We’re talking about it being on our 5th anniversary on Oct 12th, 2024.
Ideas I’ve thought of (if we’re financially able to and able to save up enough in time to book accordingly) is

#1 Sandals Resort in Emerald Bay, Bahamas -have a vacation at the same time-be at a beach together-which we’ve never done before as a couple -rather expensive, however, it’s all inclusive and ceremony is free
OR
#2 Have it all at our own home -would be MUCH less expensive than the first option -wouldn’t be a vacation —or as much of a vacation -would have potential for distractions (we live by a relatively busy highway and close-ish neighbors)-would have to clean up/decor/set up/tear down etc by ourselves