Sue of Ms. Buttercup Cakes is absolutely fantastic. We're so happy that we found her and had her as our baker for our 11.27.2021 wedding. We knew that we wanted a small wedding cake with cupcakes, but we struggled to find a baker with great tasting cake that didn't feel/taste like it was made in bulk. Sue's cakes are so tasty, and you can tell that they are made with love just for you. All of our guests raved about how tasty the cupcakes were. They were super moist and adorable. Our little cake was also delicious too! Working with Sue was a pleasure from start to finish. We highly recommend her to be a part of your special day! :)

Ms. Buttercup Cake did a great job with our wedding cake. The design was classic and elegant and the cake tasted delicious!

Sue was absolutely amazing! Always prompt answering and my wedding cake was phenomenal!! And tasted just as good as it looked!!

Sue came highly recommended by our wedding venue, and I’m so glad we picked her as our baker! She makes extremely high quality desserts at very affordable prices.

We opted for cupcakes rather than the traditional three-tiered wedding cake, so Sue whipped us up some delicious samples featuring homemade fruit fillings and rich frosting. The strawberry with champagne frosting was my favorite, followed by blueberry and lemon.

To accommodate our vision for how the cupcakes would be displayed, Sue went out of her way to buy a new circular tower and get ribbon to match our wedding colors. The result was an impeccably designed table of delicious treats that our guests loved. To top it off, Sue offered to make us a small, fresh cake for our one-year anniversary rather than have us eat something that had been freezer-burned for months. Talk about sweet :).

A helpful note for brides-to-be: Sue operates out of her house and we were a bit confused by the absence of a storefront when we first drove to Rehoboth to check out Ms. Buttercup Cakes, so keep that in mind and definitely call ahead of your visit!