Working with Stella at New York Jewelers has been one of the unexpected joys of our engagement and wedding journey.

We met Stella shortly before we got engaged, and from the very beginning, she made us feel like more than customers. She took the time to get to know me and quickly recognized that I was drawn to vintage-inspired designs. Instead of steering me toward something off the shelf, she helped us create something that was completely my own.

Using a beautiful estate ring as inspiration, Stella worked with us to design a custom aquamarine engagement ring that perfectly captured the timeless, vintage feel I had always envisioned. It is everything I could have hoped for—and even more meaningful because it was created just for me.

Our experience was so wonderful that we returned with a pair of tanzanite stones and asked Stella to help us design custom settings for those as well. When it came time to choose our wedding bands, there was never any question where we would go.

What makes Stella exceptional is that she truly invests in her clients. She listens first, remembers what you love, and then pairs that understanding with an incredible knowledge of New York Jewelers' inventory and custom capabilities. The result is jewelry that doesn't just look beautiful—it feels deeply personal and uniquely yours.

Finding a jeweler you trust is invaluable, and we feel so fortunate to have found Stella. She has become our jeweler for life's biggest milestones, and we look forward to working with her for many years to come. We can't recommend her highly enough.

My husband was several states away from Chicago Illinois. He worked with Luke Thomas to get the perfect rings!! Just married January 5th!!!

My fiancé purchased my engagement ring from Tim Jones at New York Jewelers. He was extremely impressed with the service. He said that he visit a few different jewelers and felt like he was being ripped off the whole time. When he stepped foot into New York Jewelers, Tim was super helpful, he made my fiancé feel welcome and never once pushed him into anything. My fiancé ended up buying my engagement ring here and we will be returning to see Tim for our Wedding bangs in a few months for sure.

My husband bought my engagement ring from NYJ after 3-4 of this friends recommended them. Phil helped him find the perfect ring...Phil was very thorough, honest and most important, not pushy. Since my husband had such a great experience we decided to buy our wedding bands from them as well, which we love! They have a great selection, free ring cleanings anytime you want, resizing only takes a day or two (if not a couple of hours) and they have great customer service. Since then, we have recommended other friends and family, all who have had positive experiences!

I purchased an engagement ring which my fiancé who lives in Chicago picked out there. I subsequently spoke with salesperson via telephone and finalized purchase agreement. I bought an exquisite diamond for a great price which my fiancé had indicated that she has received many compliments.
Highly recommend

My husband bought my engagement ring from them, so we decided to go back and guy our wedding bands from them as well. Our salesperson, Simon, was very helpful in providing recommendations, and was flexible on pricing. Plus, they will clean your ring for free any time you pop in and there's valet parking.

Honest people, impeccable quality.

Ask for Barry, he's a true gentleman and will find you exactly what you're looking for.

Awesome rings/ awesome prices/ lay away

Steve at NYJ is just awesome! just see for yourself! Purchase our wedding bands there and my husband also purchased my engagement ring there. The quality you get from this jeweler is simply "off the charts"!
Definitely would be keeping Steve in the iphone contact list as the number 1 jeweler in Chicago!

My fiance went here for our engagement rings, but we went together for our bands. They are in a difficult location to deal with (in the loop) but they have valet parking!!! The service was prompt, reliable and they worked with us on prices. I love our rings. We were both happy with our service and would recommend New York Jewelers for others.