Nearby Vendors to Consider

About Cakes Creatively by Crystal

Serving the greater Columbus area! Our cakes are all about you, designed especially for you and your special day. Choose from a variety of delicious flavors to satisfy you and all of your guests. Take a look at our fantastic cupcakes, chocolates and favors to add a special touch!

Categories: Wedding Cake

Regions serviced: Columbus

Follow Cakes Creatively by Crystal on

91 Reviews for Cakes Creatively by Crystal

out of 5.0
User Photos
todo alt text
todo alt text
todo alt text
Filter reviews by services used:
All Reviews
Delivery (6)
Private Tastings (6)
Cakes (5)
Custom Design (5)
Consultations (4)
Setup (4)
Cake Stands (4)
Cupcakes (2)
Gluten Free (1)
Nut Free (1)
Sort by:


Beautiful and delicious cake. Our family also enjoyed the chocolate covered strawberries. Crystal was awesome to work with & great customer service.

Photo of Cakes Creatively by Crystal in Reynoldsburg , OH
Profile Picture Jerri, 12/30/17, 2 Reviews
Category: Wedding Cake
Services Used: Consultations, Custom Design, Delivery, Private Tastings, Cakes

From the very first time we met Crystal, she was so personable and attentive. We knew we were looking for someone like her to make our wedding cake...and that was before we tried her delicious cakes. The European buttercream was exactly the right amount of sweet and it truly made Crystal’s cakes stand out from the other ones we tried. We ended up doing a 3 tiered cake with a mix of flavors and fillings since we loved so many of the flavors. I wanted our cake to tie in with the rest of the fall themed wedding decor and so, Crystal decorated the cake beautifully with fresh flowers—it was a huge hit!

Photo of Cakes Creatively by Crystal in Reynoldsburg , OH
Photo of Cakes Creatively by Crystal in Reynoldsburg , OH
Profile Picture Niharika, 9/30/17, 2 Reviews
Category: Wedding Cake
Services Used: Cake Stands, Custom Design, Delivery, Private Tastings, Cakes

I wish I could save everyone the time of choosing a wedding cake vendor / artist / baker. I started my search looking for the top reviews on different websites. Then I took those, and looked at the cake designs themselves - which helped weed out a lot. Finally, I took price into consideration. My now-husband and I tried 3 vendors on that short list, and were blown away by Crystal. She is the triple threat: Delicious cakes + elegant designs + affordability. Best choice in Columbus!

Profile Picture Megan, 7/16/17, 5 Reviews
Category: Wedding Cake
Services Used: Cakes, Custom Design, Delivery, Setup, Private Tastings, Cake Stands

Cakes Creatively by Crystal Pricing

Wedding Cakes Pricing
Buttercream Frosting (Per Slice, Without Tax)
Starting from $2.00
Fondant Starting Price (Per Slice, Without Tax)
Starting from $3.00
Cake Prices Include:
Top Tier of the Cake
Cupcakes (Each, Without Tax)
Starting from $2.00
Prices Include:
Custom Cake Design
Set Up

Cakes Creatively by Crystal FAQ

Cake Pops
Dessert Buffet
Groom's Cake
Custom Design
Private Tastings
Cake Stands
Cake Cutters
Cake Toppers
Gluten Free
Nut Free
Lactose Free
Health License


34 Photos

My Photo Album

34 Photos
220x220 sq 1399863008181
220x220 sq 1371695669383 img2721
220x220 sq 1371695713530 img2739
220x220 sq 1371695754118 img2820
220x220 sq 1371695793946 img2824
220x220 sq 1371695871176 img4570
220x220 sq 1371695995088 img4662
220x220 sq 1371695624262 img2605
220x220 sq 1371696167636 img4814
220x220 sq 1379966916163 1623trautman 9840
220x220 sq 1379967188204 img4555
220x220 sq 1379967322667 wedding photos 242
220x220 sq 1379967352300 image 1
220x220 sq 1379967505257 img2441
220x220 sq 1379967630169 img2734
220x220 sq 1379967669624 img5699
220x220 sq 1379967708859 img5858
220x220 sq 1379967785631 img5905
220x220 sq 1379967825897 img5906
220x220 sq 1379968055557 img5943
220x220 sq 1399862689553 img030
220x220 sq 1399862731071
220x220 sq 1399862744079 1624trautman 984
220x220 sq 1399862818514 49
220x220 sq 1399862851358 wedding photos 241 cop
220x220 sq 1399862899854 img5971 cop
220x220 sq 1399862964443 osu cak
220x220 sq 1399863044060
220x220 sq 1399863158975
220x220 sq 1399863318819
220x220 sq 1399863557622 img429
220x220 sq 1399863609665 img529
220x220 sq 1399863666389 img530
220x220 sq 1414878648517 1


PO Box 568, Reynoldsburg , OH 43068   See On Map
614-783-4830 (phone)