Creative Cakes Reviews
Reviews
We're all about trust. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.
4.9 out of 5 rating
4.9 out of 5 rating
250 reviews
98% recommend it
Awards
-
Featured
![Shannon]()
Shannon Sent on 10/22/2024Your Guests Will NOT Stop Talking about it.
I was a bride that DID NOT want cake at her wedding; however, my mother had a different opinion. Let me tell you a little story.
We were at a bridal expo at Jacob Henry Mansion and my mom made a beeline for Creative Cakes. She took one bite and looked at me with her eyes rolling into the back of her head. She said you have to try this and I said yeah yeah. After one bite, I immediately said "where do I sign the contract?" It was that good. It's not been a month since the wedding and I am still having guests come to me and ask where we got our cake and sweets from and how delicious it was. Our sweets table was wiped clean with no leftovers. Creative cakes even went above and beyond. It was beautiful and delicious. If you want guests still talking about how great the cake was then you should immediately book them, you will not be disappointed.Creative Cakes's reply:
THANK YOU SO MUCH! We appreciate you taking the time to share your experience. It makes us so happy to know that you and your guests enjoyed it! -
Katelyn L. Sent on 01/04/2025
Delicious!
Our wedding cake and sweets table were absolutely amazing! We received so many compliments and our entire sweets table was devoured by the end of the night! I had the pleasure of working with Becky and she made the entire planning process stress free. I definitely recommend Creative Cakes Bakery!Creative Cakes's reply:
Thank you so much Katelyn! We were honored to celebrate with you both. Don't forget to order your complimentary 1 year anniversary cake! ; ) -
-
Amanda M. Sent on 12/11/2024
Our wedding cake was amazing!!
Our wedding cake from Creative Cakes Bakery was absolutely amazing. Not only was it delicious, it was so gorgeous! Everyone was so nice and easy to work with. We had 3 flavors - red velvet with white chocolate mousse, yellow with fudge and white with raspberry preserves. We had a full sweet table as well but we still had no cake left at the end of the night because it was so delicious and popular! If you need a beautiful and tasty wedding cake look no further!! Thank you creative cakes!Creative Cakes's reply:
Thank you so much for the kind words Amanda! We loved making your cake! It was one of our favorites of the year!
Looking forward to celebrating with you in the future! -
-
![Katrina]()
Katrina A. Sent on 12/10/2024A cake to remember
From the first email to the delivery our cake was everything we dreamed it would be and the taste was even better the only thing that I regret is that I didn't have more!
Katrina and WalterCreative Cakes's reply:
Thank you Katrina & Walter - We were honored to be part of such a special memory! Congratulations again! -
-
Erin Q. Sent on 07/07/2024
Wedding Day Perfection!
Creative Cakes is the absolute best! Our wedding cake was perfect! We worked with Becky and her team, and they were truly outstanding. From our first meeting, Becky guided us through every step of the process, took detailed notes, and asked questions to help us think through every detail. She even shared a sketch based on what we discussed. Becky was incredibly patient and understanding of last-minute changes. She is knowledgeable, flexible, and truly cares about her customers. Our guests absolutely loved the cake, with several asking where we got it. We couldn't have asked for a better experience. Thanks for everything!Creative Cakes's reply:
Thank you so much for the kind words! It was truly a pleasure working with you both to create your perfect cake! -
-
![Sam]()
Sam J. Sent on 01/02/2025Best Wedding Cake!
Creative Cakes made our wedding cake and absolutely blew my expectations of what a wedding cake could be out of the water. Their tasting process was so simple - pick up a sampler of their cakes and buttercreams to take home and have at your own convenience. Their product was delicious and we had a hard time choosing what we wanted - ultimately went with a banana cake and white chocolate frosting. Working with their designers was so simple as well. The final product was exactly what we had envisioned and tasted even better than I remembered from our tasting. We still get compliments to this day on how good our cake was from our guests! I can't recommend the bakery enough. -
Caroline R. Sent on 08/14/2023
Excellent- Must Order!
We had the most beautiful and delicious wedding cake from Creative Cakes in Tinley Park, IL. Their professionalism and responsiveness was so wonderful.
