Skip to main content

Post content has been hidden

To unblock this content, please click here

Jamie
Devoted August 2018

Why Honeyfund's, cash requesting is bad for your bottom line (psychologically).

Jamie, on July 11, 2018 at 12:39 AM Posted in Etiquette and Advice 1 36

Alright ww family, I am going to be completely real with you. I know this discussion about asking for cash, for money for a honeymoon has always been a hot topic with much discussion and much controversy.

I am that guest you want at a wedding. Why? Because I give very generously. I am child free, make 6 figures, no debt, oh and I give anywhere from $300-800 minimum for a gift. No this isn't bragging, it's just the ideal situation for someone that has the ability to give large gifts. However, I do not give to Honeyfunds, or any other request for cash. poem. jar etc. You invite me to you wedding and dictate what I am allowed to give? You might get a nice piece of Fiesta Ware.

Why am I being hateful? I am not... I am sick of being probed for money. Every time I turn around, someone is asking me for money. I am a target for it, it's my own doing. Sometimes I give in (especially for animals), generally I don't. You want money for your honeymoon, have your MOH tell me. You want cash for a new stove, be modest and discrete. I am happy to give as much as possible to people that aren't asking me for it, with the justification that they are getting married. Sorry, lots of people get married...we can't suspend manners for us all. Lastly, I don't want to give money to some unknown company on the chance I am paying for an "experience". I work in network security, and their policies around privacy are iffy at most.

Look at it from another perspective. Your friends who are cash fund gung ho....are they giving hundreds of dollars? Or are you stuck in the $25-$50 dollar donation rut. That is the financial amount people feel "ok" to lose if a transaction goes bad (overdraft fees anyone?). Imagine how much more you would have gotten if you hadn't made a Zola cash registry a choice. TBH I had never heard of Zola before all this. As a guest, I certainly would not have given them money to be transferred to you.

36 Comments

Latest activity by K&M, on July 15, 2018 at 6:00 PM
  • Jamie
    Devoted August 2018
    Jamie ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content

    In the end, it's up to you...

    Believe me when I say, you will get more when you ask for less. People want to give generously, but they want to feel it's their choice. It's their idea.

    I have yet to see a bride or groom report a Honeyfund that offset their honeymoon costs....most have been a few hundred bucks at most. Think on that before you send your invites. How much did you lose because you felt the need to ask something that was a given. Cash is always welcome, no need to ask for it twice.

    • Reply
  • E
    Dedicated August 2018
    Elizabeth ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    Wow, I hadn't thought of it that way... thank you
    • Reply
  • Catti Labelle
    VIP July 2018
    Catti Labelle ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    Perfect post....10/10.

    We had small registries in relation to our invited count and most gifts were purchased for my shower. There were only a few gifts left by the time my wedding rolled around and we received almost all cash and checks. We didn’t beg, didn’t virtually stick our hands out, and we were gifted....a LOT. Was it enough to break even? Not even close, but let’s just say it’s way more than the cost of our honeymoon including projected expenses for when we’re there. With that said I married into a large Italian family and apparently they go all out for weddings, so I’m not sure if our situation is unique to cultures who do give cash instead of physical gifts.

    No matter the culture though, money is always a great gift and everyone knows that. No need to ask!
    • Reply
  • M
    Dedicated October 2018
    M ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment

    I agree totally. Just wondering what you do for people that don't have registries at all? Do you think that it's obvious they want cash or that they genuinely don't expect gifts?

    We aren't do any kind of registry at all due to DW. We do not expect any gifts from anyone but at the same time obviously wouldn't so no to a card with cash if people REALLY wanted to give us something. Where we are from no one gives physical gifts for a wedding anyway....

    • Reply
  • J
    Just Said Yes December 2018
    Jillian ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    Love this perspective.
    what are your thoughts on not registering at all?

    I’ve been having this debate with my fiancé. We’re already established and don’t necessarily need much. After the wedding, we’re saving up to do home improvements and start a family so obviously money would be the ideal gift (but not expected). Is it rude to not register at all?
    • Reply
  • NikNak
    Master September 2018
    NikNak ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    I have tried explaining this so many times, well said, if I could 'like' your post, I would.
    • Reply
  • Jamie
    Devoted August 2018
    Jamie ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment
    My FSIL recently got married, she had a small registry but we asked FMIL and MOH what they really wanted (honeymoon to Greece) so we gave a large contribution. Guests ask your wedding party and your family what you want if there is a small or no registry, just let them know. Let them spread the word. I was much happier giving her a large sum that she didn't ask for directly.

    • Reply
  • Jamie
    Devoted August 2018
    Jamie ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment
    FH and I have no registry. We will welcome any gift or none. However if you have goal in mind, let your family and MOH know. People ask family and the wedding party what to gift. Especially for when there is a small registry that is already bought out. Just inform them, if anyone asks for a gift idea...we are saving toward home improvements.
    • Reply
  • amandaaok
    VIP June 2018
    amandaaok ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    Sorry, this is not 100% true having just experienced it at my own wedding...you can choose to be offended by it or choose to gift as you normally would, that is up to you. But depending on your social/family circle, your post is not 100% true gospel.

    There are PLENTY of people who DO NOT automatically give cash/check as a gift in ANY amount (I am one of them, whereas my Hubs would just give cash). There are also plenty of people who give no gift at all and plenty of people who will only gift if there is an actual registry.

    My wedding was just over 2 weeks ago, Hubby's family insisted on a honeymoon registry and created it long after STD and invites went out.

