Incredible! Ordered 9 dozen assorted donuts for our wedding instead of cake/cupcakes. Way more cost effective and way more delicious. There were none left by the end of the night! Ordering was simple, cost was reasonable, and pick-up was easy. They also looked beautiful!

We got the cupcake tower for our wedding. They made a little cake for us (bride and groom) and put it on top. It was beautiful and delicious!

My husband and I both don't actually like cake, so we decided to use Paul's Bakery to have doughnuts at our wedding and they were amazing! People raved about them all night!
But since it was our wedding night we also ordered a small lemon cake to have the tradition of cutting the cake together and the cake was TERRIBLE! When my friend picked it up for me she called me to ask if I wanted her to get another cake from Wegman's since the one from Paul's was so bad. I said no because I didn't think it could have been too bad, but in hindsight I wish I would have. I didn't see the cake until I showed up to the reception and I literally laughed out loud at how pathetic looking it was. It was a small cake, which is what we ordered, but it was lopsided and looked like it was going to fall off the cake stand at any moment. When my husband and I cut the cake and fed it to each other I wanted to spit it out because it tasted so bad. What we ordered wasn't from their "wedding" selection of cakes, but I expect a bakery to send out every cake looking nice and tasting good and ours just didn't.
We LOVED having Paul's doughnuts for our wedding, but if you're looking for a cake probably go elsewhere.