Creative Cakes

16649 Oak Park Ave. Unit F, Suite 355, Tinley Park, Illinois 60477 Map · Phone number · Visit website
Hired? Save
  • Photos 288
  • About
  • Reviews 219
  • FAQs
  • Network

About Creative Cakes

Creative Cakes is a bakery in Naperville, Illinois that will create a wedding cake to will wow you and your guests. Sister-duo Becky Palermo and Beth Fahey are some of the most sought-after cake designers in the area because of their simple yet elegant styles.

Services Offered
Creative Cakes has decorated more than 5,000 cakes in the last 15 years. The highly talented staff will work with you to choose a cake and design that fits your wedding theme and style. Each design can be customized for you by using local ingredients and flavors. You can meet with them during a consultation, and on the day of your event, they will deliver and set up your wedding cake with a cake stand, if needed. In additional to traditional wedding cakes, they can make other wedding desserts, including:

  • Cookies
  • Croquembouche
  • Cupcakes
  • Fruit
  • Groom's cake
  • Pastries
Follow Creative Cakes on
screen shot 2016 01 13 at 3 04 15 pm
Creative Cakes
2e241bad5533cdd6 1451598488154 screen shot 2015 12 31 at 3 46 27 pm
Creative Cakes
Three-tier cake
Three-tier cake
Multicolored cake
Multicolored cake
Black and teal
Black and teal
Three-layer cake
Three-layer cake
White cake
White cake
Pink cake
Pink cake
White flowers
White flowers
Lavender cake
Lavender cake
Five-layer cake
Five-layer cake
White and green
White and green
Two layers
Two layers
Wood design
Wood design
Simple design
Simple design
Sporty
Sporty
Gold accent
Gold accent
Barrel-like
Barrel-like
White and gold
White and gold
Silver cake
Silver cake
White cake
White cake
White and peach
White and peach
screen shot 2016 01 13 at 2 59 29 pm
Creative Cakes
6325656939edf2f41a56o
Creative Cakes
61700283825500239036o
Creative Cakes
6156722180c89b76b152o
Creative Cakes
6156195421ce3330e867o
Creative Cakes
6173280244ba70ba2531o
Creative Cakes
6636706773b725438215o
Creative Cakes
6172753747488bc81185o
Creative Cakes
6169495529e6ceac6c4ao
Creative Cakes
619521579415312391bbo
Creative Cakes
69240234173fcdd95cbdo
Creative Cakes
61732733723cb087e20fo
Creative Cakes
6173270648bc9d1c0a7bo
Creative Cakes
6173276642cdcb5975cfo
Creative Cakes
6172755205eaf31a8571o
Creative Cakes
615616957965fc9c2dfdo
Creative Cakes
6156168665f5332d5ca5o
Creative Cakes
6156741910c946408fa2o
Creative Cakes
61567426981326b1b7d3o
Creative Cakes
6169497661a9df36ae4co
Creative Cakes
6169498463bc0660e450o
Creative Cakes
6807275177a321c43c8ao
Creative Cakes
61700340262f334f6752o
Creative Cakes
6170028584ced998f051o
Creative Cakes
617327268670e2490380o
Creative Cakes
6172745355d0f0f1f261o
Creative Cakes
6172752475221fb02426o
Creative Cakes
6172764593e55404c60fo
Creative Cakes
620081968494ae16d58bo
Creative Cakes
6924023503a801fb9aa8o
Creative Cakes
6777955534caaf95eb58o
Creative Cakes
black fondant
Creative Cakes
dsc04629
Creative Cakes
rose gold custom
Creative Cakes
mistwood wedding cake
Creative Cakes
draping and lace
Creative Cakes
61694928592f48ba0be0o
Creative Cakes
quilting damask
Creative Cakes
screen shot 2015 12 30 at 9 58 06 am
Creative Cakes
10730766893c23b48d72do
Creative Cakes
7349435208988827c114b
Creative Cakes
wooden barrel
Creative Cakes
6156726886eff0fd64d0o
Creative Cakes
615672491667977b8db1o
Creative Cakes
61560822737cb48e359bo
Creative Cakes
6172742589b4fb508ec3o
Creative Cakes
67777740305b20d85445o
Creative Cakes
6807263343031bdf455ao
Creative Cakes
67777920965d54790f40o
Creative Cakes
gatsby crop
Creative Cakes
embossed quilting bling
Creative Cakes
chicago skyline
Creative Cakes
clean with bling
Creative Cakes
fondant pearls
Creative Cakes
smooth with gold quin
Creative Cakes
238084327916c7879d588k
