Too much Makeup??? (Pics)

You look great, don't change a thing!

I dont thinks it too bad...maybe u just need a bit more natural tones like in ur pictures so u wont look so overdone, but makeup still looks amazing!!

Against a pure white dress, I think you need to have that extra layer (at least I do). I think your makeup looks beautiful, maybe changing the eyeshadow to a lighter color could lighten up the look a bit?

Can I be honest with you? I was looking at your pictures, and I think your make up in the picture where you were wearing the orange dress. I think that looks pretty and really natural. I think something like that for your wedding day would be absolutely beautiful! =)

The only thing that I see why she may have said that is that the blush wasn't blended that well (IMO) or the shade of blush used wasn't the right one. Other than that I think its fine and won't look overdone or look like you have on alot of make up

Forgot to mention it before, but I literally had the same issue with my makeup/makeup artist. The first trial we did looked great and very glamorous-I had severnal girlfriends say they like it. But, then I saw my fh and he didnt like-or at least not for the wedding. he felt it looked hot, but hot like I was going to a night club instead of getting married boys....Anyways, so I explained it to my makeup artist, we went and did another trial and came up with a way to do a very similar glamorous look that was just toned down a bit. And mainly for me (and I have dark hair and eyes like you do) it was the eye liner on the bottom of my lids that changed everything. Seriously, we made the eye shadow a little lighter than before, but I was amazed at what a difference just not having eye liner on the bottom of my lid did. not saying thats it for you-but there could easily just be one small detail that if it were less or lighter could change the whole look!