nuptial wedding dinner buffet for our relatives in the Pennsylvania/Maryland/Virginia/Delaware area this past weekend. All planning had to be done long distance, and we were so appreciative of how helpful and accommodating the Catering Director was! All her recommendations for menu choices and all other details and arrangements were perfect. The staff who worked the event were extremely efficient and friendly, and guests all expressed how much they enjoyed the delicious food, especially the sliced tenderloin of beef!Sent on 03/19/2018
We have worked with Ann for many years and have loved her wonderful expertise. Plum Street Gourmet is always dependable and food delicious.