x9 Award winner
Award winner thanks to recommendations from couples on WeddingWire.com.
- 2026
- 2025
- 2023
- 2022
- 2021
- 2020
- 2019
- 2018
- 2017
Crispin Hill
Interested in this vendor?
1/165
"We cannot say enough good things about Crispin Hill and its incredible owners, Chelsey and Heather...."
"Our wedding at Crispin Hill was a dream come true! Chelsey and Heather were the best to work with in..."
Why couples loved this venue
- Quality catering
- Guests comfort
- Amenities
About this venue
Located near the world-renowned Finger Lakes, Crispin Hill is the perfect barn wedding venue in Penn Yan, New York. The 100-year-old barn maintains a truly unique feel and timeless history. It sits overlooking the beautiful Keuka Lake, which is a flawless backdrop to any special event.
Facilities and Capacity
The barn has a variety of spaces to move between on the property including the Crispin Barn, the farm house, and stone patio. The barn and patio can serve a maximum occupancy of 175 guests. . If you rent the space for the barn venue, you have the option to the farm house with accommodations for up to 10 guests. This is perfect for bridal parties or close friends and family the weekend of your special day.
Services Offered
In addition to a breathtaking venue, Crispin Hill offers couples on-site catering, which is managed by their executive chef and co-owner, Heather. She is an accomplished graduate of the Culinary Institute of America. In addition to delectible on-site catering, fellow co-owner Chelsey provides bridal coordination services for the extent of your planning experience to ensure that everything goes to plan on your big day. Together, they make a great team to make your event as stress-free as possible.
Cuisine
There is a wide range of cuisine packages to fit various budgets and needs. Each package is completely customizable to meet your individual tastes and dietary requirements. All packages come with access to an open bar, an artisanal cheese board, a crudite board, a plated salad and dinner, and an end-of-the-night coffee station. Upgraded packages include a champagne toast and your choice of four passed hors d'oeuvres. Three plated dinner options can be selected and each is served with roasted asparagus and one additional side. All food is made fresh for your event, so you know you’re getting an unforgettable meal on an unforgettable day.
What You'll Love About Crispin Hill
Couples love this venue for the amazing support they provide the whole planning process. They appreciate just how much the venue has to offer and how much they work to ensure a smooth flow on the big day. To learn more about the setting and gorgeous views, check out the gallery.
Experience
-
11 years in business
-
We speak English
Weddings at this venue
Veronica & Michael
52 photos
Messages sent successfully.
Bundle and save time!
Contact Crispin Hill and their preferred vendors
-
Crispin Hill -
Wonder in Adagio -
Brandon Vick Photography -
The DJ Duo
FAQ
Do you have a site fee for wedding receptions at your venue?
Yes
What is the starting site fee for wedding receptions during peak season?
$4,000
What is the starting site fee for wedding receptions during off-peak season?
$4,000
Do you have a site fee for wedding ceremonies at your venue?
Yes
What is the starting site fee for wedding ceremonies during peak season?
$500
What is the starting site fee for wedding ceremonies during off-peak season?
$500
Which of the following are included in the starting site fee?
Bridal Suite
Chairs
China
Clean Up
Event Planning
Flatware
Glassware
Lighting/Sound
Linens
Parking
Set Up
Tables
Which of the following are included in the cost of wedding catering?
Cake Cutting
Dessert
What is the starting price per person for bar service?
$30
Which of the following are included in the starting price for bar service?
Bartender(s)
Champagne Toast
House Beer
House Wine
Limited Bar
Open Bar
Premium Liquor
Signature Drink
Specialty Beer
Specialty Wine
What is the minimum number of guests required to book your venue?
80
How many event spaces or rooms does your venue offer?
Lounge, Ceremony Space, Tent & Barn
Describe your venue:
Ballroom
Farm/Ranch
Garden
Historic Building
What kind of settings are available?
Indoor
Covered Outdoor
Uncovered Outdoor
Which of the following wedding events does your venue service?
Ceremony
Reception
Bridal Shower
Engagement Party
What event services do you offer?
Accommodations
Clean Up
Event Planner
Event Rentals
Get Ready Rooms
What catering services do you offer?
Cocktail Reception
Hors d'oeuvres
Outside Cake
Plated
Server(s)
Tastings
What bar services do you provide?
Bartender(s)
Cash Bar
Champagne Toast
House Liquor
Liquor License
Open Bar
Premium Liquor
Signature Drink
Specialty Beer
Specialty Wine
What event items are available?
Altar/Arch
Chairs
Dance Floor
Decor
Furniture
Lighting
Tables
Tents
Tent Accessories
What food and beverage items are available?
Barware
China
Flatware
Glassware
Linens
What transportation and access is available?
Parking
Shuttle
Wheelchair Access
What months are included in your peak season?
