First post here! Getting married October 1, 2022 in Milwaukee, WI. We reached out to 2 catering companies and had a tasting for each. We are having a hard time deciding which one we should go with.
Caterer A: decent food, nothing special, and seems to get more options for the buffet/cocktail hour (example: 7 appetizers, 3 entrees, 3 sides).
Caterer B: definitely better food in my opinion, more limited (4 appetizers, 3 entrees, 2 sides), and $2,000 more expensive.
We are estimating around 100 for guest count. Both have amazing customer service, linen/china rentals, and well known & liked in our area, so very comparable there.
Is it worth the extra money for more delicious food or should we "settle" for the decent food & spend elsewhere?
P.S. We are paying for everything ourselves and the extra expense is DOABLE but not sure if it's worth it!