Skip to main content

Post content has been hidden

To unblock this content, please click here

B
Just Said Yes November 2018

Couch for a Bridal Shower gift?

BJ, on October 18, 2018 at 12:52 AM Posted in Etiquette and Advice 0 18

My fiance and I have been living in a house for the past few years and we don't need anything for the house other than a new couch and new dining room set. I don't want to register just to register for things I don't really need. Is it rude to ask for $25 as a gift that would be applied for us to buy a new couch? How do you even phrase that to the guests? In on the fence about this! Thank you.

18 Comments

Latest activity by Maren, on November 5, 2018 at 8:05 PM
  • Caytlyn
    Legend November 2019
    Caytlyn ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    Cash isn't an appropriate bridal shower gift. You can choose not to register and people will gift you money, but you would have to turn out anyone's offer to host a shower for you if you don't want to receive physical gifts.

    • Reply
  • A
    Super September 2019
    Anna ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    You could register for the gift cards at wherever you want to buy the couch . If you have a wedding website then you could put something on there along with the “registry website” saying it would go towards the couch and dining set
    • Reply
  • Victoria
    VIP October 2018
    Victoria ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    I don't know if it's not appropriate, but it's certainly not the traditional gift. Do you know where you want to get the couch from? Sometimes some stores allow you to register and let guests pay for a portion, or in essence crowd fund through the store, the larger gift you registered for.

    However, if you plan on doing this and you do plan on having a shower, you should also register for smaller items. We had our own houses until we moved in together a couple of years ago and we still were able to put together a small registry of lawn games, planters, home sound system, new cooking utensils to replace broken (normally we'd do this ourselves but decided to just wait and put them on our registry), etc. Things we don't have and don't necessarily need right now, but would love if someone chose to gift them to us.
    • Reply
  • V
    Super April 2019
    Valerie ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    In my family this is how it is done. Only baby showers are individual items while the bridal shower is the family getting together and giving a portion for a larger gift. How it is usually done in our family is whomever is hosting the shower sends out the invites and just tells people where the bride and groom are looking for gift cards when the person RSVPs.

    Also, until I came to this site I didn't know people still opened gifts at a bridal shower. I thought that it was one of those old time traditions that no one really did anymore - like the bouquet and garter toss. I've never actually been to a shower where gifts have been opened. And yes, I understand the original purpose of the shower is to 'shower the bride with gifts' but times change and opening them or having it have to be physical gifts is just way in the rear-view mirror for many people.

    • Reply
  • WED18
    July 1993
    WED18 ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    Perhaps it’s a regional thing but I’ve never been to a shower without gifts. I would personally never give a gift card or even attend a shower if the couple didn’t need household items. That’s the purpose of the shower. If they don’t have a shower, then I gift more at the wedding where I always bring a card with a check which the couple can spend in anyway they choose.
    • Reply
  • Denise
    Devoted May 2019
    Denise ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    If I saw it announced somewhere like on a shower invitation that you wanted cash or gift cards, I’d think it was tacky. If I saw you didn’t have a registry and asked a brisdesmaid or your mother or someone what kind of gift was appropriate and was told you were saving to buy furniture, I’d happily put a Benjamin in a card and call it a day.
    • Reply
  • Kristen
    VIP August 2018
    Kristen ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    I've been to a bridal shower without gifts and we were all kid of like "um ok why are we here?" Sure, there were games and stuff but usually a shower involves the bride opening your gifts. If you would just like cash for your couch then you could just not register and then people will figure it out. But then I would wonder what you would do with a shower and no gifts.

    My husband and I lived together for almost 3 years before we got married so we had a lot of things already and didn't need much. We took the shower opportunity to upgrade a lot of things like our silverware and towels, even little things like a new butter dish and wooden spoons. We also registered for things we wanted but may not have spent the money to buy it for ourselves, like a Margaritavillle machine (husband's idea lol) and really nice Kate Spade china that I can't wait to to use this year for Christmas dinner!


    ETA: Our friends and family were also super generous with their wedding gifts and we can spend that money however we'd like. So with the money you receive from your wedding gifts you can put that towards the couch and use the shower gifts as an opportunity to get a few new things.