May
June
July
August
September
October
What months are included in your off-peak season?
April
November
Still have questions?
Reach out about anything you didn't see answered here—no question is too small!
Reviews of Crispin Hill
This AI-generated summary gives you a snapshot of the overall ratings and feedback from the reviews this vendor has received.
Review summary
Powered by AI
Crispin Hill receives glowing reviews from happy couples who had dream wedding experiences at the venue. The staff, including Chelsey, Heather, and Jenna, are highly praised for their exceptional service, organization, and attention to detail. Guests also rave about the delicious food served by Chef Heather. The beautiful lake views and well-maintained property offer stunning backdrops for ceremonies and photos, making Crispin Hill a highly recommended wedding venue known for exceeding expectations and creating unforgettable moments for couples and guests alike.
Weddingwire
99 reviews
Google
113 reviews
Morgan Sent on 11/21/2025
5 out of 5 rating
A Beautiful Venue with Truly Exceptional Owners
We cannot say enough good things about Crispin Hill and its incredible owners, Chelsey and Heather. From start to finish, they exceeded every expectation and made our wedding day seamless, beautiful, and unforgettable.
Heather is the chef and is exceptional at every part of it. If you get married here, your guests will undoubtedly rave about the food. She also gave us our initial tour of Crispin Hill, which immediately sold us on the property.
Chelsey, handles everything besides the food and bar, answering all planning questions, leading the rehearsal, and serving as the day of coordinator. Throughout the entire planning process, she was the most responsive and organized vendor we worked with (and we had an amazing vendor team overall). Crispin Hill has every detail thought out, and when you’re planning a big wedding with endless decisions to make, their structure and documentation are such a gift.
The venue has incredible lake views (honestly better than being right on the lake), and the entire property is meticulously maintained. We have photos by the hydrangea bushes that look absolutely perfect. There are endless spots on the property for amazing photos, which was a huge perk.
During the reception, a staff member named Jenna, checked in on us and our immediate family. She brought us drinks, water, and even found my flats when I needed to change. It’s those small touches that make the whole experience feel elevated and personal. We felt totally taken care of.
Crispin Hill impressed us from the very beginning and continued to exceed our expectations all the way through the big day. Crispin Hill is the place if you want a beautiful venue run by people who truly care and a wedding day that feels effortless.
Heather is the chef and is exceptional at every part of it. If you get married here, your guests will undoubtedly rave about the food. She also gave us our initial tour of Crispin Hill, which immediately sold us on the property.
Chelsey, handles everything besides the food and bar, answering all planning questions, leading the rehearsal, and serving as the day of coordinator. Throughout the entire planning process, she was the most responsive and organized vendor we worked with (and we had an amazing vendor team overall). Crispin Hill has every detail thought out, and when you’re planning a big wedding with endless decisions to make, their structure and documentation are such a gift.
The venue has incredible lake views (honestly better than being right on the lake), and the entire property is meticulously maintained. We have photos by the hydrangea bushes that look absolutely perfect. There are endless spots on the property for amazing photos, which was a huge perk.
During the reception, a staff member named Jenna, checked in on us and our immediate family. She brought us drinks, water, and even found my flats when I needed to change. It’s those small touches that make the whole experience feel elevated and personal. We felt totally taken care of.
Crispin Hill impressed us from the very beginning and continued to exceed our expectations all the way through the big day. Crispin Hill is the place if you want a beautiful venue run by people who truly care and a wedding day that feels effortless.
Danielle Sent on 11/23/2025
5 out of 5 rating
The best day of our lives!
Our wedding at Crispin Hill was a dream come true! Chelsey and Heather were the best to work with in the planning process, giving us all the tools we needed to make everything organized and go so smooth. Everything there was absolutely stunning! The food was some of the best things we have ever had and our guests continue to rave about the experience. They were able to accommodate our dietary needs and even do so for our guests so everyone could enjoy our day with full bellies. The staff was literally the best people we have ever experienced in our life, we felt like royalty all day. Everywhere I turned, someone was there to help me and making sure everything we needed was done including food and drinks brought to you as you enjoyed your family and friends. The staff treated us and our guests like family all day long. Everything about Crispin Hill was exactly how we envisioned it and worth every penny we spent. The only thing I wish we could have more of was time. When everything was done we were so sad that it went so fast! I would recommend this wedding venue to anyone and everyone. I wish we could do it all over again!
Emily Sent on 09/07/2025
5 out of 5 rating
Best wedding venue in the Finger Lakes!!!
Crispin Hill is well known to be an incredible wedding venue, and after experiencing it as a bride I can attest it is even better than what you hear and read about! From the organization, planning, and recommended vendors to the amazing food and service on your wedding day… it is unmatched!! We lost count of the amount of guests who said it was the best wedding they have ever been to! Chelsey & Heather do an awesome job and they have the best staff!
