Wedding Favors

I would eliminate the cake pops; like you said you're already serving cake. Plus the tic tacs and kisses you can order in bulk to save money.

We did the kisses in tulle bags (Amazon) and ordered in bulk from Candy Warehouse in the colors we wanted (the foil wrappers, obviously). Got some tags on Amazon and had a sheet of stickers made on Vistaprint. Ended up being a fairly affordable ordeal, and if there were leftovers we didn't mind - that means we got to take them home and eat them

If I was a guest, I'd prefer the cake pop! Even if I already had dessert, cake pops are so small and you could serve them at the very end of the wedding.

Be prepared for every one to eat the kisses and leave the little foils and whatever box or bag you put them in all over the venue. I have been to too many weddings where the favor was candy and before dinner was served everyone had eaten their favor.

With that said I would go with the Tic-tacs. People will be more inclined to bring them home, toss them in their purse or leave in their car. Then when they use them they will think of you and your awesome wedding!

I would eat the cake pop or the kisses. Probably not the mints.

I like the mints or kisses!

I vote for #2, I think it'll be easy on you, easy for your guests to grab, and very cute

If you offer the cake-pops, only at the exit, as people are leaving, then it will to interfere with the cake. If you can not place them at the exit, go with the kisses!