Here at the Bean Counter Bakery in Shrewsbury, Massachusetts, all of our fine cakes, cupcakes, cookies, tarts,
pies, desserts, pastries and baked goods are hand made from scratch. We use only the finest and freshest premium quality, all natural ingredients to create the best combination of taste and flavor. (no preservatives or artificial flavors.)
We specialize in creating custom-designed and award winning wedding cakes, from scratch. You will be presented with a variety of classic and specialty flavors and fillings to choose from, and your wedding cake will be custom designed for you with the utmost attention to detail, flavor and service.
Our team of professional bakers, cake artists and pastry chefs, are committed to creating fresh, unique cakes and work together to create edible works of art and perfection, designed to exceed your expectation. Fresh, Exquisite, Elegant and Flavorful.
We also offer several other dessert options for your wedding such as Cake Pops, Cookies, Cupcakes, Grooms' Cakes, Croquembouche, Dessert Buffets, Pies and Pastries.
We can create cakes and desserts that accommodate dietary needs, such as gluten free, nut free, lactose free, and vegan.
Cake stands and cake toppers are also available for couples to add on to their order.
We offer Consultations, Private Tastings, Delivery and Custom design.
Recommended by 97% of couples
29 User photos
Stephanie · Married on 12/08/2018
Alice was confident, knowledgeable and easy to work with!
Alice is absolutely incredible. We tasted her cakes at an expo at our venue and there was absolutelf NO COMPARISON to the other bakeries. Her cakes were moisit, flavorful and the buttercream was amazing. The other cakes were dry and the creams tasted like lard that left a film in your mouth.Sent on 12/22/2018
I could not believe how well they replicated my vision! Cannot wait for our anniversary to have more!!
Laura Brewer · Married on 11/11/2018
Our cake was so delicious that the only bite we got was the one when we cut our cake! I have never been to a wedding where the guests eat all the cake but we heard for days on end after our wedding how amazing everyone thought our cake was and how they went back for seconds! By the time we got a chance to eat some, it was all gone! And not because we didn't order enough - almost everyone got seconds!Sent on 01/14/2019
They even made gluten free and vegan cupcakes for our wedding party who had allergies!
Absolutely amazing - can't wait for our anniversary cake!
Stephanie · Married on 10/07/2018
Best cake ever!
Our wedding cake from the Bean Counter was absolutely delicious. Guests were coming up to us saying it was the best wedding cake they had ever had. Not only was it delicious, it was beautiful too. We had a grooms cake made for my husband and it came out great too. It was a football with an Alabama "A" on it which is just what we wanted! Everyone from there was great to work with. Everyone should get their cake from The Bean Counter!Sent on 11/05/2018
The Bean Counter Bakery is one of the best bakeries in the Metro-West Area, our wedding packages include a cake from the Bean counter and all of our brides love the service and the cake they receive. Alice works hands on with our couples to create a customized wedding cake they always dreamed of. They also have the best gluten free alternative desserts and cakes. We highly recommend the Bean Counter to all our of clients
YUM! This sums up the wonderful cakes etc that Alice and her staff provide....
I first met Alice of The Bean Counter a few years ago at a bridal fair. Not only were her cakes delicious, creative, and beautiful, but she and her staff couldn't have been more friendly. I have referred more than a few clients and friends to them, and everyone has been delighted. One client ordered a carrot cake and raved about it so much that the next Fathers' Day, I ordered one for my father-in-law, who is a carrot-cake connoisseur always on the lookout for the best one. He can stop looking. :) I know that when I recommend Bean Counter to someone, I have nothing to worry about. My friends and clients are in the best of hands.