My husband grew up near Rhinebeck and his family has eaten at Gigi's for many years, so when we decided to get married in the same area they were our first choice for a caterer. We had a fantastic tasting with them early on in the process, and they were very flexible about changing and adding items to our menu, especially since my husband has a number of food allergies and we had some vegetarians and vegans on our guest list. On the wedding day itself they were absolutely fantastic. We had a barn wedding and the Gigi staff somehow managed to produce the most delicious meal for 175 people out of a mobile kitchen. We got so, so many compliments on the food, including the pie bar we had for dessert. Their wine selection was also great. My mom and stepdad are even planning to go back to their restaurant and "recreate" the wedding meal by ordering the same items we had!
The only downside of our experience with Gigi is that unfortunately during the year leading up to our wedding, they lost a number of their staff on the catering management side, so our contact person there changed four times, and as a result it was sometimes hard to get answers to our questions or arrange meetings with them. Eventually my day-of coordinator took over dealing with them. But, everything was absolutely perfect on my wedding day and that's what matters! I would definitely recommend them.