Wedding Times!

I am having such a hard time deciding what time to do my wedding. Catholic Churches on Saturday are difficult because you can ether do a 2PM wedding for a 5:30PM wedding.
My wedding is November 12th, 2022 so the sun sets at 4:20ish. Would it be crazy to do a wedding that starts at 5:30pm? It’s all indoors and we would do a first look before the church around 2:30pm and do group photos outside in the light and the reception would end around midnight.
Or does the 2PM mass sound better so my guests can see the sunset at cocktail hour through the windows of the room. I would still want to do first look photos so I would have to be completely ready by 11am! And the reception would end around 9pm I’m so conflicted with these time choices.