    We did not advertise it, but those who asked if one existed, we told them yes and where. By far and away those who knew about the registry used it exclusively (no gift was given under $100 through it) and noted how excited they were about it. We had 6 people out of 42 couples who actually gave us a physical card with either a small amount of cash or a check at the wedding AND THAT WAS IT. No other gifts received.
    We are fine with it, we didn't originally have a registry and really just wanted our nearest and desrest there to celebrate us.
    However that being said, it was very clear to us that had we had a registry of any kind to begin with and given everyone the information about the registry (even after being created) it would have been used.

    My point is, know your guests, then make a judgement call.
    • Reply
  • T
    Super December 2018
    T P ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment
    Well said!
    • Reply
  • Jamie
    Devoted August 2018
    Jamie ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment
    You missed the point. 100%. If a family created and curated a honeyfund for you, that is their gift, their choice.
    Tell me how much did you miss out on because people found out, found it distasteful, decided not to gift?

    True, some people don't gift at all, some people only gift if they aren't spending anything of their own at the wedding (e.g. cash bar, wishing wells, DW), some people only give physical gifts, some only give cash.

    At this point you will never know because you made your choice. I am only posting the perspective as a guest to many many weddings.
    • Reply
  • Lauren
    Dedicated August 2018
    Lauren ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    The last wedding I went to was a sweet missionary couple. They mostly live in Honduras. They couldnt travel back home with a bunch of gifts. They beautifully worded their situation and simply said that they covet the prayers of their loved ones. But many people kept asking them what they could do
    so they added three sections to their wedding site. A fund to buy the bare necessities of what they needed while in Honduras, a fund for their organization/missionary work, and a fund for the delayed honeymoon they are saving up for. It was done perfectly. However, it is really the only one I’ve seen done in a way that doesn’t make me NOT want to give someone cash.
    • Reply
  • Swtnss238
    VIP May 2019
    Swtnss238 ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    Oh my goodness!!! To each their own!! Ur life, ur wedding, ur choices!!!
    • Reply
  • amandaaok
    VIP June 2018
    amandaaok ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment
    Oh no, your point was quite clear; you detest them and are even willing to hold back a more generous gift from a couple at there mere idea of them having a registry you do not agree with.


    Whether I made it or his family made it or an alien created it does not matter - the fact that OTHER people used it upon hearing of its existence, my friends/family and his alike, including some who could not attend the wedding, were excited about it and more than generous and kind is what matters.

    That in and of itself shows that your reaction and opinio does not make it true for *all guests* of a wedding, which was my point.

    You didn't post "the perspective as a guest" , you posted *your* perspective as a guest, which is not every guests perspective.
    • Reply
  • C
    Devoted April 2019
    Cheyenne ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    It doesn't offend me. I look at it as a form of honesty. They'd prefer cash over physical gifts that they'd return or never use! But you feel how you feel and that's okay to.
    • Reply
  • StephanieLuna
    Devoted December 2018
    StephanieLuna ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    This doesn't offend me either. I wouldn't dare ask money from anyone, but other people? Who. Cares. I also don't get why you would snub on the gift out of spite. Not someone I would want at my wedding anyway. Go ahead and send in the ugly dish, if it's a perfect reflection of your taste? If you got it, give it. You don't want to? Don't.
    • Reply
  • Alforev
    VIP August 2018
    Alforev ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    This was an excellent post that gives the other prospective! One of my bridesmaids actually brought up to me recently how upset she was because the other bridesmaids told her she had to give cash for the wedding. She came to me asking what I wanted because she said she couldn’t afford to give me much for the bridal shower and had a gift she wants to give me for the wedding. I was stunned that she asked me and my response was “I want for you to show up and stand by my side as I marry the man I love. You’re my friend and I just want you there with me.” She felt a lot better hearing that. I feel like money is such a touchy thing and you should never invite people thinking to make money off of them. I also think it’s incredibly rude in general to ask people for money. In my opinion, register for the gifts you really want only or don’t register at all and just enjoy spending time with those you love.
    Just also don’t make the mistake like I did of putting things in your registry you don’t really need... someone ended up buying me the $6 ramekins I had on mine and while I appreciate the fact that they got me anything, I couldn’t help but feel silly when I realized I didn’t even need the ramekins and just had them in there for those on a budget. Now this guest can’t wait for me to make cakes in these ramekins, and the ramekins are about two inches in diameter so it’s a bit awkward. 🤷🏼‍♀️
    • Reply
  • Priscilla
    Devoted August 2018
    Priscilla ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment
    Very true. Everyone is different and every culture is different.
    • Reply
  • themost
    Dedicated October 2021
    themost ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment
    As a guest to many, many weddings myself, I respectfully disagree with your opinion, and don't have any problem contributing to a fund, whether it be for a honeymoon or home improvement. Nor would I feel offended that the couple is implying what I should be gifting them or withhold a gift or give a smaller amount because I felt slighted.

    Your opinion on the matter is precisely that... one of many opinions on the matter. Please don't presume that your opinion is the only one that counts.
    • Reply
  • shannon.sv
    Devoted July 2021
    shannon.sv ·
    • Flag
    • Hide content
    View Quoted Comment

    This is how I feel! My FH and I already have a home (and just about everything you need to have in a home) so we may put a couple of things on a registry like pots/pans, but we are totally fine with cash that we can use for our honeymoon or for starting a family. I think most people want to give the couple what they really want and if they know that it's money, they are willing to do it.

    • Reply

You voted for . Add a comment 👇

×
WeddingWire celebrates love ...and so does everyone on our site! Explore how we embrace diversity

Groups

WeddingWire article topics