Which bridesmaid / maid of honor combo

Definitely the purple/pink combination! I'm not a fan of the purple and red

For these specific shades, the purple pink combo is better because they both are jewel colors, have similar cool undertones, and are roughly similar in luminosity (brightness). The red shade is too dark and rich to go with that shade of purple. If you wanted to do purple and red you'd need a darker purple to go with it. The purple and red shown here actually clash and do not look good together IMO.

The second combo looks better at least on my screen because the fabrics look the same. In the top combo, the purple fabric looks way too shiny compared to the matteness of the red dress's fabric.

Oh gotcha! I think a lot of people are confused.

In terms of style, I think you can mix and match any of the above. If the fabric and silhouettes are similar, I don't think the neckline matters all that much. I'd go with whatever your MOH/maids are most comfortable with. Maybe let your MOH get first pick and then have your bridesmaids vote on which one of the remaining two they all want to wear.

I like the second grouping better! The tops make more sense and coordinate better since both have straps that touch the neckline.

I think both necklines work well together!! Have your bridesmaids tried them on or expressed a preference for either style?

Hey Jasmin! Good news is they are both gorgeous so you can't go wrong but I totally see what your'e saying and agree that the fuchsia doesn't match the clean structure and lines of the MOH dress style. If that's super important to you then def switch. BUT the fuchsia style has perks like being bra-friendly and rouching is usually a figure-flattering detail so could be a winner for more body shapes. But honestly, both are lovely! And in a pale pink a little ruffle/texture might be a nice mix-up. Wait... am I changing my mind now? I think I'm on team fuchsia now lol. Good luck!