Creative Cakes
pearls fondant draping
Creative Cakes
85028823591701e7c57fo
Creative Cakes
62843224380350ab7f64o
Creative Cakes
836846414054f795910fo
Creative Cakes
6172747447bf1caa3441o
Creative Cakes
617276205753f4776b70o
Creative Cakes
61727440798aff636687o
Creative Cakes
61727636075d198acbbco
Creative Cakes
617328223808684a6dd0o
Creative Cakes
6173277600d6c31fbb15o
Creative Cakes
61561901433843ca03d9o
Creative Cakes
6172743297a906d15c30o
Creative Cakes
61732921822620c8a3c7o
Creative Cakes
6836039672bb6cabc5f7o
Creative Cakes
615671208621123d2d40o
Creative Cakes
61561746213362399b9ao
Creative Cakes
6173276404b198b7c85ao
Creative Cakes
61561787313724676913o
Creative Cakes
6173277936ab08aebaeeo
Creative Cakes
71193773490afde07a3eo
Creative Cakes
615617663104266ff5a4o
Creative Cakes
615617953700e32e0db5o
Creative Cakes
61695005674628210169o
Creative Cakes
61561930439af6f90476o
Creative Cakes
692390513145fff5c9e8o
Creative Cakes
617002709271c5ca3b0do
Creative Cakes
61003659862a5675fe63o
Creative Cakes
5458987494228c4ddf21o
Creative Cakes
5458994938ec9dafbfa8o
Creative Cakes
5459024078eb6d049e4co
Creative Cakes
6170032996d894cc12fdo
Creative Cakes
61700309681c147d25c3o
Creative Cakes
6099821241f331267aeco
Creative Cakes
6156167287177d5d788eo
Creative Cakes
6156184475095306d233o
Creative Cakes
61003662186474ed72f6o
Creative Cakes
61727628053bc374c4b3o
Creative Cakes
6173279274ae5798f280o
Creative Cakes
61727588599f5e127e37o
Creative Cakes
82916307597376414ec2o
Creative Cakes
62008193669a7f0d44f7o
Creative Cakes
68471334727b65f743cbo
Creative Cakes
6847155704ec49f16ce2o
Creative Cakes
69932805379b371ecdc1o
Creative Cakes
72979332948654046be8o
Creative Cakes
73494357324ecd1f2e44o
Creative Cakes
79556614627002fa65bfo
Creative Cakes
8367758225426b7cff6ao
Creative Cakes
8368373696a654b8a07co
Creative Cakes
851832628728aa705432o
Creative Cakes
smooth buttercream
Creative Cakes
buttercream roses detail
Creative Cakes
almost naked
Creative Cakes
birch bark
Creative Cakes
horo floral cascade
Creative Cakes
dots rosettes with pearls
Creative Cakes
horo notre dame
Creative Cakes
spring scrolls
Creative Cakes
cornelli lace
Creative Cakes
horo with rosettes glitter
Creative Cakes
mixed tiers
Creative Cakes
clean gold bling rosettes
Creative Cakes
lucy 2017
Creative Cakes
rustic with rosettes
Creative Cakes
texture large rosettes
Creative Cakes
rosettes 3dot
Creative Cakes
horo gold
Creative Cakes
6172759659c22c70882ao
Creative Cakes
61732814743178bebc9bo
Creative Cakes
56200567060d0a42ac66o
Creative Cakes
61727631237e570a9a77o
Creative Cakes
6172760447e71e760ba1o
Creative Cakes
61727458352d0769a0b2o
Creative Cakes
56200563526fc4ac45ddo
Creative Cakes
61561822657475565639o
Creative Cakes
6156172081436b19bc74o
Creative Cakes
6156169811fcafba7f64o
Creative Cakes
61561946618c68bdb2b0o
Creative Cakes
61567256145084434d76o
Creative Cakes
6156718172c439944f0ao
Creative Cakes
6156736460bdd4d19c65o
Creative Cakes
615617085388e13b74cfo
Creative Cakes
5619470267a8973b870ao
Creative Cakes
6156729466d74270959eo
Creative Cakes
6156176901cf11c95a1fo
Creative Cakes
6156185233ed157f2e72o
Creative Cakes
6170031852cc2b6edd5eo
Creative Cakes
6156721960acc0e536dfo
Creative Cakes
6156717404801d6cd796o
Creative Cakes
5620061238dd282a6a55o
Creative Cakes
61561682134c7e8bf5b4o
Creative Cakes
6156167991594f2a8edfo
Creative Cakes
6156169115bf2302beb1o
Creative Cakes
6156171871f237b506bao
Creative Cakes
61732760980c1b97a879o
Creative Cakes
615673219888c9abc2fao
Creative Cakes
6173293628018992b7a7o
Creative Cakes
545899623436ed78538bo
Creative Cakes
545901914418f7508034o
Creative Cakes
54584134435d4538c59bo
Creative Cakes
617274722513a2a5b1c8o
Creative Cakes
562005609694b9a7556bo
Creative Cakes
6156178465b5f9211efeo
Creative Cakes
6156173273e401d6ce8fo
Creative Cakes
6156725166fb973096eeo