We did a three tier, three layered cake of vanilla, chocolate, and banana cake with vanilla mousse and vanilla buttercream. It was outstanding! A guest who attended our wedding even ordered the same kind of cake for her birthday 4 days later. We loved it.
It won’t let me post a link but their website is creativecakes bakery, Creative Cakes Bakery, and their instagram handle is cr8cakes -
-
![Veronica]()
Veronica Sent on 09/18/2022Flawless!!
Our wedding cake was a dream come true! It was just what I had envisioned and more. The flavors were on point and we had quite a few people ask us where the cake was from!
I highly recommend this bakery!
Fun fact: they give you a free top layer cake for your 1 year anniversary which is such a sweet compliment.Creative Cakes's reply:
Wow thank you for the kind words! We were honored to be part of your day. We look forward to hearing from you for your anniversary cake and congratulations!! -
-
![Fiona]()
Fiona C. Sent on 11/16/2021The best wedding cake you will ever taste!
We are so happy with our experience after using Creative Cakes for our wedding cake and desserts! Becky was a joy to work with! The overall price point was extremely reasonable. We opted for a more simple style, but they offer all sorts of wedding cake styles from small to large and simple to very lavish, but one thing that doesn't change is how good the cake tastes! We also ordered a cookie tray and it was perfect for our group. The drop off experience and set up went smoothly and I was over the moon when I saw the cake at our reception - it was perfect. Highly recommend!Creative Cakes's reply:
Thank you again Fiona for your fabulous review - you are so kind and it means the world to us that you were so pleased! -
-
Brittany S. Sent on 08/26/2021
They'll be our cake place forever now
Working with creative cakes was awesome. because of covid we did a zoom call to design the cake. They have foam cake tier rounds so you can really visualize how the cake will look! I was able to individually design each layer. And there are so many cake and filling options! All my guests cannot stop raving about the banana cake. Many guests have told us its the best cake they've ever had! I'm pretty sure my family expects this cake at all future events! so yummy!Creative Cakes's reply:
Thank you so much Brittany! Congratulations again. We were honored to be a part of your special day! -
-
![Kathryn]()
Kathryn P. Sent on 11/02/2020Gorgeous Wedding Cake
We were extremely happy with our wedding cake from Creative Cakes! They took a rustic farmhouse cake design that I had sent them and made the design look exactly like my Pinterest photo. The staff was very friendly and pleasant to work with! I added on a rental stand at the last minute and the staff could not have been more helpful! I am so glad we used Creative Cakes to design our dream wedding cake!Creative Cakes's reply:
Thank you for the kind words, Kathryn! It was our pleasure to make your dream a reality! Don't forget to order your free 1-year Anniversary cake next year :) -
![Maya]()
Maya Sent on 10/28/2020Perfect Cake!
Our 4 tier wedding cake turned out beautifully, thanks to Creative Cakes! I sent them a picture of the cake I want and they did it the same in addition with so many creative ideas that I loved!
The staff were very responsive, friendly, creative, and professional especially Becky whom I enjoyed working with!
The taste was beyond amazing as they have so many filling options and all of our guests enjoyed the taste!
We are so happy that we chose Creative Cakes for our wedding! Highly recommended!!! -
-
Angel A. Sent on 12/08/2020
Beautiful & Delicious Wedding Cake!
I’m so happy that we went with Creative Cakes as the bakery for our wedding cake. We got married this fall, and we were in the middle of scrapping our original wedding plans for something more intimate. There were a lot of moving pieces to keep track of already, and I was hoping to find a company that would be reliable and easy to work with. The work you guys do honestly speaks for itself and the staff is amazing to work with. We worked with Emily to go over options and to discuss what we were looking for. We received a COVID-friendly to-go tasting platter and narrowed our flavor down to a chocolate cake with raspberry mouse filling along with the horizontal/rustic buttercream icing. I tried it with my sister—because my husband lived out of state—and we had the hardest time coming to a decision because all of the flavors were just that delicious. The cake arrived to the venue on time and was decorated beautifully. We had ordered flowers and a topper online to be placed on the wedding cake upon arrival. When I saw the finished product as we walked in, I just remember thinking how it turned out better than I imagined. I can’t thank your team enough!