    • Reply
  • MOB So Cal
    January 2019
    MOB So Cal ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    You asked, "is it rude to ask for a $25 gift?" And, yes, I would find that rude, and super awkward -- both directly asking for cash and suggesting an amount! (It doesn't make it "better" for me that it is a relatively small amount; it's still rude to suggest what a guest should give you. It's kind of like charging admission or something.) I'm sure, like many things, it might be a "know your crowd" kind-of a thing, but if some of your guests are likely more "traditional" in their thinking, they might find this off-putting, too. If you literally don't need one thing for your home beside money to buy furniture, I would politely decline the offer to host a shower for you, since that is what, traditionally, a shower is for. I also wouldn't register anywhere and it's likely guests who choose to give you a gift for your wedding will give you a check or cash that you can then spend on whatever you like. I get that "times are changing," but that doesn't mean people won't judge you for your lack of manners and etiquette. Some will advise you to "do whatever you want, it's your wedding!" While I agree we each can make whatever choices we want to, we also should understand the potential ramifications and consequences of those choices. Is $ toward a new couch worth the potential risk of people seeing you (and your FH) as ill-mannered? It would not be for me. Good luck to you!

    • Reply
  • J
    Master 0000
    Judith ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    Just as 3-5 shower guests may decide or buying one bigger joint gift, a large super deluxe microwave convection oven, or a small desk top computer or similar, they can also pair up to buy an expensive chair, so you get 4 of the 8 you wanted, or a group can go together for a couch or dining table. Before the last 15-18 years when registries like today's, good at all stores nationwide, were made possible by small business computers connecting and coordinating all customer lists with all stores, people used a combination of 5-10 items on a registry in one brick and mortar store, for china, crystal, and silverware patterns, hope chests or cedar chests, big appliances( for a shower) like a Sunbeam mixer, set of pots and pans. Only well off people near big stores did this. And for those same items, if bought by guests not near that store, brides or couples gave their immediate families, especially grandmothers, aunts, MOG & MOB and wedding party women, a wish list. Listing things not by store, but item, Fieldcrest towels in these 4 colors, Kitchen Aid free standing dishwasher. Then smaller household items. That is why older advice columns and books, and current Dear Abby, Miss Manners columns and books mention, if you want suggestions for what would be an appreciated shower or wedding gift, consult the guest of honor's registry, or the MOB, close women of the bride's family, or members of the bride's side of bridal party. These are also the people most likely to organize showers. So, follow that accepted tradition. Make a wish list. And on your website, or on shower invitations or by word of mouth, it can say, We registered only for a few items on registries, because we have greatest need of a few items of furniture. If a few people would like to join in to purchase one larger item, or get suggestions for smaller items not on our registry, contact blah blah, names and email or phone numbers. People in our rural area and our family background, still want to give gifts, or services, not money and gift certificates. The older generations of my husband's family, grew up where a group af family members, like aunts and uncles, and work friends, neighborhood friends, would pick out and buy in groups, all on installments like layaway, at local stores in Brooklyn and Queens, a recliner here, a dining table there, a tv, or washer dryer. Who a shower for 30 might result in 3 big gifts from 20 people, and 10 small items. My FI had built us a beautiful solid cherry table, carved legs and edges and all, seating for 12, 18 with leaves put in. And we were using goodwill and folding chairs still. So 2 of my aunt's overseas who could never travel to our wedding, and a bunch of MOG's sisters bought us 8 expensive Cherry chairs that were nice with our table. My Mom and MOG out that deal together, I am sure. And a settee, and a chest, at our shower. Plus lots of small gifts. 6 matching chairs for wedding gifts, from six families, $230 a chair. We bought the last 4 chairs with cash gifts from one of his uncles and one of mine. And an expensive tv from FI younger brothers. Both of our families, and most friends, would get their backs up and think it rude as can be to make a cash contribution to anything. But a couple bridesmaids, a couple cousins or aunts, buy a $400 cedar chest, No problem. So if you are hesitant to ask for cash, or many gift certificates for one store to help purchase a big item, do a wish list through families and bridal parties. And many people will write checks, we hear you are saving for a couch, we hope this $75 will help, though they would never give you a check if you asked for money. Many people like having an idea of buying big things that last, not money you might spend on bills, or the leftover charge card bills from the little wedding stuff, money that is already spent. Try it, even if not usual in this last generation, more likely to give money or gift certificates, who would join a small group if suggested by the family, or shower hostesses, or bridesmaids.
    • Reply
  • MrsD
    Legend July 2019
    MrsD ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    I would do one of two things:

    1. Not register at all. People get the hint, and realize you want cash.

    2. Find a registry with the couch & dining set you want (Amazon, Macy's, etc.) and give people the option to "group gift" or "contribute" so they can pay whatever they want towards that.

    • Reply
  • Samantha
    Savvy November 2018
    Samantha ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    So, my FH would agree with you - ask for cash because you have a goal. But my mom would agree with the commenters that asking for cash is just not done. Two options though: definitely look into group gifting where the couch is located. Or, we registered on Target (you can add gift cards from outside vendors! Like couch stores!) for a few small things and left a note at the top of the registry that we were saving for a new house. Some people got the hint and gave us cash/checks in a modest sum with a very nice card. I followed some etiquette websites that I've since lost but this was our message: "We appreciate all of your love and support as we continue our journey together. If you'd like to give a gift, we've made a small list, but we are also saving for a new home and contributions toward our future would be greatly appreciated!" That way nobody feels pressured to give a specific amount, which is probably what bristles people the wrong way.