Creative Cakes
617275437994e9a2fe31o
Creative Cakes
680727489145b08be5f3o
Creative Cakes
6170034952abb7d30909o
Creative Cakes
6170034520ae4df4e373o
Creative Cakes
617274480324de1d85d1o
Creative Cakes
roses and pearls in pink
Creative Cakes
screen shot 2016 01 13 at 3 05 04 pm
Creative Cakes
custom scrolling
Creative Cakes
stephanie
Creative Cakes
bling buttercream
Creative Cakes
rustic stripes
Creative Cakes
dreamcatcher
Creative Cakes
quilting buttercream with pearls
Creative Cakes
floral burlap lace
Creative Cakes
tree trunk
Creative Cakes
chandelier with gp roses
Creative Cakes
jaime with ribbon
Creative Cakes
monogram lace flowers
Creative Cakes
line work bling flowers
Creative Cakes
metallic silver horo
Creative Cakes
fabulous
Creative Cakes
freehand floral vining
Creative Cakes
screen shot 2016 01 13 at 3 03 55 pm
Creative Cakes
screen shot 2016 01 13 at 3 06 46 pm
Creative Cakes
mixed with ruffles quilting
Creative Cakes
two tone rosettes
Creative Cakes
screen shot 2016 01 13 at 3 01 24 pm
Creative Cakes
beach wedding
Creative Cakes
jamie skyline
Creative Cakes
2012031617231812
Creative Cakes
screen shot 2016 01 13 at 3 07 18 pm
Creative Cakes
2012031617231867
Creative Cakes
2012031617231872
Creative Cakes
2012031617231835
Creative Cakes
2012031617231834
Creative Cakes
2012031617231852
Creative Cakes
2012031617231811
Creative Cakes
2012031617231863
Creative Cakes
201203161723182
Creative Cakes
2012031617231874
Creative Cakes
2012031617231870
Creative Cakes
2012031617231862
Creative Cakes
201203161723184
Creative Cakes
2012031617231822
Creative Cakes
2012031617231880
Creative Cakes
2012031617231839
Creative Cakes
2012031617231825
Creative Cakes
2012031617231824
Creative Cakes
2012031617231844
Creative Cakes
2012031617231857
Creative Cakes
2012031617231836
Creative Cakes
2012031617231817
Creative Cakes
2012031617231865
Creative Cakes
2012031617231841
Creative Cakes
2012031617231818
Creative Cakes
2012031617231875
Creative Cakes
2012031617231854
Creative Cakes
2012031617231816
Creative Cakes
2012031617231877
Creative Cakes
2012031617231840
Creative Cakes
2012031617231838
Creative Cakes
2012031617231869
Creative Cakes
2012031617231871
Creative Cakes
2012031617231864
Creative Cakes
2012031617231876
Creative Cakes
2012031617231851
Creative Cakes
2012031617231832
Creative Cakes
2012031617231833
Creative Cakes
2012031617231846
Creative Cakes
2012031617231826
Creative Cakes
2012031617231879
Creative Cakes
2012031617231873
Creative Cakes
2012031617231813
Creative Cakes
201203161723185
Creative Cakes
2012031617231847
Creative Cakes
2012031617231856
Creative Cakes
2012031617231848
Creative Cakes
2012031617231850
Creative Cakes
2012031617231810
Creative Cakes
2012031617231878
Creative Cakes
2012031617231819
Creative Cakes
2012031617231837
Creative Cakes
2012031617231820
Creative Cakes
2012031617231842
Creative Cakes
2012031617231845
Creative Cakes
201203161723183
Creative Cakes
201203161723187
Creative Cakes
2012031617231821
Creative Cakes
2012031617231814
Creative Cakes
2012031617231860
Creative Cakes
2012031617231861
Creative Cakes
2012031617231855
Creative Cakes
2012031617231859
Creative Cakes
2012031617231858
Creative Cakes
2012031617231866
Creative Cakes
2012031617231849
Creative Cakes
201203161723186
Creative Cakes
2012031617231815
Creative Cakes
screen shot 2015 12 31 at 3 53 21 pm
Creative Cakes
screen shot 2015 12 31 at 3 56 05 pm
Creative Cakes
screen shot 2015 12 31 at 3 56 34 pm
Creative Cakes
2012031617231827
Creative Cakes
2012031617231829
Creative Cakes
2012031617231830
Creative Cakes
2012031617231828
Creative Cakes
screen shot 2016 01 13 at 3 03 12 pm
Creative Cakes
screen shot 2016 01 13 at 3 04 15 pm
Creative Cakes
2e241bad5533cdd6 1451598488154 screen shot 2015 12 31 at 3 46 27 pm
Creative Cakes
Three-tier cake
Three-tier cake

