I've been on the hunt for my wedding ring (2.5 months to go! Eek!) and multiple friends have directed me to look on Etsy. I am on a budget, and it does seem to skew slightly cheaper. Also, some of the stuff I've found is really beautiful, but I'm anxious that there's no guarantees or quality control from in individual seller (though some of them have hundreds of great reviews). Also, I don't love the idea of buying an expensive ring without being able to try it on with my engagement ring first.
Has anyone bought wedding bands from Etsy before? Thoughts? Is this just a terrible idea?