Emma Sent on 08/24/2025
5 out of 5 rating
Crispin Hill is the best!!
We are so thankful that we chose Crispin Hill for our wedding venue! The venue is stunning and Keuka Lake was the perfect backdrop for our ceremony. Chelsey and Heather do such an amazing job at Crispin Hill, are extremely organized, and make your day feel so special. The staff was also so attentive all night and the food was incredible. I have nothing but good things to say about Crispin Hill and would chose it again as my wedding venue in a heartbeat.
Baylee Sent on 08/17/2025
5 out of 5 rating
Wedding of our dreams
Crispin Hill was the venue of our dreams and they did not disappoint!! The cost felt incredibly fair for the current market. Price was per plate for guests for food and drink based on the package you want to choose, and then they offer optional add-ons (things like renting additional spaces on-site and champagne toasts etc). Because of the cost flexibility, we were able to get everything we wanted without going over budget for things we didn’t feel like we needed.
The preferred vendor list Crispin provides was sooo helpful. Every vendor we chose had worked at the venue before, which is the most underrated benefit. They all already knew where to go and what to do so we never had to worry about anything.
The owners were kind, responsive and very understanding of special circumstances. The staff was extremely friendly and helpful too! Special shout-out to Chris on the golf cart who brought us around the venue since my husband tore his achilles just weeks before our wedding. And another shoutout to Jenna who was always making sure we had drinks! Our guests also only had amazing things to say about all of their interactions.
The food was comparable to a high end restaurant. Perfectly cooked steak, chicken and salmon. The appetizers were a huge hit too!!
Pictures don’t even do this place justice either. It’s absolutely gorgeous. We also had an abnormally hot day, and besides some extra sweating during the ceremony for the wedding party (guests had large umbrellas provided by venue too!!), everyone was able to stay cool and hydrated. Plus the barn really cools down at night with the windows and fans!
We truly had no complaints and would HIGHLY recommend this venue to everyone!!
(We don’t have wedding photos back yet to share but we just couldn’t want to give a review!)
The preferred vendor list Crispin provides was sooo helpful. Every vendor we chose had worked at the venue before, which is the most underrated benefit. They all already knew where to go and what to do so we never had to worry about anything.
The owners were kind, responsive and very understanding of special circumstances. The staff was extremely friendly and helpful too! Special shout-out to Chris on the golf cart who brought us around the venue since my husband tore his achilles just weeks before our wedding. And another shoutout to Jenna who was always making sure we had drinks! Our guests also only had amazing things to say about all of their interactions.
The food was comparable to a high end restaurant. Perfectly cooked steak, chicken and salmon. The appetizers were a huge hit too!!
Pictures don’t even do this place justice either. It’s absolutely gorgeous. We also had an abnormally hot day, and besides some extra sweating during the ceremony for the wedding party (guests had large umbrellas provided by venue too!!), everyone was able to stay cool and hydrated. Plus the barn really cools down at night with the windows and fans!
We truly had no complaints and would HIGHLY recommend this venue to everyone!!
(We don’t have wedding photos back yet to share but we just couldn’t want to give a review!)
Kelly Sent on 08/11/2025
5 out of 5 rating
Fabulous July 2025 Wedding
I helped plan my daughter's wedding at Crispin Hill in July of 2025. Chelsey and Heather are fabulous to work with. They are very organized, yet flexible and accommodating within that structure. We had plenty of opportunity to make choices and customize the wedding throughout the planning process. The venue is incredibly beautiful. We used the whole property- the farmhouse, lounge, ceremony site and reception spaces. They were all gorgeous! Both Heather and Chelsey are on site throughout the wedding day. As the MOB, I felt like I was free to enjoy the day and focus on the wedding as all of the details were being handled! The wedding and reception exceeded our high expectations and I highly recommend Crispin Hill.
Glyn Sent on 07/25/2025
5 out of 5 rating
Best venue ever!!!
Our experience at Crispin Hill exceeded every expectation we could think of. From our first day touring the venue to the day of the wedding, Chelsey and Heather made us feel comfortable, organized, and excited for the big day. We feel so grateful to Chelsey and Heather that they helped alleviate that stress through their organized checklist and hands-on coordination (and amazing responsiveness). Chelsey was also able to wrangle and organize a very excited and rowdy bridal party moments before the ceremony. The planner book was exceptionally helpful in planning a wedding with busy work schedules/ lives. The vendor list included within the book was also a huge help. Not to mention the vendors are extremely familiar with the venue, which resulted in a seamless day.
The venue itself is in a beautiful location, with plenty of spectacular views and opportunities for scenic photos. The set-up for the ceremony is picture perfect, with a backdrop of the lake for all in attendance. The indoor and outdoor areas provide a great balance for all guests.
