We 100% LOVE Old Town Bakery, it's owner Niall, the staff, the store, everything about it. Niall made our wedding cake as well as pastries delivered to hotels of our VIPS. We eat breakfast and lunch in his shop every chance we get. Great sandwiches, baguettes to die for, artisan cheese selections. HANDS DOWN THE BEST BAKER ON THE ISLAND & THE SHOP IS A CANT MISS FOR ANY FOODIE

Old Town Bakery provided the wedding cake through our venue at the Reach Resort. The cake was absolutely delicious, we chose a two layer vanilla cake with chocolate and key lime fillings. They also did a great job decorating the cake, as we chose to go a bit whimsical with rock candy on the sides. Everything turned out great, and we would highly recommend them. We wish they were able to ship their cakes, we'd love to have another (albeit smaller) cake for an anniversary, it was that good!

My cake was simple yet elegant. Old Town Bakery doesn't use lots of flavors or colors but if you're looking for a great tasting cake that won't break the bank then this baker is for you. I had a vanilla cake with vanilla icing and it was yummy!

Writing this review is going to make me drool with hunger. I was lucky enough to have most of my wedding weekend catered by Niall at Old Town Bakery. The morning of the wedding we hand an assortment of croissants delivered while my bridesmaids and I got ready for the big day. Wedding diet be damned I think I had 3 or 4. Then of course there was the cake. It was light, fresh, delicious and gorgeous. We had so many compliments on it and the best compliment to any chef is that even though we over ordered for the number of guests we had the cake disappeared. The next day we again had our day after brunch at the hotel augmented with an assorted tray of croissants from Old Town Bakery and again I had 3 or 4. You'd think with all of that that my husband and I might try somewhere else for lunch before we left town, nope. We stopped at Old Town Bakery on our way out of Key West for some lunch sandwiches for the ride back. I'm not exaggerating when I say we both had the best lunch of our lives in a rental car driving down highway 1. If you're lucky enough to have Niall make your wedding cake, don't stop there get every meal you possibly can from him. You won't regret it. Of course I want to return to Key West for the people, the weather and the fun. But at night I dream of Key West croissants. Thank you Old Town Bakery!

Our wedding cake was a 3 tier cake and each tier was a different flavor. The cake, every tier, was so yummy and delicious. Our cake topper was quite heavy and I don't know how they managed to make it stay without the cake crumbling to pieces but they did. They were so easy to work with and not very expensive at all. The owner only works with buttercream though and refuses to do fondant for any cake.

Cake was beautiful and everyone loved it.

Neil was able to get a cupcake stand for us and bake and set up a gorgeous cupcake display for our wedding. We also had white chocolate edible seashells on the cupcakes which were a perfect touch! Our cupcakes looked and tasted great!!

Niall was amazing with our cake. He was flexible, affordable, and knowledgable. Everyone loved the cake! He delivered to the restaurant and did a great job for the price. Yummy!!

I had cupcakes and a small wedding cake from the Old Town Bakery. Niall did an awesome job of the Chinese character, double happiness, on the cake. We also had lots of compliment of the cupcakes that were moist and fluffy, and the cream was smooth and light.

Niall do have a store to run during daytime but email seemed work the best for us!

We had a cupcake tree! It was beautiful! The deserts flew off of the stand!

Very nice!