We absolutely loved our cake from Ithaca Bakery! It looked stunning and more importantly, tasted amazing!! We went with a golden layer cake with lemon buttercream frosting and raspberry jam filling and it was definitely a crowd pleaser! They made our unique vision come to life and it was so easy coordinating with Carley, the bakery manager. The pricing was reasonable and we had the cake delivered, which is recommended for a 3-tier cake, but made the process so easy for us. They even coordinated directly with the venue and changed the delivery time last minute to make sure it arrived on time.

Ithaca Bakery was a great find for our DIY barn wedding. They supplied food (with chefs and serving staff), bartender, linens, plates, and silverware - and it was all incredibly affordable. Our catering manager, Shannon, was amazing - so accommodating and responsive. Our guests loved the food, as much as we did!

I've been going to the Ithaca Bakery my entire life so I knew they had to be a part of the special day. I hired them to make two kinds of cupcakes and a cake for my wedding in October. Months prior to the wedding they were so accommodating with answering all my questions and updating the menu several times. When it came to the wedding, everything went smoothly. There were no issues and everything tasted amazing! I'm so glad I was able to book them and it meant so much to be able to share this special place with all my loved ones. Definitely would 100% recommend booking them for your wedding!

Ithaca Bakery is so much more than just your catering company! If you’re lucky enough to work with Niki, your wedding planning will be a breeze. She is super friendly and knowledgeable. She is patient and has brilliant ideas for your big day. She will be with you for every step of the planning process to make sure nothing is left out! We are so thankful for her and the rest of the crew that was there for our wedding day! They were fast and efficient and did whatever necessary to make sure ourselves and guests were happy. The food itself was simply amazing! Our guests raved about it all! Our overall experience exceeded our expectations and we wouldn’t hesitate to recommend them to anyone for any event needing catering!

Ithaca Bakery did a fantastic job with our cake! The floral decorations were exactly what we envisioned and the cake itself was absolutely delicious; everyone was asking who our vendor was! Their options are great as well; we were having trouble deciding what combination of flavors to go for. In the end, we had an almond flavored cake with chocolate ganache. It was absolutely superb! They were so easy to work with, both with determining decorations and working out pricing. We picked our cake up as our venue was a bit out of the way. The employees there were very helpful with telling us how to transport the cake without having it tip over in the car or on the way into the venue. Definitely recommend them for your bakery needs!

Ithaca Bakery became the unofficial caterer of the entire wedding weekend that my friends, family and I spent in Ithaca. We ate it for breakfast on our set up and wedding day. They also ended up baking our cake at the last minute which turned out perfectly and was extremely delicious. And then finally they actually catered our morning after brunch at Treman. We did a buffet of bagels, muffins, pastries, fruit, coffee and juice and everything was wonderful. They came in and set up without me even knowing so when my husband and I woke up everything was ready to go. Our more-than-slightly hungover guests were very pleased.

defiantly the BEST wedding cake! tasted so good and everyone loved the cake! It looks exactly like the one we designed! highly recommend ithaca bakery for the wedding cake!

Cake was more beautiful than we could have imagined, and tasted amazing.

Cake was more beautiful than we could have imagined, and tasted amazing.

We sought out Ithaca Bakery primarily for our wedding cake, but also ended up using them to cater our wedding related wine tour-- and both choices were well made! We started with a very positive experience with cake tasting. While We knew what kind of 'look' we were going for, we were fairly deeply divided on taste preferences. Though it may seem obvious to some, given that we had selected a two-level cake, it was a revelation to have our coordinator Heather suggest NOT compromising-- and making one level 'his' and one level 'hers'. To me, this was genius and something I had not considered as a viable option. With this idea, we efficiently concluded our plans and waited on our cake.

In the mean time, plans were evolving that required some sort of snack/lunch catering service. We went to Ithaca Bakery in hopes that they could simplify our lives once again and we received variety platters ( one cheese board, one hoagie platter) that delighted our guests (and our wallets). We were impressed with the quality of the items we received!