Interested in this vendor?

Request pricing

219 Reviews for Creative Cakes

Recommended by 98% of couples


4.9 out of 5.0
  • Quality of service 4.9
  • Professionalism 4.9
  • Flexibility 4.9
  • Value 4.8
  • Average response time 4.9

10 User photos

Creative Cakes 1
Creative Cakes 2
Creative Cakes 3
Creative Cakes 4
Creative Cakes 5
Creative Cakes 6
Creative Cakes 7
+ 4
Sort by:
  • Erin

    Erin Eliz · Married on 08/25/2019

    5.0
    • Quality of service:
      5.0
    • Responsiveness:
      5.0
    • Value:
      5.0
    • Flexibility:
      5.0
    • Professionalism:
      5.0

    Beautiful cake, amazing flavor

    Our wedding cake turned out beautifully and was better than I could have ever hoped for! They were extremely responsive to my emails and so sweet on the phone. Best wedding cake ever!

    Sent on 08/27/2019

    Creative Cakes's reply:

    Erin, it is so good to hear you loved your wedding cake. I told our decorators I hope you love it as much as I do! Congratulations!
  • Bridgette

    Bridgette Love · Married on 08/25/2019

    5.0
    • Quality of service:
      5.0
    • Responsiveness:
      5.0
    • Value:
      5.0
    • Flexibility:
      5.0
    • Professionalism:
      5.0

    Beautiful and Delicious

    The cake was a huge hit. Everyone loved it. It looked beautiful and tasted amazing.

    You can customize each tier the way you want with no extra charges.

    Sent on 09/03/2019

Awards

219
WeddingWire Couples' Choice Awards 2019 Winner
WeddingWire Couples' Choice Awards 2018 Winner
WeddingWire Couples' Choice Awards 2017 Winner
WeddingWire Couples' Choice Awards 2016 Winner
WeddingWire Couples' Choice Awards 2015 Winner
WeddingWire Couples' Choice Awards 2014 Winner
WeddingWire Couples' Choice Awards 2013 Winner
WeddingWire Couples' Choice Awards 2012 Winner
WeddingWire Couples' Choice Awards 2011 Winner
WeddingWire Couples' Choice Awards 2010 Winner
WeddingWire Couples' Choice Awards 2009 Winner

Creative Cakes FAQ

  • What is the starting price for wedding cakes with buttercream frosting (per slice, without tax)? $ 5.00
  • What is the starting price for fondant wedding cakes (per slice, without tax)? $ 6.00
  • Which of the following are included in the cost of the cake? Anniversary Cake, Top Tier of the Cake
  • What is the starting price for cupcakes (per cupcake, without tax)? $ 3.00
  • What services do your prices include? Consultation, Custom Cake Design, Tastings - Private
  • What types of desserts do you provide? Cakes, Cookies, Croquembouche, Cupcakes, Fruit, Groom's Cake, Pastries
  • What services do you provide? Consultations, Delivery, Setup
  • What cake items do you provide? Cake Stands
  • What special ingredients do you use? Local
  • Are you licensed by the state health department? Yes

Professional Network & Endorsements

6 Endorsements

  • TWA Photographic Artists
    TWA Photographic Artists Wedding Photographers

    From festive holiday goodies to amazing wedding cakes, Creative Cakes is our go-to bakery! Your taste buds will never be disappointed when you bite into any one of their decadent desserts!

  • Harry Caray's Lombard
    Harry Caray's Lombard Restaurant Weddings

    Creative Cakes is by far the best bakery I've ever worked with. Their product & customer service is better than anyone else. My brides & grooms always come back with huge compliments from their tasting visits. Beth, Becky & the Creative Cakes team truly know how to take care of our guests!!

  • The Odyssey
    The Odyssey Country Club Weddings

    FANTASTIC! That is all we need to say about their products and staff. Everyone is super friendly and they really LOVE what they do. We have a longstanding working relationship with Creative Cakes and highly recommend them. Their wedding cakes are not only beautifully decorated they taste incredible, too!

Preferred Vendors

Map

  • 16649 Oak Park Ave. Unit F, Suite 355 Tinley Park, Illinois, 60477 See on map
    630-473-9958 (Phone number)
    7086149755 (Other Phone Number)
    By Appointment Only
  • 16649 Oak Park Ave., Unit F Tinley Park, 60477 See on map
    708-586-5580 (Phone number)

By clicking "Request pricing" I agree to sign up and accept WeddingWire's Terms of Use.

Write a review