Our cake turned out exactly how we envisioned! It was beautiful, tasty, and reasonably price. Would highly recommend!

We absolutely loved our wedding cake and our few gluten free guests were obsessed with the gf cupcakes they made for them! When a cake looks as good as it tastes what else can you ask for?

They were very great and easy to work with. We got free tastings for the cake flavor and were very accommodating when we wanted to have 2 flavors in our cake. The cake was beautiful and tasted amazing. Would definitely recommend.

Our wedding cake from the Rolling Pin was included with our package with our venue, and we couldn’t have been happier! They designed a beautiful and delicious cake for us, and customized it to exactly what we wanted with different flavors. Best part is that they said they’ll bake us a new cake to celebrate our year anniversary with! This is a wonderful bakery, and we would absolutely recommend them!

I had a vision for my wedding cake from the moment I got engaged and The Rolling Pin made that vision a reality. First of all, I scheduled a few tastings around local bakeries which was like jumping through hoops, but the Rolling Pin made it so easy and just had us fill out a survey online and to come pick up the three customary samples when they were ready. They were ALL delicious and it was hard to pick just one. After my husband and I chose the cake we wanted, we just sent them a picture of what we wanted and the rest was history... it was a painless, easygoing experience with an incredible payoff. I also had a number of guests tell me that it was the most delicious wedding cake that they had ever had!

Probably one of the easiest parts of our wedding planning. We used the bakery that was in our contract, which came from the Bay Shore location. A few months prior to having our wedding, we went online to order 6 cupcakes for a tasting. Each one was so delicious, we had a hard time deciding. We decided on yellow cake with raspberry and vanilla mousse.
Absolutely DELICIOUS!! Once we did decide, all I had to do was send a photo of the type of cake we wanted (thank you Pinterest!), and they made it. Ours was simple, as we wanted a naked cake look. Our amazing florist dressed it up with fresh flowers, and voila! It was beautiful. Our cake was delicious!!!!

Great bakery. the cake was so delicious and beautiful that people are still talking about it and asking me who made my cake. my wedding was 9/14/2018. The emailing back and forth with the baker was outstanding. responses right away. I also had them make a separate cake for a guests birthday and it was amazing, my friend loved it. Thank you to the rolling pin bakery team for you outstanding service!!! highly recommend and would use again!

Our wedding cake from The Rolling Pin was extremely beautiful and, most importantly, delicious! The entire process of ordering the cake was easy and stress free. We chose 6 cake and filling combinations to take home to taste and were not expecting such HUGE portions. Every single one was delicious, but we ended up choosing the marble cake with cannoli filling and it was perfect. Thanks for such a beautiful cake!

Our venue exclusively uses Rolling Pin for all their packages which we were excited about as Rolling Pin is well known for being a great bakery on Long Island, but we were a bit concerned they wouldn't be able to pull off vegan baked goods for us. We were very pleasantly surprised. We ordered a naked marble cake, half canolli filling, half banana creme pudding for our guests, and did the top tier vegan (vanilla cake with chocolate pudding filling) and it was amazing. We also ordered a half dozen vegan cupcakes to ensure we had enough vegan treats for all necessary guests and they were delicious.

We had Rolling Pin make our cake for our wedding two weeks ago (chocolate with cannoli filling) and it was delicious. After the cake arrived at the venue, one of the staff members bumped into it and "dented" the icing on the front. The bakery promptly returned for the cake, fixed it and returned it in plenty of time for the event.