Nearby Vendors to Consider

About Piece O' Cake

Custom cakes for custom people!
Piece O' Cake is a custom cake shop that has been in business since 1993.  We provide cakes for all occasions.  All cakes are done to order to maintain quality.  All weddings are done by appointment.  We provide you with tastings that are packaged with your specifically chosen cakes and fillings to take home and sample in you own private setting.  We only do a certain number of cakes a week and prefer at least 3 months notice for a wedding.  Please check us out on Facebook..we love new fans! 

Categories: Wedding Cake

Regions serviced: Northern New Jersey

Follow Piece O' Cake on

58 Reviews for Piece O' Cake

out of 5.0
Sort by:


Our cake was awesome! It was exactly what we wanted! I would highly recommend them to everyone!!!

Profile Picture Katie, 10/10/15, 7 Reviews
Category: Wedding Cake

The cake we got for our wedding was honestly the best cake I have ever had. They listened to everything we wanted...even when it came to having sprinkles put into the batter to make a "funfetti" cake. I was so thrilled with the way it came out...I definitely recommend them.

Profile Picture Devin, 5/23/14, 4 Reviews
Category: Wedding Cake

Piece O Cake designed my Grooms Cake, which was zombie themed after the "Walking Dead." I wasn't 100% sure what I wanted, so I sent them a couple pictures from pinterest and let them do the rest. All I can say about the cake was.....WOW. Everyone at the wedding was so impressed with the detailed work on the cake. Furthermore, the cake tasted great. They did an awesome job and cannot thank them enough. People couldn't stop talking about how they had never seen such an original and amazing cake.

Profile Picture Victoria, 5/3/14, 6 Reviews
Category: Wedding Cake

Piece O' Cake Pricing

Wedding Cakes Pricing
Buttercream Frosting (Per Slice, Without Tax)
Starting from $4.00
Fondant Starting Price (Per Slice, Without Tax)
Starting from $5.00
Cake Prices Include:
Anniversary Cake
Top Tier of the Cake
Cupcakes (Each, Without Tax)
Starting from $3.00
Prices Include:
Set Up
Tasting - Private

Piece O' Cake FAQ

Groom's Cake
Cake Pops
Dessert Buffet
Custom Design
Private Tastings
Cake Stands
Cake Cutters
Cake Toppers
Fresh Fruit
Health License


20 Photos

My Photo Album

20 Photos
220x220 sq 1243994572921 imgp1397
220x220 sq 1243994572953 imgp1438
220x220 sq 1243994573468 imgp1378
220x220 sq 1243994573515 imgp1372
220x220 sq 1243994573984 imgp1368
220x220 sq 1243994574078 imgp1351
220x220 sq 1243994574515 imgp1318
220x220 sq 1243994574656 imgp1154
220x220 sq 1243994574984 imgp1151
220x220 sq 1243994575265 imgp1149
220x220 sq 1243994575578 imgp0992
220x220 sq 1243994575937 imgp0979
220x220 sq 1243994576171 imgp0969
220x220 sq 1243994576546 imgp0922
220x220 sq 1243994576734 imgp0913
220x220 sq 1243994577312 imgp0505
220x220 sq 1243994577328 imgp0454
220x220 sq 1281527050013 476
220x220 sq 1281529298123 504
220x220 sq 1281529406404 488

Professional Network & Endorsements

Piece o Cake never fails to please. Not only are the cakes beautiful but more importantly ...delicious! And the second topper as a "take home" is always a delight to our couples!

We got our own Wedding Cake AND we get cakes twice a year from piece O' cake, for our daughters birthdays! Always amazing!


717 broad street, Shrewsbury, NJ 07702   See On Map
732-741-3802 (phone)