    • Reply
  • Sarah
    Devoted May 2019
    Sarah ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    Hard eye roll to anyone saying why even have a shower.. Maybe someone offered to throw one and are you just going to be like "no thank you". I don't want a shower, but if someone offers, then I guess it's going to happen. I'm like you, we don't need things, but we are working on renovating our house so we'd much prefer money for that. You could ask whoever is the host to say in lieu of gifts, the couple would love a contribution to their furniture fund, or something to that effect. You can set it up somewhere or just let people give you a check, but I wouldn't feel awkward about it. It's still going to be a fun day where you get to hang out with your friends and have brunch or tea or whatever your heart desires! I think it's super awkward to open gifts in front of people and the thought of having to do it gives me hives, so by all means feel free to skip it.

    • Reply
  • A
    Super February 2019
    Amy ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    I'm always surprised that people are really stringent about the actual gifts being at a shower. I get thats the traditional purpose but I think they are also just a great way to celebrate with loved ones if someone is inclined to throw one!

    My aunt wanted to throw me a shower even though I'd be flying up to MA from SC and could never bring the physical gifts home with me. I do have a registry but I don't expect opening gifts, I'm guessing they'll be shipped to SC. Deapite this, we talked and decided it would be a good opportunity to get the family together and just have another way to celebrate my upcoming marriage. I don't live near any family so I'll take every opportunity to see everyone I love. Everyone is scattered and busy and always is happy to have time together!

    I also would not suggest an amount but maybe do the group gift thing via Amazon or Macy's as others have suggested!
    • Reply
  • Vicky
    VIP January 2020
    Vicky ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment

    Yes, if you don't want physical gifts, then you say "No, thank you" when someone offers to throw a shower for you. If you still want to have some sort of get-together you can have a bridal brunch or tea, where gifts are not expected.

    • Reply
  • Sarah
    Devoted May 2019
    Sarah ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    That's splitting hairs over the semantics of calling it a shower versus a party or brunch or tea. It's not really that different. It's a get together with friends and family where they can say on the invite what gift is needed, if any. I've been to a bridal brunch where I was expected to bring a gift and also to a couples shower where I was asked to contribute to their "we're building a house fund".

    • Reply
  • L
    Dedicated June 2020
    La ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    This is definitely a "know your crowd" type thing. I, too, think it's a little ridiculous that people get all hung up about giving money to people when what they want/need is money. Like, yeah, a bridal shower was traditionally for furnishing a house, but traditionally the couple-to-be did not live together prior to the marriage and THAT is why getting things like towels and crockery and silverware and whatever was so important. Because they didn't have anything.

    But if a couple has set up a household (and I literally do not know anybody in my peer group who did not co-habitate prior to marriage), then, um, they have a household already. They probably already have towels. Could they get NICER towels? Yeah, probably. But there are likely other things that they need more than that.

    Again, know your crowd. My peer group would not be put off by this. In fact, the past couple of bridal showers I've gone to, the younger set basically all gave Amazon gift cards. As to "what do you do at a bridal shower if there are no gifts," well, you eat food, have a few drinks, maybe play a few rounds of Cards Against Humanity, and what's the problem? It's not like somebody opening a box of towels automatically transforms the entire event.

    Plus, I also think that there's more potential judgment when people can actually see the caliber of gifts being given, anyway. "Oooh! Great Aunt Mabel got me a set of Le Creuset! ooh!"

    "And Sally got me... IKEA dish towels."

    I mean, come on. In my opinion it's less gauche to have Great Aunt Mabel donate $300 toward a couch and Sally donate $20 since that's where they are at financially and the only person who knows is the recepient.

    Clearly, according to the answers you've gotten here, OP, plenty of people would be offended by this. So know your crowd.


    • Reply
  • B
    Just Said Yes November 2018
    BJ ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment
    😜 😆😉😁😀😂🤣😎😄😅😉

    • Reply
  • Maren
    Champion October 2021
    Maren ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment

    Hi BJ! Kristen gives some great feedback here and says it perfectly. I agree, if you don't register, your guests will know to bring cash that you can put towards a couch later on. Using a shower & registry as an opportunity to upgrade on necessities or items you want/need is a good idea, even if you already live together.

    We have a helpful article here that highlights some extra registry items and ideas for if you already live together and some must-have's that you might need, too!

    • Reply

You voted for . Add a comment 👇

×
WeddingWire celebrates love ...and so does everyone on our site! Explore how we embrace diversity

Groups

WeddingWire article topics