The day-of service was excellent- every single staff member went out of their way to accommodate us, in addition to our guests. They were so friendly and helpful and truly helped to make our day incredible. We felt like celebrities! There were certain moments of the day that we were told would be private to the two of us (right after the ceremony, final private dance) – and those moments were just that. The staff was so incredibly respectful of our day and the little moments to be shared between us. It was the perfect balance of moments of just the two of us with periodic check-ins, making sure we both felt attended to and taken care of, along with the best party ever.
The food was also outstanding- we received SO many compliments from guests. Not to mention the option of buffalo chicken dip for the cocktail hour was a huge hit! Our signature drinks (Spicy Margarita and Red Wine Sangria) were both delicious, with a wide variety of options in between.
The work and love that Chelsey and Heather have put into Crispin Hill shows in the most beautiful way. Could not recommend more!!
The venue itself is in a beautiful location, with plenty of spectacular views and opportunities for scenic photos. The set-up for the ceremony is picture perfect, with a backdrop of the lake for all in attendance. The indoor and outdoor areas provide a great balance for all guests.
The day-of service was excellent- every single staff member went out of their way to accommodate us, in addition to our guests. They were so friendly and helpful and truly helped to make our day incredible. We felt like celebrities! There were certain moments of the day that we were told would be private to the two of us (right after the ceremony, final private dance) – and those moments were just that. The staff was so incredibly respectful of our day and the little moments to be shared between us. It was the perfect balance of moments of just the two of us with periodic check-ins, making sure we both felt attended to and taken care of, along with the best party ever.
The food was also outstanding- we received SO many compliments from guests. Not to mention the option of buffalo chicken dip for the cocktail hour was a huge hit! Our signature drinks (Spicy Margarita and Red Wine Sangria) were both delicious, with a wide variety of options in between.
The work and love that Chelsey and Heather have put into Crispin Hill shows in the most beautiful way. Could not recommend more!!
We're all about trust. Our community relies on honest reviews to help you make those big decisions with ease.
Awards
Are you interested?
Team
Chelsey Madia
Owner
Heather Tompkins
Chef-Owner
Professional Network & Endorsements
Wonder in Adagio
5.0 out of 5 rating , 60 reviews
·
Wedding Photographers 
Brandon Vick Photography
5.0 out of 5 rating , 7 reviews
·
Wedding Photographers 
The DJ Duo
5.0 out of 5 rating , 29 reviews
·
Wedding DJs 
Foote Florals LLC
4.8 out of 5 rating , 25 reviews
·
Wedding Florists 
Megan Antalek Photography
5.0 out of 5 rating , 60 reviews
·
Wedding Photographers 
In Bloom Florals
5.0 out of 5 rating , 75 reviews
·
Wedding Florists Map
Location
Schedule a visit
Get an in-person vibe check and have your questions answered in real time.
Why use Weddingwire to message vendors?
- Messaging our verified vendors on WeddingWire is complimentary, safe, and secure.
- Effortlessly manage vendor communications and planning details in one centralized location.
- Our mobile apps ensure you can stay connected with vendors anytime, anywhere.
- For customized pricing and package information, messaging the vendor directly is the quickest way to get the details you need.
Crispin Hill frequently asked questions
Crispin Hill includes the following items and services for wedding events in its starting site fee:
- Bridal Suite
- Chairs
- China
- Clean Up
- Event Planning
- Flatware
- Glassware
- Lighting/Sound
- Linens
- Parking
- Set Up
- Tables
Crispin Hill includes the following items and services in its wedding catering costs:
- Cake Cutting
- Dessert
The bar service starting price at Crispin Hill includes:
- Bartender(s)
- Champagne Toast
- House Beer
- House Wine
- Limited Bar
- Open Bar
- Premium Liquor
- Signature Drink
- Specialty Beer
- Specialty Wine
The space offered by Crispin Hill for wedding events is known for:
- Ballroom
- Farm/Ranch
- Garden
- Historic Building
Crispin Hill offers the following indoor/outdoor options for weddings:
- Indoor
- Covered Outdoor
- Uncovered Outdoor
Crispin Hill offers the following types of wedding events:
- Ceremony
- Reception
- Bridal Shower
- Engagement Party
Crispin Hill offers the following services for wedding events:
- Accommodations
- Clean Up
- Event Planner
- Event Rentals
- Get Ready Rooms
Crispin Hill offers the following furniture and decor items for weddings:
- Altar/Arch
- Chairs
- Dance Floor
- Decor
- Furniture
- Lighting
- Tables
- Tents
- Tent Accessories
Crispin Hill is recommended by 100% of couples who have used their services. Their overall rating is 5.0, with the same score awarded for quality of service, flexibility, value, professionalism and average response time.