Also, can we just talk about how they thoughtfully provide a fresh, complimentary cake on your first wedding anniversary! Yes please, no need for the frozen, year old wedding cake here lol
Creative Cakes's reply:
Hi Angel,
Thank you so much for the kind review, we are so happy to hear how much you loved your cake and the experience! It was a pleasure working with you & don't forget about your complimentary anniversary tier next year! -
-
![Jasie]()
Jasie Sent on 01/26/2021Couldn't have been better!!!
My now husband and I went to one place to sample cakes, and we were instantly sold. We were able to get a bigger cake with more details/decorations than we were expecting because they were priced so well. And because it ended up being two tiers instead of one, we were able to get one in my husband's favorite flavor, and one in mine.
We had to change our venue cause of covid and they were super great about it.
People kept telling my parents all night that it was by far the best wedding cake they'd ever had, and I completely agree. My husband and I have been craving it ever since we finished it! We definitely won't be waiting until our one year anniversary to get more from them! -
-
![Alanna]()
Alanna G. Sent on 12/03/2020Perfect wedding cake!!
I LOVED my wedding cake! They did such an amazing job and were so easy to work with and very accommodating! It was an all around perfect experience from the initial cake tasting to the designing to the set up and then taste of the cake! Would 10/10 recommend!! -
-
![Katrina]()
Katrina A. Sent on 09/17/2020Covid wedding
Creative Cakes is an incredible bakery to work with! Becky has been so patient with all of the changes to our wedding due to COVID. She was very quick to answer any questions I had, gave her feedback for my design and definitely delivered on our day! Everyone loved our cake and said they're excited to try our cake in April. I can't say enough wonderful things about Creative Cakes and I will recommend them to everyone! I can't wait to see their design for our April wedding cake!Creative Cakes's reply:
Thank you so much Katrina for the wonderful review! You made our day. We are looking forward to April too! -
-
![Leslie]()
Leslie F. Sent on 02/20/2020Best decision ever was to use Creative Cakes
Not only was our wedding cake beautiful the flavors and cake itself was delicious. I will be using Creative Cakes again! All of our guest asked for seconds cant wait till our First anniversary when we get a fresh tier all for our self's lolCreative Cakes's reply:
Thank you so much for the wonderful feedback! We can't wait to make your anniversary tier and help you celebrate your future events. Congratulations! -
Paige Sent on 02/29/2020
Delicious Cake, Beautiful Execution
From the wedding cake tasting to the real thing, Creative Cakes did an amazing job! We had an Art Deco theme, and they delivered on our vision. The cake tasted amazing and all of our wedding guests loved it! I highly recommend Creative Cakes for all of your baking needs. Thank you!Creative Cakes's reply:
Thank you so much - we LOVED the Art Deco theme and being a part of your special day! Come see us again! -
-
![Shannon]()
Shannon M. Sent on 10/08/2019It was an amazing experience
They did our wedding cake and did an amazing job. The detail on our cake was so beautiful. I will recommend them to anyone and everyone! Everything was exactly how we wanted it. -
![Ankica]()
Ankica J. Sent on 10/16/2019So delicious we got 2 cakes!
Through our venue package we had a handful of cake vendors to select and work with. Creative Cakes was the most flexible, creative, and the MOST delicious. We ended up getting our grooms cake with Creative as well.
They even made sure to have extra packaging and materials for the top two tiers we were going to be using for our second ceremony the day after our first wedding.
Guests kept asking me what exactly the flavors were and the baker - they absolutely loved it. And as the bride and groom, I made sure we got pieces as well. Completely enjoyed their service and attention to every detail. -
![Erin]()
Erin E. Sent on 08/27/2019Beautiful cake, amazing flavor
Our wedding cake turned out beautifully and was better than I could have ever hoped for! They were extremely responsive to my emails and so sweet on the phone. Best wedding cake ever!Creative Cakes's reply:
Erin, it is so good to hear you loved your wedding cake. I told our decorators I hope you love it as much as I do! Congratulations! -
![Bridgette]()
Bridgette L. Sent on 09/03/2019Beautiful and Delicious
The cake was a huge hit. Everyone loved it. It looked beautiful and tasted amazing.
You can customize each tier the way you want with no extra charges.
Are you interested?
Are you interested?