I've ordered cakes from CCB twice: once for my vegan mother's birthday (vanilla/vanilla), and once for my wedding (carrot/cream cheese). The wedding cake, it should be noted, was just a regular cake-- I didn't have them do anything special with it, as we had a "cake bar" instead of a traditional wedding cake.
They were great to work with, if at time difficult to get a hold of. The staff is very small, so sometimes the phone goes unanswered and it can take a day or two to get your email returned, but your persistence will be rewarded. They were very polite and eager to give me a great experience each time. I was able to pay in advance and have someone else pick up the cake, which was awesome.
The best part was the cake itself. No one at my wedding knew the carrot cake was vegan (I mean, other than the vegans I had made sure to tell so they could have cake), and everyone commented on how moist and delicious it was. The frosting is so rich, and you would never know it contains no actual cream cheese!
One quibble: I chose the carrot cake for my wedding after doing a tasting with a friend of mine of basically every cupcake they sell. Some of the frostings on their flavored cupcakes (thinking of the lemon and strawberry) taste very artificial to me, like they are using strong flavoring and not fruit. The strawberry frosting tasted more "pink" to us than anything else. That's the reason for the deducted star.
